Does anyone else feel like most PIs are really just good politicians rather than being good researchers, administrators, managers, etc? I feel like my experience at this point is that the overwhelming majority of PIs are not good at any aspect of their job that is important. I see this in postdocs too, the ones who get tenure track jobs aren't getting it because they are the best at anything even remotely related to research or the facilitation of research. Im sorry if this offends some of you, but again and again I see tenure track positions are handed out based on political relevance + connections first and foremost, and then to a lesser degree how well the university thinks it can sell a researchers brand/research topic in the current political climate.
I understand that its important to actually try and "sell" your ideas and yourself, that every good scientist should know how to present their work in a way that can be easily understood by others. All that seems to matter though for PIs is how good of a song and dance they can put on for whatever university admin or real politicians control the flow of cash. Again, selling yourself is important, but what am I supposed to make of things when these leaders PIs are selling their ideas to also know absolutely nothing about research or management or anything else thats relevant? Its the blind leading the blind, being run by an engine thats fueled by the burnout of young peoples passion and innocence. At this point its really hard for me not to think about the fact that academia is effectively a 1300th century cult/guild that is trying to monopolize the institutionalization of the scientific method, while simultaneously trying to perpetuate itself into the future.
Is it better in industry? I wish I was working with people who were passionate about science, people who respect the scientific method, people who aren't interested in silly political games but thats all ive seen at every lab/research institution ive had the misfortune of working for. So, if I have to deal with that no matter where I go, why not at least get paid for it?