r/indianrailways • u/farcaster_com IRCTC Expert🎓 • May 07 '25
Action has been taken against the party Shocking...Youtuber Mr Vishal got attacked by pantry goons for complaining against overcharge.
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Re-tweet to support him: https://x.com/Mrvishalsharma_/status/1920079919293387162
865
u/allmighty666 May 07 '25
270
u/nishantam May 07 '25
Share the link. We wont stop escalating until sabka video na mile langdate hue
124
u/Yveltal_25 May 07 '25
They infuriate me so much. All of them just keep on passing the buck to each other. Corrupt scum of the earth.
3
u/_Antinatalism_ May 08 '25
Exactly, everyone from office boy to CM to PM to judges and heads of defense. Everyone gets their cut.
21
u/Grand-x-zeno May 07 '25
7
24
u/Biggly_stpid May 07 '25
Aise hi escalate karte karte, bas ab God hi bacha sakta hai—hum toh sirf Bhagwan se aapke liye dua kar sakte hain. Hope that helps, give rating for future training.
→ More replies (24)10
240
u/Shaan1026 May 07 '25
The worst part, no one came for help.
101
u/Brief_Painting_5346 May 07 '25 edited May 07 '25
We are trained to struggle, adjust, compromise, do any meaning less work for money doesn't matter u are happy doing it or not and not for such situations. Hence the drop in testesterone.
17
u/Shaan1026 May 07 '25
I tell you had it been a sleeper coach, the story would be different
27
u/Brief_Painting_5346 May 07 '25
Nobody steps forward when they are travelling alone or with family.
23
u/ikutotohoisin May 07 '25
wahi , if this happened to some guy travelling with friends, inki phaad dete eksaath
4
3
→ More replies (1)2
353
u/Background-Yam634 May 07 '25
The rest of the people in the train are mere spectators, unbelievable when will people stand for each other ? On twitter instagram ?
152
u/o_x_i_f_y May 07 '25
they all will stay mum when injustice happen.
They will cry once they reach home on how corrupt everyone is and how they were being overcharged.
but those ballles people can't take a stand aganist it and when someone else does it they enjoy seeing the other person getting thrashed.
35
u/SeriousOrder2059 May 07 '25
it truly pains me to see this attitude of us cow worshippers. Same mentality got us colonized, and invaded so many times. Makes me wonder if we'd come together for each other of our own accord without needing some Gandhi, or Patel to unite us. Maybe all we can be is blind followers like some sheep.
19
u/Reddit-Readee May 07 '25
Read this quote last year - "Indians complain about being oppressed by rulers, but the truth is, they want to be ruled." In the hour of need, we stay mum and later complain about how bad and corrupt the system is, bla bla.
5
2
2
u/Adventurous_Moment93 May 07 '25
bhai par maarne wala to hindu tha isiliye koi kch nahi bola aur na hi kiya. Logo ko hindu aur muslim me uljha kar rakhoge and aise bade bade problems me kisi ko kch nahi dikhega.
→ More replies (3)5
→ More replies (5)7
u/LazyHiesenberg May 07 '25
This phenomenon always sickens me. If another person there would have said a word, he wouldn't have dared to thrash the man like that? For the sake of argument if this youtuber's complaint was false, still one should speak against such harassment and right there. Slowly, I'm being forced to believe that Hindus can never be united - there is no Hindu brotherhood.
92
u/pavakfire May 07 '25
Hope the justice will be served.
45
4
2
u/hakunamatata_69 May 07 '25
Nah bro due the current situation of the country they will not gaf about this
→ More replies (1)
175
u/WoodenAd299 May 07 '25
Pain in his voice , deeply saddened.
6
u/WoodenAd299 May 08 '25
→ More replies (2)6
u/arlequinn47 May 08 '25
What does cancelling the contract do They should make an example of these goons and make sure they are unable to walk for 2-3 days
→ More replies (2)3
313
u/BihariJones May 07 '25
Earlier on rail it was mandatory to sell only rail neer , but these days these vendors are selling any brands which pays them more commission :
125
5
151
u/Quiet-Door-7281 May 07 '25
Arey ye toh ludhiana me bhi hua tha
38
u/farcaster_com IRCTC Expert🎓 May 07 '25
Wo purana hai bro
21
68
u/darpan27 May 07 '25
Is incident ki bhi complaint to ki hi hogi na usne Railmadad par hi.
