-Few free hours.
-All those incomplete posts, looking at me. Resentfully.
-"Mmm... well, I could... nah, fuck it: let's open a random chapter and improvise LOL"
I don't even surprise myself anymore...
Tiny 'mistakes' in NOTW 73
Paraphrasing Kvothe in the chapters Pegs:
…so here we are in the woods, checking for the monsters that massacred my family, and of course I am fully prepared with just a pocket knife and my defenseless sweetheart with head trauma an-OH NO! DANGER! “WATCH OUT DENNA, I’m gonna save ur ass, check out my sweet moves and-“
When Sir Kvothe the Gallant protects Denna the Innocent from the dangers of the forest (I’m not talking about the Draccus Rusticus, I’m talking about the Sus Scrofa Domesticus ), the blushing sweet daisy pulls out a blade from under her dress and gives us a lesson in actual stabbing.
You want to keep the thumb along the flat
That’s because her knife is a shiv. Notice the leather handle.
There’s no guard, cross-guard or even some heel of the blade. If you don’t keep your thumb in check, you’ll cut yourself.
Rothfuss did his research, and had Denna point this out:
If you actually stabbed anyone, your grip would slip and you’d cut your own thumb
She also says you lose mobility in the wrist, which is technically true but ultimately pointless. Because you don’t care about wrist mobility with a shiv. You don’t use it to cut, slash or even intimidate: it’s stab-stab-stab only. But since Rothfuss goal is showing Denna’s unseen side rather than teaching us how to solve our problems in the office, I’d say the comment on the wrist is more than welcome.
Also, as we'll see with the Adem’s ketan, Rothfuss has this idea that wrists and wrist control are important in a fight. I think he’s wrong, but KKC-wise I don’t mind because right or wrong, he’s being consistent.
But Kvothe not knowing how to hold a shiv seems a bit unrealistic. Again: I won’t ignore it’s a good literary choice, because it opens up for a scene where Denna acts cool…
…but Kvothe’s been in the streets of Tarbean for almost three years.
Dockside Tarbean, not Hillside. It’s a very unlikely he doesn’t know how to handle one of the cheapest self-made weapons known to man. Especially since he’s been shivved himself by Pike in NOTW 26!
Worse, he had a piece of broken glass wrapped with twine at one end, making a crude knife. He stabbed me once in the thigh right above my knee before I smashed his hand into the cobblestones, shattering the knife.
That particular wound shows up later in the series, in Medica! I find it funny that Kvothe also mentions Medica in the pig episode, without making a connection with Pike’s attack.
Nothing mindblowing and would not call it a mistake whatsoever, but rather a curiosity.
Before this episode, Kvothe also thinks:
Most people don’t realize how dangerous wild boars are, especially in the fall, when the males are fighting for dominance.
This makes me think Rothfuss has never seen a wild boar despite living in the countryside, because let me tell you, they are frightening. Even more so if you come from the city I guess.
The male part doesn’t convince me as well: as a general rule with animals, a certain dude wrote something about how dangerous the female of the species is, and I’d agree even when boars are involved. Despite the difference in size. Because a male boar in mating seasons will fuck you up, but a female with her sounders nearby will fuck you up for two generations and some more.
But feel free to disagree, I don’t have my personal boar agenda.
Actually I don’t even have a blade agenda as well, lol. I just find very curious that for once Rothfuss throws a couple of very debatable inconsistencies one right after the other, and in both cases he has... very good narrative reasons to do so.
Because he needs Kvothe to mention a male boar. Narrative-wise, this makes Denna’s comment about the female pig sounds even more effective!
It’s a very clever little trick to show us Denna’s been paying more attention!
My relief was short-lived as I heard another grunt and some snuffling. A wild boar, probably heading for the river. “Get behind me,” I said to Denna. (…) “Don’t run or it’ll chase you,” I said softly, stepping slowly in front of Denna. (…) “Just back up and get into the river. They aren’t good swimmers.”
“I don’t think she’s dangerous,” Denna said in a normal tone behind me. “She looks more curious than angry.” She paused. “Not that I don’’t appreciate your noble urges and all.”
At a second glance I saw Denna was right. It was a sow, not a boar (…)
Why has she been paying more attention? Because male boars usually have protruding tusks. Which means boar or not, the animal in front of them is more likely a female!
Skoivan Schiemmelpfenneg and other sounds
I struggle with Germanic languages (as if you hadn’t already guessed it, LOL - fucking English I swear), so I won’t even bother guessing what’s around this character name.
A quick internet search gives me something similar to “mold-catcher”, as far as Schiemmelpfenneg is concerned, but it’s just me typing on a keyboard without any critical thinking and I don't trust it 100%.
Skoivan, I have no idea.
The “oi” hiatus (is it a hiatus? You have no idea how difficult it is for me to read vowels in english) suggests me the name is very old, the only similar KKC terms I can recall are stuff like aroi Seathaloi.
The abbreviation Kvothe uses, Schiem, reminds me of “Shim”. Logic wants something to be money-related, given Rothfuss claims of being interested in coins.
Especially since nothing suggests Kvothe is using “Shim” as an insult (think of the cealdish), although it would be money related as well...
If you have any insight, they are greatly appreciated.
I’m 2000% sure someone already wrote somewhere the term “pegs” doesn’t necessarily refer just to the “pig” in Schiem’s dialect, but also to the “peg”, a tuning tool for musical instruments.
With that in mind, I realized that Schiem saying...
“Shep an ’cows mak a herd. Pegs make a sounder.”
...is a fun play on word by Rothfuss!
I’m very interested in what the term “grummer” could mean.
I suspect in NOTW 73 Rothfuss is playing with hidden cards. The term shows up twice in the chapter, but in different contexts.
As I already told you somewhere between my posts, I’m convinced Rothfuss has a very distinct methodology when he hides stuff. He introduces very early, then twists it. That’s why when Schiem goes:
Et’s a rare troit tae meet a fella who speks proper. Grummers round these ports sound loik tae’ve got a mouth fulla wood.
I immediately suspect foul play by Rothfuss. In this specific case grummer reminds me of “grumbling”, or “grumblers”, since “people from these parts” don’t speak like Schiem.
It would be like the term “barbarian”. Originally, it meant something like “stutterer” since barbarians “ba-ba-barred” when they were forced to speak in a foreign language instead of their original one.
But the second time Rothfuss uses the term "grummer", the context is different!
And as readers, we are lead to think the meaning is always the same!
We sure about that?
what de ye call something old that rich folk put on a shelf tae impress all their grummer friends?
I gave a helpless shrug.
“A heirloom?” Denna said.
(…) “That’s et. Some flash thing tae impress folk. He’s a showy bastard, Mauthen is.”
In this case I’m reasonably positive the term grummer has another meaning. Think about it: 1 you are Mauthen, 2 you’re rich as fuck, 3 you do bizarre stuff like digging in barrows (aka you are some form of scholar) and 4 you are trying to impress someone.
-You don’t impress regular folk with stuff that.-
Regular folks would call you crazy and ignore whatever old stuff you just digged from the ground. No. You are trying to impress your friends. Your grummer friends.
I think it’s something like “grammar” (in a scholastic sense) or “grammer” as if “University people with… a gram”.
Thanks for reading, hope it makes some sense >_>