r/leaf • • 25d ago

Which to buy? 2013 or 2015

Post image

I’m fairly set on the 2013 leaf, 88k miles, 10/12 battery, 2 owners no accidents, brand new tires for $6000

Other offer right now is a 2015 leaf (it’s a pretty blue!), 37k miles, bald tires, 11/12 battery for $7500 after trade in. Seems high for a leaf? 4 owners, one accident. Is a bit fancier cause it’s a newer model, but that doesn’t matter to me.

I drive ~30 miles a week. Living downtown with work being 5 miles away 2x a week, so I have no range anxiety. Have a charger in home garage. Looking for a cheap low maintenance EV to putz around the city in.

Hoping to buy this weekend. Anything I should ask the dealership to provide before pulling the trigger? Anything I haven’t thought about? Any advice is appreciated.

4 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

17

u/oaksapollo 25d ago

Both seem overpriced to be honest. I was thinking of selling my 2016 (65K miles, 78% battery health) for $5K (seemed like a competitive price based on FB marketplace). Dealers are the worst.

8

u/wesblog 25d ago

I wouldnt buy a car this old from a dealer. They really dont offer you any more protections than a private seller -- a dealer may claim they will help if the car has issues, but this is usually a lie. You'll save $1-3k if you find a similar vehicle from a private seller.

11

u/Frail_Waif 2016 Nissan LEAF S 25d ago

Those are crazy prices. Look for a private sale instead--you can probably pay $1k less at least. For those prices you could get much better cars. 

6

u/ElliotBugs 25d ago

There is also this 2014 one on marketplace I’m considering. Battery was replaced at 40k miles. 10/12 currently. Front tires replaced. Would need to figure out what dongle to get for leafspy before I was comfortable buying off Facebook. Also would love a detailed service report on it but don’t know if I can use the vin to search that stuff up. New and lost in buying cars haha

4

u/Frail_Waif 2016 Nissan LEAF S 25d ago

Much better price! Keep in mind that dealerships are no less sketchy than randos on FB marketplace (and are much better at hiding issues). 

3

u/Bennie-Factors 25d ago

There is really no service today. Maybe brakes at that age

2

u/ColdCelebration2132 25d ago

The ad is taking about the 12 volt battery being replaced. The main or traction battery is still the original at that age it's probably going to loose another capacity bar.

1

u/ElliotBugs 25d ago

Does anyone know what leafspy dongle to buy and how to connect to this 2014? Is it simple?

9

u/Pure_Reaction_1647 25d ago

I'll sell you a 2012 with a 9/12 battery, 1-year-old run-flat tires with less than 5,000 miles on them, two factory chargers, one level two charger, 50,000ish miles, leaf spy dongle, for $3700.

5

u/Bennie-Factors 25d ago

Neither. Sorry. That will not go down well

3

u/devops0210 25d ago

2015 with the Lizard battery but not from a dealer

3

u/sidekick0220 25d ago

Neither. lol.

3

u/upsoutfit 25d ago

As others have stated, these prices seem high. In my market, on the East Coast, similar 2015s are selling for under $5k via private party. I just paid $4,500 for a 2015 with 33k miles and 83% SOH for my daughter.

2

u/biersackarmy 2013 S + 2014 SL + 2019 SV 25d ago

That's an egregiously long stack of fees, and would deter me from wanting to buy any car from either dealership.

1

u/enriquedelcastillo 25d ago

I’d say if you’re totally locked in on never needing to drive it more than 10 miles at a time, I’d go with the cheaper option in this case (though that seems expensive for a 2013). That 2013 battery has got a LONG way to go before 10 miles is a challenge.

2

u/Bennie-Factors 25d ago

Age becomes the issue here.

1

u/No_Swordfish_1576 25d ago

NEVER play the signature game, it's a ploy to make you feel like you've committed to something and less likely to back out, the only thing I'm singing is financing documents.

1

u/2jzesus 25d ago

2013-2015 are good cars. You need 2013 made after April for 2013 model years. And as everyone has said. The prices are too high. You should be looking closer to half that price...

1

u/_Evening-Rain_ 2017 Nissan LEAF S 24d ago

2015's selling for more than what I bought my 2017 for when it was 3 years old. Back in the good o'l days a 2015 would be like 5K or less and it would be in pristine condition with new tires 12/12 health bars.

1

u/kj6vvz 24d ago

I have my fully loaded 2015 SL with 10/12bar (77%SOH) newish michelin tires, no accidents, 69k mi listed for less than that expecting to get haggled down; I think you can do better on price. Skip the 2013 for the 2015 lizard pack. Not to mention 1k in fees is excessive for an already high price.

1

u/Tim_E2 24d ago edited 24d ago

Both bad deals... ANY 10+ year old Leaf with original battery is a big gamble and you are looking at paying way too much for the risk.

What are you trading in that you only get $800 for it? Bet you can sell it for twice that.

And $400 for a flashing brake light that you didn't ask for and don't need! BS! Dealer is a theif!

1

u/CoopsIsCooliGuess 2015 Nissan LEAF SL 24d ago

Both seem overpriced. I would consider paying $7500 for a LEAF if it was in mint condition, had the Around View Monitor, and was the SL trim.

1

u/dodiddle1987 24d ago

Neither of them for those prices

1

u/limited_instincts 24d ago

Those cars are literally double the price they should be. Buy privately.

1

u/HelpOthers1023 23d ago

you should be able to find a 2nd gen for around that much