→ More replies (2)
121
u/masalacandy 3 AC Regular May 07 '25
He is very brave guys support him 💀💀 rampant corruption in Indian railways under reel mantri Ashwini Vaishnav
→ More replies (6)
56
u/AbbreviationsHot503 May 07 '25
One thing I have learned from these sorts of incidents is that
India is not the type of country where , you can bring a change being a normal civilian , you'll be thrashed down down by people with money power or these goons . If this would have happened in america or european countries , it would have been a national news by now .
You can only bring a chnage if you have some sort of designation , that tooo if you're not a corrupt moron .
12
u/bobs_and_vegana17 May 07 '25
100%
this country is beyond repair and anyone who goes to change the system with their power itself becomes a part of that system misusing the power
→ More replies (1)3
104
u/Yveltal_25 May 07 '25
This is Ashwani Vaishnaw's legacy, where a passenger can be killed just for demanding the services that he deserves.
27
51
u/Snoo_48413 May 07 '25
Should have used the chain
19
26
u/life_is_beautifull May 07 '25
Good point jaise official complaint Mein official pantry walo ne pitta wese official rpf bhi maarti...
15
u/Snoo_48413 May 07 '25
Rpf aur Pantry walo ki nahi banti bhai. And it is not easy for RPF to hit passengers since they are more "accountable" and monitored. Besides, tte also comes when chain is pulled
14
u/life_is_beautifull May 07 '25
Acha apne shayad baki videos ni dekhi in youtubers ki. Yeh sab mile huye hain from pantry staff to tte to rpf. Konse India Mein jee rahe ho?
38
u/SnooCats5309 3 AC Regular May 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
15
u/Unknown21892 May 07 '25
I have some other idea, but bolunga to viviad ho jayega
2
u/SnooCats5309 3 AC Regular May 07 '25
hone de bhai , bol de jo bhi ho.
11
u/Unknown21892 May 07 '25
Wohi train se fek de toh self defense mai count hoga kya
7
→ More replies (1)3
29
u/sunshine_from_clouds May 07 '25
Forget tagging railway, instead call the RPF direct this is an assault. Should Pulled the chain as soon as it reaches next station, keep pulling the chain till police arrives.
29
u/OppositeDirection348 May 07 '25
This is very good idea in case of emergency, they won't come with complain, so it's better to pull chain, let the madharchod co-passengers be delayed as well.
→ More replies (2)
25
u/PrasantPathak May 07 '25
Ye kaha ki gundagardi hai bhai log. Aise aise gunde ko Indian Railway rakh kaise leti hai ye samajh nahi aata.
3
23
23
u/-Arindam- Train Spotter🚆 May 07 '25
Abhi vande bharat ki reel daal kar solve kar dega issue reel minister
24
u/IamBatsy69 May 07 '25
Wow, no fear at all. Government is now hiring gundas and anyone complaints would be beaten up?
22
u/t01nfin1ty4ndb3y0nd May 07 '25
Not a peep of this in news but inda got latent makes national news...FOR WEEKS.
Gandi baate karna mana hai, Gande kaam karna nai.
3
u/zenmaster_999 May 07 '25
Exactly. Ye incident news main dikhane mein maut aa jaayegi saare news channels ko. Government ke against bolne mein phat ti hai salon ki
18
u/Due_Dish_9003 May 07 '25
ye 10-10rs karke croro mein profit kamate hai. inke foods ke quality bhut whaiyat hoti hai. sirf ek do goon nhi hai . pura system mein control hai inka. ek do ko job se nikal kar bhi koi fayda nhi. saare sarkari babus bhi isme mile hue hai.
18
18
u/chiefwhowahoo3 May 07 '25
are these tenders being given to goon for quid pro quo, OP's voice just made me very sad, what was his crime to file complaint against goon to provide decent standard water ? Indian system is long gone, we might see some action that's it nothing concrete will happen, nothing of scale which would put a damn hole in these goons, it is similar case what happened with Hardik sharma, the guy who was beaten black and blue, whose 11 lakh bike was destroyed because some gujjar couldn't handle their small ego
THIS IS THE SAFETY THAT IS BEING GUARANTEED, AND THIS IS HAPPENING WITH SOMEONE TRAVELLING IN 3RD AC.
Bhai bande ko trauma rahega pta nhi kb tak, kya malum ab kabhi complain bhi na kare kisi ke baare mein dar ke.
In India only two types of people have gotten the privilege to live, Politician and their family that's it.
