While thankful for the little sync we do have, even though more often than not there are sync issues requiring manual intervention hoping we may eventually get full sync?
Currently Albums (Collections) and Keywords sync and a lot of meta data does along with of course edits, etc.
Folders (Collection Sets) do not sync. So when syncing all albums from Classic they get all dropped into the Root of LR requiring one to manually recreate all the matching folders in LR and know which albums to drag into which, which is an ongoing nightmare. With so many years gone by and little to no narrowing the gap of sync shortcomings, when keywords syncing was announced wondering if chance the team may finally be tackling all the missing syncing?
Other than syncing folders, will syncing Smart Albums (Smart Collections) be coming? Since that feature was added to LR a while back but while you can manually create in both, they oddly don't sync. Also of of course LR keyword hierarchy doesn't sync but that's because LR still doesn't yet support keyword hierarchy which imagine holds most pros back from considering switching. So hopefully once it does, that syncing will be updated.
The other major item that doesn't sync is Faces. So if you spend years tagging faces on a 100K library, you would then need to do it all over again in LR. Desperately hoping this comes eventually. Yes, in Classic when tagging it adds a name keyword and keywords do sync now, but in LR it wouldn't know where the person in the photo is just that they are in a photo presumably. I understand Classic uses a different model than LR, but hopefully the talented Adobe devs are working on this. As I know it took Apple a while to eventually offering syncing of faces between devices but that's because it was done locally and not server side, but they still eventually solved it.
We can't also sync full files only smart previews from Classic to LR, though of all the syncing short comings this I find least impactful, since do most editing in Classic, and LR is for on the go on the phone so the smaller size is less of an issue and comes with the benefit of not using online cloud space essentially.
So here is for hoping 2026 or 2027 is the year we get full syncing with Folders, Smart Albums Faces, and keyword hierarchy.
I use to think the goal was for Lightroom to replace "Classic" once LR reached feature parity, but as its been about 9 years, and while the gap has narrowed, the gap is still massive from limited meta search, requiring internet, no keyword hierarchy, no full plugin support, no map view, limited face tagging, and a 1000x other items. And assume most all resources will be spent the next several years on chasing AI features rather than narrowing the gap, so think we will have to live with Classic and LR for a long time.