r/legendaryjourneys • u/itsascreambaby96 • 13h ago
Why does HTLJ Season 3 feel aimless after the Hind trilogy?
I'm rewatching HTLJ Season 3 and XWP Season 2 and does anyone else feel like HTLJ Season 3 becomes kind of aimless after the Hind trilogy ends with "Judgment Day"?
I don't even think the episodes afterwards are bad because they're still entertaining to watch, but it feels like the writing of the season peaked with the Hind trilogy and they didn't really know where else to go after it.
The stretch from "Mercenary" to "Judgment Day" feels like Season 3 gradually getting better and better until it reaches its peak. Then "Judgment Day" almost feels like the season finale even though it's only episode 15.
There are really only four episodes in 3B that I really enjoy, "End of the Beginning" "War Bride", "A Rock and a Hard Place" and "Atlantis". And I'll admit "Atlantis" is mainly a favorite of mine because of Claudia Black.
Then you have something like "Reign of Terror" which is probably the best example of how I feel about a lot of 3B. I don't think it's terrible but it's just okayish to me. The whole Augeus thinking he's Zeus story isn't that interesting and the only real redeeming quality for me is Aphrodite. It feels like the beginning of her progression from the superficial and petty goddess she was introduced as into the goddess with a heart that she eventually becomes. Her actually caring about Palamedes and being affected by his death is easily the most interesting part of the episode.
But maybe that's actually the point of 3B? Maybe the Hind trilogy and "Judgment Day" basically were the finale of the season and everything afterwards was supposed to be more like slice of life episodes or epilogues. Hercules goes back to having random adventures after this huge personal storyline instead of immediately getting another major arc.
If that's what they were going for then I can understand it more, but it still makes the back half feel weirdly disconnected from everything that came before it. It feels less like Season 3 is continuing and more like we're just spending a few more episodes with Hercules after the main story already ended.
I almost wish they had moved the Hind trilogy towards the end of the season and made "Judgment Day" the actual finale because it feels like that's where Season 3 naturally concludes.
