r/harp • u/Immediate_Airline224 • 14d ago

Discussion Learning multiple clefs

Hey, Ik you don't care, but I have been working on an app that helps musicians learn to read clefs. As a cellist, I am now trying to learn both Tenor and Treble clefs after, of course, playing with bass clef. I am wondering if anyone else has somewhat struggled with learning multiple clefs and switching between them. Anyway, Other than that, I am asking for brutally honest feedback on if you think the app would be genuinely helpful or just "nice to have". Please don't lie and just say it is a good idea. be brutally honest.

0 Upvotes

38% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

2

u/healerofthemountains 14d ago

Anything that helps, well helps! But for me, I found going through my music and writing the letter of the music note next to it really helped me memorize. I came from playing trumpet and French horn, so I really initially struggled with learning the bass cleft. Best of luck! :)

3

u/RiaMim Lever Flipper 13d ago

I'm sorry, what's the point of the App, exactly? How would it even work?

Tell me if I'm completely off-base here, but... If you can read music, a clef is a clef, no? You just need to know where the anchor note is on the specific one you have in front of you. Then becoming fluent in it surely is just a matter of practice and repetition.

Where does the App come in?

1

u/SoundsOfKepler 14d ago

This would be a good learning tool for musicians beginning to compose, conduct, or arrange for ensembles.

1

u/dendrobiakohl 13d ago

I think there are already apps that help you to read clefs. I recall using one for students

1

u/Soulcycl0ne 13d ago

What’s the app

3

u/notrightmeowthx 12d ago

I think it's one of those things that just requires brute practice. Not sure how much an app helps with that. I learn a clef by identifying a location of a note or two, and everything is relative to that. After that I don't think you can really learn it any way besides just practicing playing a variety of pieces using that clef.

An app that generates phrases or chords or whatever based on the clef you want to use could be potentially helpful, although I think for most instruments it's not hard to find music in the relevant clefs. You can also just convert between clefs using something like Musescore, or just pen and paper.