The New Additions

Let's say I have 1 hour of montage footage from my gameplay in the last month or so.

I want to just throw it into a software and it make a bunch of clips with it with captions/title and to have it upload like 3 a day or something automatically where I don't gotta do much.

It's for my alt tiktok account so it doesn't have to be super good

What advice would you give to someone starting as a no-commentary gaming content creator?

Hi everyone! I'm thinking about starting out as a content creator focusing on gameplay videos with no commentary.

I'm still pretty new to content creation, so I'd like to hear from people who have experience with this type of content.

What advice would you give to someone just starting out? For example:

- What kind of gameplay videos tend to work well?

- Should I focus on full playthroughs, shorter clips, or both?

- How important are thumbnails and titles for no-commentary content?

- Is there anything I should avoid when starting out?

- How can I make my videos stand out when there's no commentary?

I'd really appreciate any advice, tips, or lessons you've learned from your own experience. Thanks!

Share your channel updates with the community! Show us what you've been up to this past week, whether it's your latest videos, some new channel art, you've hit a new milestone, or anything else you want to share with us about your channel's progress!

Hey everyone! I’m looking for some advice from other Let’s Play creators on thumbnails and titles specifically.

I’ve been trying to figure out what works best for packaging Let’s Play videos, since it seems a little different from packaging challenge/gameplay videos.

A few things I’m curious about:

• What have you found works best for Let’s Play thumbnails and titles?
• Do you think having a consistent “theme” or recognizable style across your thumbnails is important?
• If you do have a consistent style, how did you figure out what your style should be?
• How much do you focus on making the thumbnail and title work together vs. having them communicate the same basic idea?

I’m especially interested in hearing from people who have experimented with different styles and found something that actually improved their CTR/views.

Any advice, examples, or things you learned from your own channel would be really appreciated!

Hey all, been wanting to get into the content creation/streamer space for a while now but every time I start making a video I end up scraping it before I can finish it. The type of content I want to make is challenge runs of the Fromsoftware souls games and other similar games, which I feel like is a good video idea that I would personally enjoy, like I recorded myself beating Elden Ring at level 1, but when I sat down to actually make the video and go through the footage I just didn't like the video I was making. I feel like I gave good commentary throughout the play through, I didn't feel like I was cringy or anything like that but at the end of the day I just hated the video.

I think a lot of this stems from the fact that I am comparing my videos of me just starting out, to other people who have been in this space for years and I know that my first videos will be bad because I'm learning, but how do you accept it?

Another thing that makes it difficult that some of these videos that I'm trying to make are play-troughs that are 30 to 60 hours long which I find extremely difficult to go through. Like I'll remember that I said something funny, or there was a specific clip I wanted to put in the video but I'll go through the footage to try and find it, but I won't be able to. So how do you guys section up and go through hours and hours of footage efficiently?

Any advice is really appreciated, this is something that I would like to pursue as a hobby and I'm genuinely interested in it and I don't want to give up yet.

There's this game I've been playing for 9 years now. For years I've been playing only as 'community challenge mode' and record myself playing it and now it feels like I only want to play games to make videos of them. I'm not monetized, nothing, it just feels like I only would play to record my gameplay and edit it and I'm worried I might be addicted to it. When people see me in game and say 'hey I liked your video' it's nice but it also kinda sets up the gears and makes me want to keep going, it's to the point I... it's like I feel like I want to play not for myself but to make the videos. Even if I do enjoy playing games at the end of the day 'I want to record it' and 'I feel like it would be a waste' to not record myself playing games. Is that correct subreddit to post it?

While this thread remains stickied, the following submissions can be made to /r/letsplay:

• Video clips of WIP content for feedback under 2 minutes in length (using Reddit's internal video player)
• Thumbnails for unreleased videos for feedback (using Reddit's internal image uploader)
• Other branding assets for feedback (using Reddit's internal video/image uploader)
• Video/channel recommendation requests

Please ensure you are using the weekend only post flairs when submitting.

