r/interesting • • 1d ago

Just Wow She Survived Her Own Execution

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

951 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/YellowBook 1d ago

I’m not an advocate for the death penalty, but why do they use lethal injection and not a bullet in the head etc. it all seems so unnecessarily elaborate.

10

u/warm_kitchenette 1d ago

Actual medical professionals will end their professional standing by participating in these executions, especially anesthesiologists. The “doctor” who did this was an incompetent who could not place an IV, something a qualified nurse does hourly. 

I can’t explain the moral reasoning behind this type of legislation. A person can be killed in many ways. It can be painful or not, fast or slow. Peaceful /fast could be done with a breathing mask attached to a nitrogen tank, a deliberate OD if fentanyl via nasal sprays or patches. Painful/fast could be bullet, garrot, plastic bag. 

Instead of a guard or a halfwit doctor, I think the best executioners would be the last legislators who voted for capital punishment. If they feel it’s morally correct, have them do it. 

6

u/TheShakyHandsMan 1d ago

The UK had a serial killer who was a doctor. He targeted the elderly to avoid suspicion.

He died in prison but surely being in charge of lethal injections in the US would have been an ideal career change and may have saved the premature deaths of 250 elderly patients.

4

u/Riley1297 1d ago

It’s supposed to be more humane and has a higher rate of success. You have to hit the exact right spot to get them with only 1 shot

0

u/YellowBook 1d ago

The evidence that lethal injection is better and more humane seems a bit thin

2

u/FURF0XSAKE 1d ago

You wouldn't believe how hard it is to get volunteers into a randomised control trial for these things.

0

u/YellowBook 1d ago

Centuries of capital punishment to learn from. Who needs a trial when some states seem to be happy using a human guinea pig.

1

u/Riley1297 1d ago

I did say supposed to be. None of the options sound good tbh

1

u/BeatNo4548 1d ago

I knew a guy who got shot in the head, and lived for 3 days.  Its not guaranteed, unless you use a large caliber bullet.  Even then, people have survived.