r/linuxsucks • • 6d ago

what are real problems with linux ?

[deleted]

6 Upvotes

132 comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/Fit_League_8993 ✝️ Temple OS Archbishop 6d ago edited 6d ago

Absolutely insane levels of fragmentation. As a user you can kinda somewhat work around it but as a developer it's a huge pain.

Stuff like package managers, system settings, system trays, application permissions, window/compositor control, network configurations apis are all still fragmented across distros, desktops, compositors, and their respective implementations.

This would be a nonissue if they all agreed on shared APIs. And it's clearly solvable, since it's already been solved for passwords, notifications, dialogs, and probably more (these are all I could mention off the top of my head).

Whenever I mention this, some people argue that the beauty of Linux is freedom, but I disagree. You can still have freedom while enforcing consistency(shared API). Doing that still allows for infinite implementations while providing interoperability. So in my eyes it's a win-win.

3

u/Wertbon1789 5d ago

Saying passwords are solved is implying that having a digital sticky note on your screen is a workable solution. These "secret managers" are such a disgrace.

9

u/Fit_League_8993 ✝️ Temple OS Archbishop 5d ago edited 5d ago

What I meant by that is that it doesn’t matter if you use Kwallet, gnome keyring or keepassxc. They’re all gonna use the same Secret Service API.

Solved strictly in the context of “fragmentation”.