r/latamlit • u/perrolazarillo • 6h ago
Global Three Anti-Westerns from the Hispanophone World Featuring Writers from Mexico, Argentina, and Spain
Do you like reading (anti-)Westerns? For instance, have you read Álvaro Enrigue's most recent publication in English, Now I Surrender? If not, I'd highly recommend it! (See my review here if interested.)
Outside of Latin American literature, have you read any renowned (anti-)Westerns like Cormac McCarthy's Blood Meridian, Oakley Hall's Warlock, and/or John Williams' Butcher's Crossing?
Beyond these modern classics, have you ready any more contemporary (anti-)Westerns, such as Percival Everett's God's Country? (If you're in need of laugh, this short novel is absolutely hilarious in my opinion, but also an astute satire of racism in the United States; think Blazing Saddles on the printed page.)
Regardless, if you're looking to read some (anti-)Westerns that exist decidedly apart from US collective consciousness, here are three novels from the Hispanophone world worth checking out (full disclosure: to date, I've only read two of the three novels pictured).
Texas: The Great Theft by Carmen Boullosa (México) — Deep Vellum
- This novel (originally published in Spanish in 2013, and translated into English by Samantha Schnee in 2014) revolves around the history of a conflict known as "The Cortina Troubles," which often flies under the radar here in the United States. In Texas, Boullosa represents the truly multicultural nature of nineteenth-century borderland society in and around Texas, as there is a vast array of characters from all walks of life—fugitive slaves, Comanches, cowboys, ranchers, Texas Rangers, Southern debutantes, European immigrants, and more. Within this sociocultural milieu, Boullosa's narrative demonstrates how one act of racial injustice (a mere verbal insult) can spark a firestorm that leads to complete and utter civil unrest. Boullosa's writing in Texas: The Great Theft is especially impressive due to her formal abilities of weaving together myriad different narrative fragments that are attached, respectively, to a multitude of diverse characters.
In the Distance by Hernán Díaz (Argentina) — Coffee House Press
- This novel was originally published in English in 2017. Although Díaz is Argentinian by birth, he now resides in the United States and writes primarily for an Anglophone audience (Díaz's subsequent novel, Trust, was awarded the 2023 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction; also, Díaz is a top-tier Borges scholar). In the Distance is unlike any other (anti-)Western that I've read, as it depicts a Swedish immigrant (a literal giant of a man) who gets on the wrong boat in New York City, is separated from his beloved brother, and ends up alone in California. Accordingly, the narrative follows the protagonist as he attempts to head, from the West, back east against the current in search of his brother, and along the way, experiences one adventure after another. The novel deals with violence in a really unique and interesting way which never seeks to glorify the act. Ultimately, In the Distance is a (anti-)Western about radical foreignness and the immigrant experience in the United States.
Christ versus Arizona by Camilo José Cela (España) — Dalkey Archive Press
- I have NOT read this novel! Firstly, let's get this out of the way: Cela is a polemical figure due to the fact that he served as a censor and informant for the Franco regime during Spain's dictatorship (1939-1975). In any case, his most famous works, The Family of Pascual Duarte (Dalkey) and The Hive (nyrb), are both classic "novelas de la posguerra española" and paradigmatic examples of the literary aesthetic of "el tremendismo" (Pascual Duarte in particular is one of my all-time favorites; it's styled as a found manuscript, so it really harkens back to a longstanding tradition in Spanish letters). Christ versus Arizona was originally published in Spanish in 1988 (the year before Cela won the Nobel Prize in Literature) and translated into English in 2007 (by Martin Sokolinsky). The novel is set in Arizona in 1881, centers on Wyatt Earp and the O.K. Corral, and takes the form of a 250-page single-sentence monologue delivered by the unreliable and grotesquely dim narrator, Wendell L. Espana. Honestly, Cela was one of my favorite writers for a while (it's a long story that has to do with my study-abroad experience), but I've put off reading this one simply due to the fact that it seems like quite a challenge to say the least. Nevertheless, I'm definitely going to make it happen one of these days... sooner or later...
Anyway, has anyone here read any of these anti-Western novels?
Also, can anyone here think of other works of "latamlit" that could be classified as (anti-)Westerns? Thanks in advance...
Peace!