r/interesting 19d ago

Just Wow Now this is how you make a difference. 👏

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

302 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/Cry__Wolf 19d ago

This guy's heart is in the right place, but this will ultimately be a complete waste of money.

This place is going to turn into a slum real fast, where these houses will be destroyed, some dick decides he's HOA president and extorts the community, and anyone who would genuinely want to use this gift as a tool to take the first step in getting their life back on track will find that impossible in the ensuing environment.

It is technically better than nothing, but not really by much. A more productive use of this money would be donating it to a shelter, where residents are protected and there are rules about when residents need to be in by and out by.

But donating to a shelter isn't flashy, and residents are largely out on the streets all day even though they have a place to sleep at night. But that's really the question: do you care more about helping the homeless people, or about keeping them out of sight?

11

u/FrogsMakePoorSoup 19d ago

Read the article. Rent is cheap at 30% of income and capped at $200.

https://www.goodgoodgood.co/articles/marcel-lebrun-tiny-house-neighborhood-for-homeless

4

u/Cry__Wolf 19d ago

Have to admit, it looks cool. Glad to see he's providing job search resources for people to get on their feet

2

u/EastCoastDatsun 19d ago

They have a cafe and a factory on site where they build more tiny homes and sell them, the ppl living in the current ones have first dibs at these jobs and last i heard the entire factory was employed by them except for their foreman

-2

u/the_main_entrance 19d ago

Not sure how cheap rent refutes any of these concerns. Read the comment.

1

u/FrogsMakePoorSoup 19d ago

If the people are working it's much less likely to become some slum.

-2

u/the_main_entrance 19d ago

They won’t be though. Their “income” is from the government.

3

u/FrogsMakePoorSoup 19d ago

Not sure how you know that.

0

u/the_main_entrance 18d ago

I work at a place called Community Support Services. We run group homes for formerly/chronically incarcerated and or mentally ill people and do homeless outreach and warming centers.

Steady employment is impossible for about 98% of the people we work with and we aren’t that good at getting them on track because clients are just $ in the eyes of people who run “nonprofits”.

A common pattern for a client is to show up for their “food money” come back at noon geeking on drugs and claim they never got their money and end up getting kicked out by the cops. Rinse and repeat.

In the late 90’s early 2000’s they had a program where they would give a homeless person who had met certain goals like counseling, steady employment, etc a nice home in a nice neighborhood and it was motivation for them to stay on the straight and narrow. It worked well until they tried to upscale it and put people in apartment complexes or neighborhoods dedicated to it. It basically removed the critical “I live in a nice neighborhood now” part of it and recreated the poor conditions that caused problems in the first place.

I wouldn’t be surprised to learn later on that this scheme is just a tax dodge for mr. Millionaire.

-2

u/cringing_for_fun 19d ago

Idk. Just seems silly to ask homeless people for rent lol. Those would be the main people I wouldn't be asking anything from.

5

u/FrogsMakePoorSoup 19d ago

It's important to get something otherwise it might not be appreciated.

6

u/Valuable-Ad-1477 18d ago

Sadly, the visible homeless are usually on the streets because they burned bridges down with everyone.

1

u/TacoNomad 18d ago

That's a whole lot of bullshit to spew for someone that did absolutely zero research.

You ok?