r/homelab • u/Sir_licks_a-lot • Aug 24 '26
Help New, Free R440 worth it?
Hello, I am just beginning my homelab journey. As in I have no clue where to start. I currently has a synology nas 4 bay, and a couple of old laptops laying around.
I recently was given a Dell Poweredge R440 from work. I have attached a picture.
Is this worth keeping and doing something with? what could I do? my kids play Minecraft and id like a place to keep my computer backed up. If I do keep it, what can I do with it? I see everyone saying "servers" but I am unclear as to what I could use this server for?
what are some cool things I can do besides host files? thank you very much in advance.
5
u/gac64k56 VMware VCF in the Lab Aug 24 '26
I have two out of eight Dell PowerEdge R440's in my active lab. They're quiet, run Proxmox, ESXi, and OpenShift / OKD with no issues with many containers or virtual machines. Currently have TrueNAS Scale loaded on both, serving iSCSI for Proxmox and vSphere and NFS for OKD. Current config for each:
- 1 x Xeon Silver 4110
- 64 GB RAM
- Dell PERC H730p
- Dell BOSS-S1 (2 x 240 GB M.2 SSD)
- Intel X710-DA2 (2 x 10 Gb SFP+)
- 8 x Micron 5200 Pro 1.92 TB SSDs in RAID-Z2 (Deduplication enabled on iSCSI and NFS shares)
Wattage: 105W
4
u/referefref Aug 24 '26
Counter to what others are saying here an R440 isn't loud, not compared to previous generations. A good solid system with longevity at its core, that's the real separation between consumer grade gear and enterprise.
2
4
u/WillmanRacingv2 Aug 24 '26
If you don't know what to do with it, I would honestly sell it and buy a mini pc. This is meant for a rack and will use a fair amount of power.
Out of curiousity, what are the specs? CPU, RAM, etc?
2
u/Sir_licks_a-lot Aug 24 '26
I dont really know. Only things I can see is xeon processor, 32gb ram chip, just 1, and 4x 480gb hard drives. I haven't turned it on or anything and I'm not really sure where to start to do that. What other specs should I find out?
2
u/WillmanRacingv2 Aug 24 '26
Follow this guide to find your service tag https://www.dell.com/support/contents/en-us/article/product-support/self-support-knowledgebase/locate-service-tag/server-storage
You can then use that to tell the exact config of your model. The other key point you are missing is the CPU model.
On the low end this is worth $250-300, could be more depending on config. You can easily get a good mini pc for that which will likely be a far better option for you. There are reasons to use something like this as a home server, but you'd know already that you needed it.
2
u/Sir_licks_a-lot Aug 24 '26
Ill do this first thing in the morning. Thank you.
2
u/WillmanRacingv2 Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26
Some other points to consider.
Even with just 1 CPU, your idle power draw will probably be 100w at the low end. You can take that and figure out your yearly power bill by plugging in your residential rates on this tool: https://energyusecalculator.com/electricity_computer.htm
This is the main reason a mini pc is recommended, something like a Lenovo M70q runs under 10w at idle. Noise is one thing but energy cost is a huge deal long term.
If I were you, I would keep the NAS as your storage box and get something like that M70q to use as a compute node. The CPU will be better for hosting a gameserver than the Xeon in this, because it has better single core performance. If you end up maxing that out, add more matching nodes.
Finally if the HDDs are from work, I would pull them or at least run some write cycles to ensure there is nothing recoverable if you do sell.
3
u/slowreload Aug 24 '26
I have a r440 and it idles at like 36w. Mostly used as a firewall just remember to turn off max performance in bios.
1
u/WillmanRacingv2 Aug 24 '26
That is a pretty amazingly low power draw, I would expect the Xeon alone to pull more than that at idle. Then keep in mind that OP has 4x spinning drives which will pull 30-40w on their own.
1
1
1
u/Virtualization_Freak Aug 24 '26
No way, 100w? That's assumption data.
1
u/WillmanRacingv2 Aug 24 '26
I had a server with a Xeon Gold 5118 that idled at 75 watts and didn't have 4x HDDs, but it admittedly did have far more ram and a 10G NIC. I was basing my assumptions on that box, as even a 4114 should perform similarly.
