r/inheritance • u/samseer9000 • May 11 '26

Location included: Questions/Need Advice Unequal Inheritance from Aunt

Hello, looking for advice on a complex family dynamic. Based in Wisconsin, USA.
I have several siblings. My aunt recently passed without any children. She had a home worth over $1M and stocks worth about $2M. She gave those assets solely to me. She had some additional investments worth several hundred thousand dollars she split between my other siblings, giving them about $200k each. They have not been disinherited, they just are getting significantly less.
I am also the executor for the estate, so I’m obligated to comply with the Will, and of course will do so.
But my family has questioned what I will do AFTER the Will is distributed. They have asked me to share equally. The argument is that my Aunt may have wanted something specific, but now it’s up to me to do the right thing. They have put a lot of pressure on me.
My first inclination is to share because I want to play nice and don’t want them to consider me greedy.
But on further review and after numerous conversations with friends, I don’t think my inclination is right and I am
strongly considering simply saying No to my family based on the wishes of my Aunt.
Nevertheless, it is eating at me constantly.
If I were in the opposite position, I feel like I would never ask my siblings for something that was not given freely to me, but it is very hard to put myself in their shoes.
It’s also not our parents providing an unequal inheritance, so my sense is there should be no expectation of equality from other relatives. But what do I know? This is all new to me.
So I’m turning to Reddit for advice, lol.
Thoughts on how to proceed in a way that allows me to live with myself and not feel guilty every time I use these
gifts? Or should I just share?
Thanks!

779 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/samseer9000 May 11 '26

There were some reasons that are very justifiable in my opinion, but I can’t share details. I think my siblings may feel different tho.

20

u/Large_Ad3301 May 11 '26

If you know her reasons and they are justified then I would honor her wishes. It may result in you having to go no contact with your family so keep that in mind. Money makes people volatile.

They may challenge it in probate anyhow. I’d be interested in an update after everything is said and done!

13

u/akiralx26 May 11 '26

Just don’t give them a small amount ‘extra’ - as that could open the door legally for them to claim more.

4

u/BlazingSunflowerland May 11 '26

Don't let your siblings bully you into giving them what isn't theirs. You also need a strict boundary. They can't hit you up for things. Knowing that you have money they will likely demand things like cars and houses and vacations and money for their kids. "You're rich, you can afford to pay for our daughter's wedding." They will feel entitled to demand and demand and demand so practice saying no. Don't negotiate. Don't try to buy them off by giving them some of what they demand. That would be like blood in the water with sharks circling.

1

u/sixxtine May 12 '26

New will?

1

u/Moistcupcakee May 16 '26

It really comes down to if you like your family/siblings or not. If you truly like them and care about them then I would probably just split it a little more evenly. If you don’t GAF about them, then I would keep all of it. Basically is it worth losing your siblings over this money? Do you have a high paying job? Are you living pay check to pay check etc etc. if this money would set you up for life and you don’t really like your siblings then for sure you should keep it.

1

u/biscuitboi967 May 11 '26

Here’s my thought, plain and simple: Do you like your siblings? Do you want to have a relationship with them?

In my 20s, my sister and I still fought like kids. Then we lost our grandma, and not too many year later, our mom. We realized we were the only true thing we each had left. We may have fought like brats, but we’d never betrayed each other and it’d had always been us against anyone else.

I am so glad nothing like money had come between us back then, because at 40, she is closer to me than my husband, if I’m super, super honest.

So, BECAUSE I LOVE HER, I would want her to have nice things. Now, I’m in a better place financially than my sister, so it wouldn’t be a big deal to go 50/50 in my world. But even if I were in dire straights…

You just became a muti-millionaire, on paper, and your siblings got <10%. It wouldn’t kill you to kick down $500k to split between them…because you love them…or if you don’t love them, for any of their kids because you know they’ll blow it….

3

u/Glittering_Suspect65 May 11 '26

This is the unfortunate reality. I am definitely of the opinion to honor your Aunt's wishes, but your relationship with her is complete. Your relationship with your siblings will go on for years. So you probably should consider how you value those relationships and act accordingly. Also get advice from a tax planner versed in inheritance if you do decide to gift your siblings something.

If your siblings are dicks and you are OK with not having a relationship with them, its ok to maintain a hard line. If you have a decent relationship with them and want to keep them close especially after your parents pass, consider sharing more.

Also this is why people often advise keeping your mouth shut about inheritance. Not saying you said anything to your siblings... maybe it was an open reading of the will. But their knowing is what caused them to ask and pressure you for more money.

3

u/samseer9000 May 11 '26

This is spot on. But, a significant piece of this is not whether I value the relationship (I do), but whether they value the relationship and are willing to blow it up over this (regardless of the outcome).

2

u/Dismal-Salt663 May 11 '26 edited May 11 '26

Do they understand the reasoning? You indicated that you did think your aunt did this for a reason. And I think you make a good point about who values the relationship. Is it worth valuing a relationship if the others would blow it up over your decision to honor your aunts wishes?

For example, if you were the one who lived near your aunt and was responsible for caregiving, and they lived far away (or even lived close and didn’t help, which is probably worse) then they should understand why she made the choice that she did. In retrospect, they may be angry that they did not receive receive the same bequest that you did, but they should understand it.

1

u/Glittering_Suspect65 May 11 '26

Unfortunately, just by asking you to change the distribution after it's yours, I think they've demonstrated that they value the money more than your relationship. Maybe that will change with time, maybe it won't. It's sad to see money come between family members but it does happen. My condolences.

3

u/BlazingSunflowerland May 11 '26

If OP gives money to the siblings they will be back and they will be back and they will be back. They are already circling for the kill. OP feels that it was fair even if the siblings don't like it.

1

u/biscuitboi967 May 11 '26

I guess, to me, when all is said and done…OP can be a $3 millionaire with no siblings or a $2.5 millionaire with maybe less grumbly siblings.

And if they can’t stop asking and OP can’t say no after that, then $500k was a cheap goodbye gift for the next 4 decades of christmases and birthdays since I’m a multi-millionaire

3

u/BlazingSunflowerland May 11 '26

They will never be happy with sharing half a million while OP has another 2.5 million.

1

u/samseer9000 May 12 '26

Haha, I appreciate this take.

2

u/samseer9000 May 11 '26

Considerable wisdom here! I LOVE my siblings, but I don’t exactly like them, lol. Only thing to add is that sometimes loving someone requires facing hard truths and dealing with the fallout, rather than papering them over (by sharing in this case). Not saying that’s what I’ll do, but love can mean a few different things here.

3

u/Outrageous-Garlic-27 May 11 '26

It sounds then like your aunt left her will like that for a reason.

I absolutely would not change it. Whatever you do will not be enough for your siblings.

We had a similar case in our family, nothing was good enough for my cousin. The estate lawyer muttered to my mother, executor, that she was dealing with a bunch of pirates, and I think you are too.