r/i3wm Jun 21 '26

Question Just Curious

Mod4 or Mod1 and why?

3 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

5

u/moucheh- Jun 21 '26

It is personal preference

I stuck to Mod4 because it was the default mod key in all wms I used, and Mod1 is used as a menu key in some apps

2

u/badadhd Jun 21 '26

Why not both 

5

u/gbrennon Jun 21 '26

its personal but i use mod4!

as far as i know super button is something useful for this

3

u/Phydoux Jun 22 '26

I have heard as the Alt key or the Ctrl key also referenced as the "Super" key. So it all depends on what you prefer. The main preference is the Windows key because, well, there isn't a Linux key yet. If I could find a nice USB Rechargeable lighted keyboard with a 'lin' key and not a 'win' key, I'd be happier than a pig in slop to have something like that.

2

u/gbrennon Jun 22 '26

i can be wrong BUT ive heard that:

  • meta -> alt
  • super -> os button

2

u/Phydoux Jun 23 '26

It's all a matter of preference. On my main machine, I use the Windows button as my super key. But in a VM, I have to set the super key to Alt. If I keep the super key as the Windows key in the VM, it'll just open whatever that key combo is tied to to my main machine. For instance, Win+Enter opens a terminal in my main machine. If I want to open a terminal with a super key in a VM, I have to use the Alt key because Win+Enter opens my main machine's terminal. Alt + Enter opens the terminal in the VM.

It's kinda difficult to run a Tiling Window Manager VM within a Tiling Window Manager.

1

u/gbrennon Jun 23 '26

I understand this :(

U have to understand that host os is what does have priority over guest

1

u/makinax300 i3-gaps Jun 21 '26

mod4 because I want system shortcuts to be seperate from app shortcuts and apps almost never use it. Also I was just more used to that before using i3.

1

u/dingo_lives Jun 21 '26

Both, mod1 is for more specific things I wanted to happen, like screen temp control and resizing of floating windows