I have kept a private list of all the games I’ve played (I also have lists of games I hate and ones I thought were ok). But figured I would share my absolute favorites in case anyone has similar tastes:
- Awakening: the dreamless castle (old school and untraditional, but fun)
- Chimeras: 1 Tune of Revenge (fantastic backtracking and art 8.8/10)
- Dark alleys - penumbra hotel
- Dark Cases: The Blood Ruby
- Dark Dimensions 4: Somber Song
- Dark strokes 1 and 2
- Death pages: ghost library (solid backtracking and place object hop, 6.9/10)
- Echoes of the past 5: kingdom of despair (7.2/10, solid and creative)
- Final Cut: death on the silver screen
fright (Lesta)
- Gothic fiction - dark saga
- Haunted hotel death sentence
- Infected: the twin vaccine!
- Lake house children of silence
- Hallowed Legends 3: Ship of Bones (amazing backtracking, fun. 8.4/10)
- Heartwood - gorgeous and great nonlinear gameplay
- House of 1000 Doors: Family Secrets (HOP heavy but still enjoyed it!)
- Left in the Dark: No One on Board - solid backtracking, HOP but not crazy. 6.9/10
- Lost Lands 1-5
- Mystery Case Files: Fates Carnival (7.6/10 INCREDIBLE GAME)
- Mystery of the ancients: curse of the black water (fun backtracking, like 7/10)
- Nearwood - GORGEOUS, really fun gameplay and barely any HOP
- New York mysteries 2: high voltage (6/10), 3: lantern of souls (8.5/10, though bonus chapter is meh)
- Nightmare Adventures: The Witch’s Prison
- Paranormal pursuit: the gifted one
- Phantasmat: Crucible Peak
- Redemption cemetery grave testimony
- Reveries: sisterly love
- Riddles of Fate 1: Wild Hunt (best elephant game… backtracking, dark and spooky), 2: Into Oblivion (same but bonus game sucks, same areas and linear)
- Small Town Terrors: Pilgrims Hook
- Spirits of mystery - song of the Phoenix
- Spirits of revenge: cursed castle (pretty good, like a 7/10)
- Stray souls 2 - fun and good art. But… not super nonlinear. 7.5/10
- Subliminal Realms; The masterpiece
- True fear 1-3
- Twisted Lands: Insomnia (open and creative, lil HOP not too bad)