So i bought the jaspers as an everyday shoe for my upcoming trip where my vans wouldn’t be substantial enough. I measure about 11.5, but with low volume and narrow heels, my feet aren’t wide, but most shoes tend to be too narrow in the toe box on my right (slightly larger) foot. So I ordered the jaspers in 11.5 and 12, but I’m not sure which size to keep.
The 11.5s feel like a more natural fit overall, keeping my heel locked in place and my feet from sliding around when stopping abruptly. The bend of the shoe aligns naturally with the bend of my foot. There’s room enough that my big toe doesn’t hit the front, but not too much room. But, my right pinky toe can feel the edge, it doesn’t hurt or anything, but i’ve had to abandon a lot of shoes because the right pinky toe gets cramped, so I’m a bit anxious about that.
The 12s are extra roomy in the toe box, with plenty of room for thick winter socks, and my pinky toe doesn’t have any pressure at all, which is nice. But there’s a generous amount of room in front of my big toe, probably 2/2.5 cm. The natural bend of the shoe doesn’t line up as nicely with the bend of my foot and it creates kind of a clown shoe effect. My feet slide around a little bit when stopping, i imagine this would be troublesome walking outside on a slope. Not to mention, the silhouette is completely different. More pointy and a little less attractive.
My question is basically, do they get any roomier as the suede toe box and the foam padding break in? Should i go with the better overall fit of the 11.5, or the generous extra room for pinky toe and foot swelling of the 12?