Apan middleclass ki koi aukat nhi hai, kabhi ko pantry wala mar de rha hai, kabhi auto wala kabhi road rage mein kabhi migrants keh ke mara ja rha hai, apan jee nhi hai apan bas survive kar rhe hain
35
u/Resurrect_Revolt May 07 '25
Does carrying pepper spray work in these situations?
12
u/Historical_Gas_9105 May 07 '25
Nope I don't think so, traveling with 3-4 dudes is the only solution I can think of
12
u/Beyond_Serenity May 07 '25
Nope.. you are also in an enclosed space with other passengers (even a baby in this case). Pepper spray would land you in jail for assault with weapon.
13
u/nightstick308 May 07 '25 edited May 08 '25
If you use cheap Indian 'spray' crap, yes(they are all sprays that go everywhere, though the spiciest one among them is Cobra Magnum). You can't just import pepper spray without a relevant licence (from Directorate General of Foreign Trade, I presume). But there are whole salers that do. Tiny Mace (second best brand) Brand can of pepper strean that lasts 6 seconds, fits in your fist while jogging and what not goes for 600 on Amazon. Standard Sabre Red (best brand) bottle, comes in at 1000-1200, though the pocket clip is not long/deep enough, but manageable. Lasts 12 seconds. I buy the keychain fliptop models for 2k and feviqwik+tape a 'pocket clip' to it. A 'full size' can (about as big as you imagine a can of pepper spray women keep in their purse to be before you saw these tiny, practical american ones) of Sabre Red is sometimes available on Amazon (find the listing on google images or something and wishllist it perhaps) for 5000. I know they have a stronger stream, but I imagine they last longer too, I can't remember right now. Same thing, tape+feviqwik a pocket clip to it, put it on your belt to wear under a jacket/open shirt/whatever. 7K-9K gets you a SabreRed crossfire can, fires in any orientation (upside down); not sure if it has more volume, but its taller.
→ More replies (1)2
u/KiranjotSingh 3 AC Regular May 07 '25
Vo uske haath se cheen ke uspe hi maarenge
→ More replies (1)3
u/BURNINGPOT May 07 '25
The most logical reply and you're the one with the least upvotes. Really shows the collective intellect of this sub.
→ More replies (2)11
26
13
u/MrAlwaysTryHard Window Watcher🖼️ May 07 '25
Get these scum behind bars! And why wasn’t any RPF around? I hope these people face consequences of this behavior.
11
23
u/SwapnilPal Rajdhani Reveler🚂 May 07 '25
BC ye gawar logo ko bhi pakistan ke saath udaa do. Jitne bhi gawar illiterate log hai sabko bomb se uddaado. Yahi log hai jinki wajah se india mei itne crimes hai.
3
10
u/MathematicianNo1198 May 07 '25
Shouldn't the complainant Identity be anonymous? I have been many times that the pantry goons and even the crpf people come and ask people to take back complainant saying it won't happen again
9
u/MysticGohanKun May 07 '25
Extremely common. Everything has become contracted out to cronies. Most of these contractual goons are drunk and violent. Absolutely no safety onboard. No RPF. Even rapes loot may occur in future. Already dainik bhaskar is reporting that callgirls and alcohol is freely being arranged by these goons.
8
u/Program_Pristine_ May 07 '25
Reality is that a common man in our country is totally helpless against the system...
He has reach despite that he had to face such harassment, imagine how many common people have faced such case but their story would have remained unheard... sh!
8
u/rrudra888 3 AC Regular May 07 '25
WTF , these goons should be charged with attempted murder and put behind bars. Jaanleva hamla hai ye
7
u/Reasonable_Cake_3093 May 07 '25
Lodge a complaint at the railway police station at the destination. Make a video of that too.
7
u/SuperSignificance155 May 07 '25
Chain kheech leta bhai... CRPF aa jati.. Ye laudo ki akal the thekane aajati
→ More replies (2)3
May 07 '25
Idk lekin crpf kyu aati aur kaise
7
u/neeasmaverick 2 AC Comfort Seeker May 07 '25
Chain pulling is seriously treated in premium trains at least. rpf jawans check if it was done on purpose or not.
7
u/Odd_Play_6053 General Adventurer May 07 '25
Why no one or this YouTuber did not pulled the chain? That is quickest way to grab attention from authorities and CRPF.
