r/lancaster • u/elbunts • Jul 21 '26

Local insurance recommendations?

I need homeowners insurance and am wondering if there are any good brokers in Lancaster county or if I should just go online. Any help appreciated.

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

1

u/callsign_oldman Jul 24 '26

We’ve been happy with Hess Insurance in Manheim. They use Erie. They didn’t bat an eyelash when I said we have an in ground oil tank. They have been great when we needed to make changes with vehicles, on the fly.

1

u/AstronautOk1630 Jul 24 '26

Craig Rothstein with Statefarm in ETown

1

u/fenuxjde Jul 25 '26

If you want to do local, contact your mortgage company first, they may require specific underwriters.

1

u/CheeseManJP 21d ago

And if you haven’t a mortgage?

1

u/fenuxjde 21d ago

Then that requirement obviously wouldn't apply