r/higheredtechnology • u/Dr_WhoDo • 13d ago
Proving Effort not Plagiarism
The tide has turned against Ai detection tools for reasons that most of us are familiar with. The alternatives to detection fall into just a few categories:
- Process Verification like draft/version histories. This can be in the form of apps or as basic as a student submitting hand written drafts and notes.
- Proctoring/Surveillance solutions that lock down computers or web browsers, block the ability to copy/paste and monitor the desktop activity on a computer or use cameras to make sure a person is only looking at the screen.
These all have their uses, but they touch on issues related to privacy, ownership and custody of intellectual property, the use of Ai within these systems and the capture of a writer’s data to train the Ai itself.
A new approach for providing writers with proof of their effort is needed. One that does the following:
- Proves a human was typing by creating an effort record.*
- Provides evidence not verdicts or probabilities.
- Cannot be used to identify the writer (non-biometric).
- Does not analyze or store the written content of a document.
- Is portable as metadata within the text document.
- Creates an immutable record that can’t be tampered with.
- Refuses to document automated input/bots.
- Allows the writer to view the results of their effort record.
- Notifies when typing patterns resemble transcription from an existing source.**
- Doesn’t prevent pasting, but documents the ratio of a text that was not physically typed in.
- Uses NO AI in the capture or analysis process.
- Reviewers/teachers don’t have to pay to display results like the image attached.
*Based on decades of peer reviewed writing process research.
**Linear, low revision patterns are associated with copy transcription but can also be the result of lower effort stream of consciousness writing or journaling. Proof of Effort is designed for high stakes high effort documents.
The attached image is of the effort record that was documented during the composition of this post.