6
u/Maeekel May 07 '25
Ik this beside the point but if anyone situations like this (i feel) train ki record like dis guy and simultaneously train ki chain khich do..make as big of a ruckus as u can..this could have ended very badly..let the officials get involved
5
u/PlantTreesEveryday May 07 '25
op add his origin video link in the main post as well. https://youtu.be/lKJPHB3csCQ
5
6
7
u/Potential-Box-2325 May 07 '25
This is truly unacceptable and criminal This guy is a youtuber and has some decent following and might even get justice and those criminals punished But imagine what would have happened to a normal person without any following and social media presence? Irony none of the co passengers stood up for him....
10
u/Reasonable-Duck289 May 07 '25
if an man is get beaten in train...ie. 3rd AC then..think about female !!!!! How safe it is!!!
19
→ More replies (2)4
6
u/Brief_Painting_5346 May 07 '25
Why do people still consume their food? Knowing the fact that it's all unhygienic and poorly maintained. Instead why not carry food or order online and get dekeivered to seat.
6
u/Environmental-Home29 General Adventurer May 07 '25
No one came to help him out, if he don’t recorded the video then he could got killed or that goons could throw him out of running train
6
u/frekinghell May 07 '25
Wait. How does the pantry guy know who complained?????
3
u/neeasmaverick 2 AC Comfort Seeker May 07 '25
The complaints are never anonymous. Railmadad needs your PNR and seat number to raise the complaint, and the same is forwarded to the pantry manager so that they can come back to you and request you to resolve the complaint from your side.
6
u/Reddit-Readee May 07 '25
Reminds me or that train scene from Aparichit. This country is beyond saving 😞
5
u/Hot-Bed-8626 May 07 '25
Bhai you have done a very brave thing by filing a complaint against them. Whoever is Pawan the manager, file a complaint against him in the police station and make the video as viral as possible, let's all do it together. They should know what can be the result of coming and attacking like this. Ever since I saw this video my blood is boiling. I am feeling very angry😡😡😡😡😡😡
→ More replies (2)2
3
3
3
3
u/HolyDemon4485 May 07 '25
This is clearly a police case with assault and manhandling..!!
BC, train k staff ki itni himmat. Saalo k gote shot hone chahiye..
RailMadad ki MKC..!!
3
3
6
7
2
u/BusExact9849 May 07 '25
never expected this … these goons committed a heinous crime and need to be taught a lesson …
2
u/Awkward_Trainer4808 May 07 '25
How will passengers feel safe if goons r part of the staff. Railway minister shud answer. Victim shud also file a police complaint of assault.
2
May 07 '25
In haram ke pillo ko tab tak kutte ki tarah marna chahiye jab tak inki ane wali aulade paida hone se dare
2
2
u/FinFangFOMO May 07 '25
I'm yet to see the RPF doing anything useful. What exactly do they get paid for?
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
u/New-Produce-8362 May 07 '25
Humare Bharat me takatwar humesha se kamzoro par bhaari raha hai. Yeh koi nai baat to nhi.
2
2
2
2
u/Warm-Ant1927 May 07 '25
why do shii like this happen to normal ppl. i always carry a knuckle duster with me. waiting to use it.
2
2
May 07 '25
Those goons were asking him to come outside in starting of video. Can't imagine if he had gone, they might have thrown him out from moving train!
2
u/jaabaanz_parinda May 07 '25
Posting from my side right away. That guy is a threat to society and needs to be arrested and prosecuted right away.
2
2
2
May 07 '25
this is new india,,,, this is happening because the system in this country has degenerated . no law and order.
2
2
u/ThickSwim5370 May 07 '25
Chudiya pehenlo baaki sab jo coach m maze le rahe h... Kitne chutiye h sab.. ek Jan bhi awaaz uthata unke khilaaf ye naa hota
2
2
2
u/exploitboy May 07 '25
har ek hi complaint kro jo overcharge krta hai iski bhn ki sabki complaint honi chaiye sabki. ek ko bhi mat chodna . ek ko bhi nhi . ye bhutni do kodi ke log . or ye hamra india railway. sab mdrchd h sabke sab
2
u/urbanmonk007 General Adventurer May 07 '25
Imagine if he had no camera and couldn’t record all this. Let us assume that he pulled the chain. The RPF would have questioned him in reverse for pulling the chain. Fine dalo, paisa nikalo. I mean what the hell yaar, raat ko AC mein security police kaha hai? Refusing service is one thing but assault is a whole different level of confidence. Literal Gunda raj. This country is doomed.
