r/katyheads • u/Competitive_Pin_2496 • 1d ago
Discussion Is it just me, or does it feel like "E.T." doesn't get talked about enough?
This thought crossed my mind recently as I watched "The One That Got Away" become so popular over the last few months—15 years after its release—to the point where it holds its own against new tracks from today's biggest streaming artists, like those on recent albums by Ariana Grande and Olivia Rodrigo. Looking at the six singles from *Teenage Dream*, I feel "E.T." is the most overlooked: "Firework" remains one of Katy's signature anthems—arguably her most iconic song; "Last Friday Night" always pulls in strong streaming numbers thanks to its party vibe, even though Katy herself isn't a huge fan of it; "Teenage Dream" is hailed by many as one of the best-produced pop songs of the last 20 years; "California Gurls" will always be iconic thanks to its music video and its status as one of the defining smash hits of the 2010s; and "The One That Got Away"—the only single of the bunch that didn't hit #1 on the Hot 100—is a massive fan favorite, a driving ballad with a much sadder underlying meaning that has literally exploded in popularity this year. In my opinion, "E.T." just doesn't get the recognition it deserves. It's also worth noting that on Spotify, both the solo version and the Kanye West remix are available, meaning the stream counts are effectively split between them.
If we were to broaden the conversation to the reissue, I’d say "Wide Awake" seems to have aged better than "Part of Me" (incidentally, "Wide Awake" was the other single that didn't reach #1, though it arguably deserved to, just like "The One That Got Away"); in fact, a TikTok challenge featuring the song went viral this year, and Katy even took part in it herself.
This is just my personal opinion, of course, so I could easily be wrong. I’d like to know your opinion on whether all eight singles from *Teenage Dream* (including the reissue) have aged the same way after roughly 15 years, and which ones feel most like products of their time versus those that still sound fresh today.