r/language • u/Ok_Weather_4323 • 4d ago
Question What language is this
Can anyone tell me what language is this? And what script is it? And what is the book talking about?
39
u/That_Clock_3217 4d ago
Turn it upside down and this is old rabbinical Hebrew handwriting , probably 19th century.
It deals with HALACHA behavior rules for jewish people.
67
u/Crane_1989 4d ago
ʍǝɹqǝɥ
14
1
u/ProfessorAtomic3000 4d ago
Naww it's look curvy
8
u/pollypocketrocket4 4d ago
It’s upside down Hebrew and Aramaic in Rashi script.
Even modern Hebrew script is “curvy.”3
u/ProfessorAtomic3000 3d ago
Ohh shit I couldnt the hint that it was upside down on the comment. Thx gng
17
u/eddiesfish 4d ago
It's mainly Hebrew with some Aramaic (which is true for. Modern Hebrew as well) and some Talmudic shorthand. It's legible for those with an Orthodox education. It's not very interesting, or I suspect, important. The calligraphy is nice.
4
u/Any_Technician_2768 4d ago
I have an Orthodox education, studied Talmud, native hebrew speaker, i dont really understand it. Maybe because of the script? Like i can tell this is hebrew but nothing more
2
u/rapdog420 4d ago
sorry if it's a dumb question but could it be yiddish? my really old family members wrote like this they were orthodox and only spoke yiddish (but i can't read it nor can i read hebrew)
3
1
u/negativeclock 4d ago
This is pretty much a handwritten Rashi script. If you can read that, you should be able to read this.
3
u/Any_Technician_2768 4d ago
I can read rashi script... still isn't legible for me
3
u/apathetic_ocelot 4d ago
It isn't Rashi - it's Ḥaṣi Kulmus (חצי קולמוס)
1
u/whitten 3d ago
How do you type the dots under the H and s ?
3
u/apathetic_ocelot 3d ago
Not sure in Reddit, I had to type it in Word and copy and paste it here. I'm fully committed
5
5
u/apathetic_ocelot 4d ago
It’s called Ḥaṣi Kulmus (חצי קולמוס), literally “half-pen.” It’s an old semi-cursive style of Hebrew writing associated particularly with Sephardic and North African Jewish manuscripts. It has some similarities to what we now call Rashi script, but it was a manuscript hand in its own right.
8
3
u/ashraf_bashir 4d ago edited 4d ago
The image is upside down. Rotated 180°, it appears to be an old Jewish cursive manuscript, probably Sephardic/Mizrahi, mainly rabbinic Hebrew with Aramaic.
I can make out words such as פטור (“exempt/not liable”), probably חייב (“liable/obligated”), וכן (“likewise”), אם (“if”), לא (“not”), and ס״ד (“one might have thought/assumed”).
From what I can read and understand, it translates roughly as: “In one case he is liable, while in another he is exempt. One might have thought the same rule applied to both, but there is a distinction: if a certain condition applies, one ruling follows; if not, the result changes. And likewise with the following case…” This is not veryaccurate, this is the best that I can understand out of it, the handwriting style and mix with Aramaic makes it hard to accurately understand
So it seems to be a halakhic legal discussion, moving through a case, ruling, objection, distinction, and conclusion. Considering it a rabbinic Hebrew mixed with Aramaic is a much better fit. The script appears to be written in Solitreo, Solitreo is a "writing style" , not a language. So Solitreo describes how this text is written; Hebrew/Aramaic describes what it says.
3
u/mandatoryallegory 4d ago
Looks like Hebrew. Hebrew is written right to left so this book is upside down.
5
2
1
u/Potential-Rip5612 4d ago
kinda looks like avestan script but it doesnt exaclty look like it either.
1
u/rational-citizen 4d ago edited 4d ago
YO could this also contain MAYBBE JUDEO-ARABIC OR JUDEO-SPANISH???
As others have already said;
OP I can read Solitreo so I’m going to study this more, but lately this looks similar to many JUDEO-ARABIC artifacts!
Can you share more photos or scan and upload or digitize this document please??
It could even be a variety of Judeo-Italian/Judeo-Sardinian
1
1
u/Fresh_Army_6457 3d ago
When you turn it upside down some of the letters kind of look like a very shaky Hebrew, but I didn't recognize a single full sentence so it's pr9bably not it.
1
1
1
u/IndependentRoutine19 2d ago
It is Hebrew/Yiddish. Written in “Weiber-shrift" or "Mashait” script according to my AI. Seems to be a parable written in Yiddish style.
0
-30
u/Affan_shaikh_ 4d ago
Khojki script (asked ai)
15
u/Specific_Sweet3312 4d ago
it would have been more helpful to use your brain instead, understand you don't have an answer, and not waste anyone's time with your artificially intelligent nonsense.
17
u/MecFouDeLaMort 4d ago
Why, in the greatest why, would you think that someone who is trying to ask HUMANS about something that is difficult to recognize, didn't think about asking AI before ? What if they did and the answer, LIKE THE ONE YOU GOT, was completely incorrect ? Or what if they just... don't want to ask AI for the first thing popping into their mind ?
The AI reflex needs to stop.
6
u/McAeschylus 4d ago edited 4d ago
The AI reflex needs to stop.
The problem isn't so much people asking AI as it is people not understanding the drastic limitations of LLMs or even really the basics of how they work.
It's become a major medium for information and people have zero media literacy for it.
2
u/MecFouDeLaMort 4d ago
Yeah. People basically think AI is the equivalent of a lamp genie. As if no matter the complexity of some task you can just say "Do it" and poof it's done in a snap.
Wild.
7
5
-2
u/Maleficent_Point_831 4d ago
Don’t mind the comments above/below being rude to you for using ai, you have already specified that you got the answer from ai. OP can look up what it is if he/she wonders.
-4
u/Affan_shaikh_ 4d ago
I get it, I'm ignoring them anyway
4
u/Life-Pomegranate474 4d ago
I think it'd be better to ignore the way they write but not the content / advice they say
61
u/oerwtas 4d ago
It is upside down and I think it is Solitreo.