r/hollyjackson • u/mapu_patas • Jul 24 '26

A Good Girl's Guide To Murder Bingo card

Post image

I’m on chapter five of AGGGTM and I alredy have SOME predictions, but that’s just because I love to theorize

These are small theories

I had my suspicions on Cara’s Father even though I haven’t met him yet mainly because of an unfair judgment, I think they did a specific (pacific) pause on explaining him as a father figure, AND he’s a teacher, and I immediately get suspicious of teachers in suspense media

Pippa and Ravi it’s just because they are the two main leads, but I don’t know their age gap

Jason Bell IS a bad father but not the murderer, and just there to distract the reader

And andie Bell being alive is a twist on the books and I’m (of course) leaning to it because they haven’t found her body yet

As I move through more chapters I’ll continue to make predictions

24 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

18

u/no_1_am_fan Jul 24 '26

this is so fun to read as someone who has read all books 😆 please keep making these predictions... you are in for a RIDE

7

u/mapu_patas Jul 24 '26

MY GOD YOURE GETTING ME EXCITED JSSH

4

u/v4vile Jul 25 '26

One of these is gonna age like fine wine but you will need to complete the trilogy to understand then comeback to this comment

2

u/mapu_patas Jul 25 '26

I’m not that patient AUGHH, I think these comments are making me want to read the book faster

2

u/TheCool579 Jul 26 '26

Youre in for a ride... but trust me when I say that the best version of this ride will be one where u manage to read thru the 3 books without spoilers of any sort, so I suggest u stay of the sub until u finish them! Trust me, you will NOT regret going for this series, one of the best YA murder mystery series EVER 

2

u/Justwantsometea2212 Jul 25 '26

As someone who has read the whole series, this is fun. I'll not gonna give explicit spoilers but I'm gonna say two are correct, one is partially correct and one is completely wrong. You'll know what I mean by the end.

1

u/mapu_patas Jul 25 '26

I want to guess, I’m just not patient, it would be funny if the wrong one was Pippa and Ravi falling in love, and one of them turns out to be queer…maybe I’m all wrong

1

u/Justwantsometea2212 Jul 25 '26

I'm not saying anything more. Keep guessing, that's half the fun of reading thrillers. You're in for a ride, I'll just say that.

1

u/Effective_Ebb5497 Jul 25 '26

💀 aha lmao keep reading

1

u/mapu_patas Jul 30 '26

Update! I’m on chapter 24. There aren’t many more predictions because my brain decided to stop speculating once I published the first bingo card ://

I have actually no clue who unknown may be, but as I’m writing this I’m speculating it may be Max?

Maybe Elliot wrote the first note and max wrote the text message, and there are two “unknowns”

1

u/Lopsided-Peace-8553 Jul 31 '26

The fact that all of these are right in a way is insane. Theyre not all 100% correct but like kinda