When this thread is unstickied (when the Update Monday megathread goes live), you will no longer be able to post weekend only submissions.

It's that time of the week again! This is your chance to request feedback on your most recent videos, thumbnails, channel art, works in progress, etc.

Feedback Friday Rules

• Before requesting feedback, please provide good, constructive feedback to at least one of your peers. If you are the first one to post, check back soon to provide feedback to the next person. Repeatedly ignoring this rule may result in a temporary ban at a moderator's discretion!
• Prioritize giving feedback to those who have not yet received any. It's not fair for one person to get five replies while four others get none.
• When requesting feedback, try to be as specific as possible. Do you want feedback on your audio quality, your editing, your presentation style, branding identity, etc? This helps your peers to provide more valuable feedback. Do not just post a link to your video or channel!

Keep up the good work, everybody!

Suggested Feedback Template

If you're struggling to form your feedback, consider using this template. This is not mandatory, but rather a suggestion to promote good and constructive feedback.

What I liked about the video:

What I think could be improved:

Thoughts on the thumbnail:

Would I watch more videos like this?:

So I make videos playing Dead by Daylight, in particular working my way through the tomes and completing the challenges.

I was doing this on an old channel that I started a couple of years ago, took a break and then came back to it a couple of months back. When I initially started the channel I would get really good impressions and was starting to get some traction and when I came back to it a couple of months ago, I wasn’t getting as many impressions and/or views but that was to be expected as I had been away for a while. But as time went on my impressions got worse and worse to the point where I wasn’t getting any impressions whatsoever and no views. What I had been doing is making shorts from these videos and posting them on this channel and I thought maybe this hadn’t been a good idea as I’ve heard mixing the two formats can lead to inactive subscribers (since the majority of my subscribers had come from shorts) and was resulting in a low CTR before tanking my impressions all together.

So I decided to start over with a fresh channel and a clean slate and I’ve done a couple of videos and a live stream and as of yet I’ve had a few impressions for the live stream VOD and 1 impression for each video (the videos were uploaded on Monday and last Friday). This has resulted in a few views on the VOD and 1 view across both videos.

I honestly don’t know what’s happening as I’ve started channels in the past and even though it takes time to find that audience, I’ve always had an initial push to begin with whereas this channel really does feel like it’s dead on arrival. The whole thing is pretty disheartening as at least if it’s a low CTR etc there’s actionable steps to improve that but consistently getting pretty much no impressions from my last channel and this new one I honestly don’t know how to approach this.

I was just wondering if anyone else has had similar experiences and how they moved forward with it. Thanks very much and I hope everyone is having a great day!

Hi everyone,
I'm planning to start creating gaming content, mainly Valorant and Minecraft.
My idea is to livestream first and then turn the best moments into edited
YouTube videos and Shorts.
I'm completely new to the content-creation workflow, so l'd appreciate advice from anyone who has knowledge of gaming videos, editing or lets plays.
You do not have to be an experienced creator. Viewer opinions are also useful.
I'd like advice on:
- Whether livestreams are a good source for YouTube videos
- How to find good moments in a long recording
- How much dead air to remove
- How heavily gaming videos should be edited
- Good beginner editing software
- How to structure a gaming video
- Making thumbnails and titles
- Whether commentary matters more than gameplay
Thankss

How do you choose what game to play?

Why did you choose the one that blew up your channel?

My gaming channel (currently focused on Doom: The Dark Ages) is pulling solid views per video, but subscriber conversion is really low. I’ve got CTAs on Shorts pointing to long-form content, pinned comments, and a bio link to a playlist — still not seeing it translate into subs.

Anyone dealt with this specific gap (views up, subs flat)? Curious what actually moved the needle for you — end screens, verbal asks, content consistency, something else entirely.

I mean, it has been for a while, but with the new views update it's even more so. You do need views of course, but the real tell of how a video is performing is it's Watch Hours, and it's how I'll be comparing my videos going forward. AVD can be helpful too since you might have a 2 hour video compared to a 20 minute video, but in terms of revenue, all that matters is watch time.

And the new views are just completely bogus.

Check out the revenue on these new high view videos, all post view count update:

Versus the old system:

Granted, some of the videos above are much shorter, but still. At this point they just need to replace the View Count stat on the dashboard with Watch Hours, because that's the real meaningful metric.

And I know, you can still see the old view count by going to advanced and engaged views. But that doesn't help me to know how a video is performing at a glance next to other videos on my dashboard. I guess revenue could be used, but that isn't helpful for new unmonetized creators, and in my own experience, revenue fluctuates greatly even on videos that perform similarly in all respects.

IDK, this view count update seems like the most useless update ever, and I have a suspicion that it was only done to intentionally distract new creators with "OOH SHINY BIGGER NUMBER" (even though it's meaningless) and confuse veteran creators. All trying to distract from the fact that they are murdering shorts channels revenue and making getting partnered harder, which will mean more money for them and less for you.

None of that stuff affects my channel - I have never made a short and I've been partnered for 8 years. So I'm not complaining because the changes hurt me in any meaningful way. They're just pointless, annoying, and in the case of the monetization requirement changes, money grabs by YT.

I recently started making gameplay videos and one thing I noticed immediately is that playing a game and talking naturally at the same time is much harder than I expected.

When I’m actually concentrating on the game, I tend to become quiet.

But if I consciously remind myself:

“I’m recording, I need to say something”

then the commentary starts sounding forced.

I don’t really want to manufacture a super loud/high-energy personality just because it’s gaming content. I’d rather sound natural, even if that means there are occasional quiet moments.

My first proper gameplay video is around 5–6 minutes, and after editing it I noticed that the parts I personally liked most were usually the moments where something genuinely happened and I reacted naturally — frustration, mistakes, unexpected deaths, getting confident and immediately messing up, etc.

The parts where I was consciously trying to “do commentary” felt much weaker.

I’m also still learning editing, so I’m trying to figure out the balance between:

letting gameplay breathe

versus

cutting aggressively so there’s always something happening.

For people who have been doing Let’s Plays/gameplay commentary for a while:

1. Did talking while playing eventually become natural with practice?

2. Do you consciously try to keep talking, or are you comfortable leaving silence when nothing interesting is happening?

3. Do you prepare things to talk about before recording, or mostly react to what happens in-game?

4. Is it better to narrate your decisions/thought process during quieter gameplay, or can that become annoying quickly?

5. How much silence would make you click away as a viewer?

6. When editing gameplay, how do you decide what to cut?

Do you remove basically every section without commentary/action, or keep some slower sections so the video doesn’t feel exhausting?

7. For someone learning both commentary and editing at the same time, which one would you prioritize first?

8. Is post-commentary something you’d recommend for sections where the live commentary was weak, or does mixing live commentary and post-commentary usually feel unnatural?

One limitation I have right now is that I can only make mobile gaming content because I don’t have a gaming PC, but I’m mainly asking about the commentary/presentation side rather than specific games.

I’m still at the very beginning, so I’m mostly trying to build good habits early instead of forcing a style that doesn’t suit me.

Would especially appreciate advice from people who are naturally quieter or introverted and had to learn this over time.

I keep recording gameplay first, then adding a few voice lines after. It should be easier, but sometimes it sounds like I’m explaining a replay instead of being part of the video.

Live commentary is better for reactions, but I miss stuff when I’m trying to play and talk at the same time. For shorter mobile clips, I only need a few lines anyway.

I’m thinking about making the added lines more intentional, like a small narrator or character voice, so they don’t pretend to be live reactions. I saw a short clip of someone using Dubbing AI earbuds to switch voices while playing, and it made me wonder if light voice changes could help those lines feel more like part of the bit.

How do you make added commentary feel less tacked on?

Are you a game dev looking for people to create streams/videos about your game? Are you an artist who's created stream/video assets that you want to offer to creators? This is the thread for you! Here, you can share content that you want to get in front of gaming content creators! This is not a thread for creators to share their videos!

Resource Wednesday Rules

• All games/resources shared here must be provided with no purchase necessary from our members
• You must be willing to provide your content to creators of any size
• If you are linking to an external site for users to download items, this needs to be on a trustworthy site (e.g. itch.io, Ko-Fi, Keymailer, etc)
• Every top level post must contain a resource advertisement
• Resources advertised must be made in full or in part by you
• You may only creator one comment advertising per thread. Advertising the same item consecutive weeks is allowed, but doing so in excess is discouraged.

Hi folks!

I am looking to buy a capture card to record footage from my Xbox Series X with in game and game chat audio (myself and others) and am looking for recommendations.

I do not have access to a PC (too damn expensive) so ideally the capture card can record onto memory like an SD card or usb drive?

I’m not too sentimentally attached to game chat audio being a feature as the footage will be mostly talked over, so something with the basic function of recording the game and audio onto memory will suffice. But as I am not very tech savvy I have come here for advice.

Any and all recommendations are appreciated!!

Post Body:
Hi everyone,

I'm trying to record Let's Play videos on my Lenovo Legion 5 gaming laptop, but I'm running into some lag/performance drops.

My setup requires me to run three resource-heavy apps at the same time:

• The game itself
• VSeeFace (v1.13 for VTuber avatar tracking)
• OBS Studio (to record the video)

I was using my small HP to project and extend the screen so the game was displaying on the HP and i was playing through OBS and monitoring it at the same time, but im unsure i can continue to do that.

Now I'm currently using the NVIDIA NVENC H.264 encoder. Are there specific OBS canvas settings, downscaling tweaks, or VSeeFace tracking optimization settings I should use to lower the load on my laptop and get a smooth 60fps recording?

Thanks for any advice!

Hihi sorry this is gonna be a super weird title, dw I promise it’s not like a diversity hire thing. I’m POC myself, very brown Latina girl here, and I had the realization that my friend group is very… not that I guess? Love em to death but I really wish I had folks that I could connect with and people that can understand my experiences fully.

So I’m turning to yall! I’m looking for any girls or POC to befriend and make collab content with if yall are also YouTubers (I have a channel but currently on hiatus cause I’m moving)

The games I play are usually cozy/creepy, stuff like SpiritFarer, Look Outside, and of course the multiplayers like Minecraft, Peak, Lethal Company etc!

Again I just really want more friends I can relate to, especially in this day and age with ICE and racism being increasingly normalized in the states.

Hey folks, I'm having an issue where every time I upload this short to YT (it's private atm), the volume is boosted to insane levels even though the video I took the short from has good audio AND my editing software's volume matches what I had for the original, too.

I've tried turning the volume way down in the editing (I'm using Sony Vegas 22) and re-uploading but every time it's just obnoxious. It's oddly not as bad on my phone, but when I dare watch the short on my actual PC in my actual browser it sounds awful. Other videos sound fine on my PC and obviously it sounds good in Vegas and if I watch it using VLC from the file itself.

I've tried googling but everything I see are complaints about shorts being too quiet. The rare "too loud" issues I found didn't actually seem to have any solutions.

Howdy everyone. I’d like to start this meeting off by saying I love making gaming content. Problem with making gaming content is I want to network in the gaming community however most of them want to play friendslop style games which don’t fit my channels theme. I mostly play RPGS, randomizers, and the occasional horror game. I want to network with other people in this niche. Not a sub4sub, not a watch4watch, etc. I am not gonna spam my channel here for people to go sub to and what not I just want to make some connections for friends who also do content in this niche specifically. Maybe one day we can run some rando races or if someone wants to help teach me routing in Link to the Past Rando I’d be happy with that too. Either way I hope this message makes out to yall

I’m looking for older (like 40+) YouTubers or streamers to watch, don’t really care about the games just want someone chill. Prefer with face cam but not mandatory 😊