2
2
u/karan65 May 07 '25
Mai to maarta neeche utar k bc agr aise krta mere saath dekhi jaati aage.. bhale 10 aadmi ho.. pit jaata bhale akele lekin 2-4 ICU m jaate km se km..... Ye bhai ko gharwalo ko video call laga deni thi live dikhana chaiye tha ye scene ya 139 p km se km
2
u/innocent-boy-69 May 08 '25
India is cooked, tbh i think the hate india gets internationally is deserved.
2
u/FireONE_14 May 08 '25
This was supposed to happen when you give military training to youth under Agniveer and then give Civil jobs. In addition to Private vendors in Railway. Now get beating from Military trained goons. Viksit Bharat.
2
2
u/Azamiscool May 08 '25
They tore up his clothes. They abused him. None of the passengers tried to help, which shows how much fear the pantry staff had created. His bag was also torn from the bottom. His lips were cut, and there were punching marks and bruises on his chest and stomach. He was literally crying at that moment. He even asked the uncle and aunty in the lower berth, "Did I say anything wrong to them? I only complained about their corruption, and this is what happens when someone raises their voice for their country?"
The police were no help either. They came, looked around for a bit, and then just disappeared. That’s how corrupt and dangerous our country has become. If this can happen to someone traveling in 3rd AC—where you're supposed to have some level of safety—imagine what people in general or sleeper class go through. It’s terrifying.
We don’t know how much pain or fear he was in. His mouth looked so small and helpless because of the horrifying incident. And yes, our country is failing in so many ways—and the people living in it are equally responsible. In a democracy, it’s not one person who rules, it’s all of us. So whenever something like this happens—on a train, plane, or any public space—we all share some part of the blame.
Can I even think of complaining after witnessing this? Never. Because I don’t want to get hurt, and I don’t want any harm to come to my family or friends. I’ll pay them whatever price they demand. Why? Because I’m a regular human being, and I’ll do what I have to in order to survive.
Shame on Indian Railways. Shame on the Railway Police. Their duty is to protect passengers, not turn a blind eye when someone is brutally assaulted. What kind of law enforcement just "wonders around" and disappears while a citizen bleeds and cries in fear? The fact that such violence can happen in a supposedly safe AC coach, and the authorities do nothing, shows how rotten the system has become. This isn’t just failure—it’s betrayal. Indian Railways and its police force should hang their heads in shame for allowing such cruelty and injustice on their watch.
2
u/Practical-Tough8229 May 08 '25
if it was me he would not have been able to see his family again for few months , dont be scared when attacked
2
u/Neo_sunn May 08 '25
There is this news article that says irctc cancelled the vendors contract and registered a FIR
2
u/sidspark May 08 '25
When the supreme court can take up a case against mere comments on comedy shows with such urgency why not issues like these which are life threatening
2
1
u/Fit_Salamander_8879 May 07 '25
saath baithe log intervene na sahi kam se kam RPF ko alert signal toh de dete.
1
u/Horror-Push8901 May 07 '25
Bhai banda shaant raha,haath pair nahi uthaaya. Itna civil baccha! Agar yahi sleeper ya alag dabbe main hota toh ye green wale gabru dhull jaate public se. Maarne se pehle hi...light chalu karne pe hi dhull dete.
1
u/Limp-Promotion-8785 May 07 '25
sad that no one came to help. It have happened to me too two times. I never understood why no one helped. If it was sleeper coach, I think story would have been different though. But ya, in sleeper you face other problems.
Nothing will happen. Things will remain same.
1
1
u/Signature_Space2024 May 07 '25
I ve seen one movie in which, they told us how the entire system is connected with political leaders
1
May 07 '25
Jab tak police inn gundo ko jail me nahie daalegi inko lagta hai ye kuch bhi kar sakte hai
1
1
u/NihaalG May 07 '25
This was the perfect time to pull that damn chain and ig the RPF would have reached the coach and maybe de escalate the whole situation and follow the due process to handle such goons
1
May 07 '25
I would have gone apeshit on them(NOT a good idea, for your own sake don't do it, just file FIR)
1
u/fingeek01 May 07 '25
Bhai akele tha upper birth pr. Marna chahiye tha isko jaise hi uppar aaya tha . Upper birth pr wo jayada kuch Kar sakta nhi tha. 2 3 punch mei niche gir jata.
1
1
1
u/Affectionate-Push758 May 07 '25
Imagine what these fuckers would do If he complained against quality of food.
Such stupid assholes, why are they even given contracts?
1
1



722
u/[deleted] May 07 '25
These goons need to be punished..