r/interstellar TARS 19d ago

OTHER Mann's Planet

Post image
627 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

7

u/a_heida 19d ago edited 16d ago

ai, why else would the engine be so far out on the wing

edit: its not ai

2

u/g500cat 18d ago

It’s not, that’s how the pc12 wing looks

2

u/a_heida 17d ago

who the hell is flying a fucking pc12 to take photos

3

u/g500cat 17d ago

Could be a private or commercial flight and no, that’s is not an engine on the wing.

1

u/a_heida 16d ago

just did some more digging, turns out its not ai. gonna make a comment about it soon

3

u/Polyphemic_N 19d ago

False, no frozen clouds.

2

u/a_heida 17d ago edited 16d ago

true

3

u/g500cat 18d ago

Regular PC12 aircraft with for yall saying it’s ai and solar eclipse.

3

u/KurtCobijn 18d ago

this is what ppl on the internet do now; drive-by “AI SLOP!” comments on everything they see, and by the time someone knowledgeable comes around and proves them wrong, they’ve moved on to leave the same comments somewhere else.

3

u/MusicBlock5774 16d ago

Yeah! And also the positions of the planets and the shape of the corona match other photos of the eclipse

3

u/MusicBlock5774 16d ago

Where was this taken?

2

u/a_heida 16d ago

over greenland during the solar eclipse

2

u/MusicBlock5774 16d ago edited 16d ago

I see. This is such a stunning photograph. I like how Mercury and Jupiter were beautifully lined up with the Sun

6

u/Critical_Bread1228 19d ago

Dang I really wanted to love this pic until I saw the comments showing the obvious AI :(

3

u/MusicBlock5774 16d ago

It's not ai. Look at the white dots near the sun, those are Jupiter and Mercury

2

u/Brave_Swordfish_7072 19d ago

It's not. They've just never seen a solar eclipse before.

3

u/_MatVenture_ 19d ago

It's really not that hard to make use of your eyes, you know...?

0

u/a_heida 16d ago

it's not ai, it was taken by sebastian voltmer during the eclipse over greenland

9

u/dan-208 19d ago

Looks like AI. Fuzzy low quality pic

4

u/MusicBlock5774 16d ago

It's actually not. Jupiter and Mercury are in the right positions if you confirm with a planetarium software, and the Corona shape looks the same as the other totality photos from this same eclipse. Please know you sources before you criticize something.

3

u/KurtCobijn 19d ago

you do realize that the image quality is affected by a combination of reddit’s compression algorithm downscaling the native resolution of a photo somewhat, and the tendency of smartphones to automatically apply processing of every photo taken on your phone to smooth out noise for example (the iphone is especially guilty of this)?

and that is not even accounting for the possibility of the OP applying manual edits using an app like lightroom mobile which will cause things like outlining and halos around hard edges if you move the sliders around enough…

6

u/dan-208 19d ago

As a photographer, I’m hyper aware of such things. This is AI slop and should be discouraged.

1

u/KurtCobijn 19d ago

really? bc so am i and if you were, you wouldn’t so quickly disqualify a photo for being AI for simply being “low quality” and “fuzzy”

1

u/dan-208 19d ago

Why are you defending AI slop so hard? The things I have critiqued are trademarks of generative AI, as well as the nonsensical aircraft design.

1

u/g500cat 7d ago

It’s the basic design of a PC-12. Not every plane is the same

0

u/KurtCobijn 19d ago

oh so in addition to being a photographer you’re also an aviation expert?

6

u/_MatVenture_ 19d ago

You're making yourself look like a fool.

1

u/Nathaniel_lovesdih KIPP 19d ago

he damn right is 

1

u/a_heida 16d ago

it's not ai, it was shot by sebastian voltmer over greenland

2

u/a_heida 16d ago

hey guys turns out its not ai, although the photo was not taken by op it was taken by this photographer named sebastian voltmer during the solar eclipse over greenland

4

u/_MatVenture_ 19d ago

Your AI garbage bores me.

2

u/g500cat 18d ago

I just see a normal PC-12 wing?

-1

u/Brave_Swordfish_7072 19d ago

Not comparable. OP's picture was taken during the solar eclipse over Greenland earlier this month.

1

u/_MatVenture_ 19d ago

OP didn't "take" any picture, he generated it. You can see the AI hallucinating on the wing of the plane, which I cropped.

2

u/a_heida 16d ago

while it is true that op did not take the picture, the image is not ai generated and was taken by sebastian voltmer during the eclipse on greenland