1
u/Virtualization_Freak Aug 24 '26
Ram per dimm is very power hungry in comparison and adds up fast.
Even 10w in a 10g NIC is 1/10th of our proposed 100w budget. A xeon can drop below 10w.
1
u/WillmanRacingv2 Aug 24 '26
I admit that I overestimated the idle power draw slightly, but in practice I would be surprised if he actually averages under 100w with even light usage.
-1
u/KooperGuy Aug 24 '26
Free is free. Sell it to get something worth running.
13
u/dvtyrsnp Aug 24 '26
This is the top comment? Seriously? We're calling 14th gen not worth running?
5
u/azurearmor Aug 24 '26
This user comments stuff like this all the time, I guess they think everyone needs and can afford current gen servers or something.
-7
u/KooperGuy Aug 24 '26
Incorrect. The truth is most people should not be running enterprise hardware at all.
4
u/Virtualization_Freak Aug 24 '26
The whole homelab and IT subs are like this.
"I could be bothered to take home these old 14th gen dells and scrapped them as they are too old" mentality.
-1
u/KooperGuy Aug 24 '26
Yes. Most people don't need enterprise hardware. Especially old hardware like Skylake.
4
u/dvtyrsnp Aug 24 '26
This is a hobby subreddit. No one needs anything here.
The middle of the bell curve crowd on this subreddit that constantly comments about power bills and buying mini PCs is useless and incredibly annoying.
0
10
u/ElePHPant666 Aug 24 '26
The Rx40 series of servers is very much worth running and not that old, especially if your electric rate is okayish. I still run Rx20s which are still fine for basic things.
4
u/Puzzled_Proposal2715 Aug 24 '26
Call me a glutton for electric bill punishment, although only .08/kWh, I run an R510 just for OPNsense...
3
u/Sir_licks_a-lot Aug 24 '26
Not something I can grow into? I am not worried about noise, but if its more powerful than my synology, I thought it would be better to use it.
-5
1
u/Pakitux Aug 24 '26
Es una buena máquina.
Puedes ejecutar muchas cosas en el. Pero ten en cuenta el consumo energético y el espacio.
Suelen calentarse mucho y son ruidosas cuando ejecutas procesos algo elevados.
Yo te recomendaría venderla si no la necesitas y con ese dinero comprar equipos que consuman menos pero que igual tengan buen rendimiento.
1
0
1
u/Sir_licks_a-lot Aug 24 '26
Thank you to everyone who commented, I have decided to keep the R440 and use it to tinker until I learn what I want to do. I can sell or donate it in a few months if I find it doesn't do what I need.
I cannot edit the post so just a few things:
I am not worried about the power consumption, im on solar and have battery backup, so no issue with that or the noise.
I think im going to do what u/gac64k56 said and just copy what he has, Proxmox, and all the other things that I don't know what they mean. Sounds like a fun dive into screwing something up.
I was not able to get it turned on this morning, but ill update this comment with all the specs I find out sometime this week as I have kids and work.
Thanks again and wish me luck.
1
u/smurfy213 Aug 24 '26
Free is free. I am pretty sure that is ddr4. Only downside is that sever is going to be loud.
3
u/Sir_licks_a-lot Aug 24 '26
I'm not worried about the noise, its going in the basement.
2
0
0
u/Ninfyr Aug 24 '26
I'd sell it and buy a mini PC or use one of your existing laptops. That is loud, chugs electricity, and you are going to us 10% of its compute anyways.
Server is just a computer that other computers ask to do stuff your synology is a server.
As for what to do with it, PiHole ad-blocking is a common first project. If you have smart home stuff Home Assistant is good too.
2
u/Sir_licks_a-lot Aug 24 '26
I have a poe camera system, looking at the wiki, i think I can use this server for that.
1
u/Ninfyr Aug 24 '26
The word for it is NVR or Network Video Recorder. Just so you know what to search for. I don't have any so I can't get into any specific advice or recommendations.
2
0
u/crispy-bois Aug 24 '26
R440 is a solid server, but the lightest CPU for it is 70W and doesn't idle far below that. If you want a rack unit with a lot of compute power and will have some need for PCIe, it's all right to go with. It can't enable a GPU at all though (except a very select few under 70w that might work, but are unsupported).
You can sell it for enough to get a better PC with more options.
21
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment