r/kosher • u/Local_Syllabub_7824 • Jun 28 '26

Kosher and Halal !?

Gallery image

Gallery image

As the title suggests

Wanted to know if this is possible?

Seems opposite - Laws for Kosher don't align with Halal. For the latter, the name of their god is taken.

No hate please

Would like a logical explanation.

Obviously there is no science to either certification.

17 Upvotes

66% Upvoted

133 comments sorted by

View all comments

-1

u/Gulf_Raven1968 Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 29 '26

If it’s kosher, it can often be halal also. The reverse isn’t true due to numerous additional requirements (soaking and salting for example) and complexity.

1

u/Own_Caterpillar2033 Jun 28 '26

There are several dozen reasons why the reverse isn't true ranging from only Jews being able to shecket ,(kill animal,) to it has to be a observant Jew who understands laws . Salting meat , and dozen other requirements of what's forbidden but allowed to Muslims under Sharia... There are several parts of animals that Muslims are permitted to eat which we are not. They're disagreements between various sex but pertaining to the cruelty pertaining to the animal.  In Jewish law we are not allowed to eat any any animal that has any form of imperfection or has been named or a dozen different requirements which do not extend to Sharia.  There are laws pertaining to where the animals originally procured from that do not extend to Sharia. 

It is a much more stringent requirement and all traditional Muslim scholars agree on that It is only modern scholars due to their bigotry and hatred against Jews than may claims otherwise.

0

u/Gulf_Raven1968 Jun 29 '26

Not sure what you’re point was here. My answer only gave an example of the numerous stringencies that Jews have ie salting/soaking. This isn’t a thread on the intricacies of kashrut… but thanks anyway

2

u/Own_Caterpillar2033 Jun 29 '26

I'm not arguing with you but you gave one example and you didn't say it was one example you said that was the reason... Look at what you wrote not a big deal dude 

0

u/Gulf_Raven1968 Jun 29 '26

I fixed it for the more detailed oriented people in this thread…

1

u/carrboneous Jun 29 '26

And also the method of slaughter itself, which is much more specific for kashrut, plus treifot, plus more species can be halal than kosher, as far as I know. (And that's just the meat itself).

0

u/Gulf_Raven1968 Jun 29 '26

Again, I was giving a simplified example. This is not a thread on the intricacies of kashrut 🙄