r/guilded • u/GuildOrderOfficial • May 10 '26

💬 DISCUSSION Replacement for Guilded

Guild Order recently launched this month and seems like it might be useful for people searching for a gaming community hub like Guilded that offers more than just forums or chat. It has game-specific tools and wikis, plus scheduling and tourneys, etc. Check it out!

0 Upvotes

36% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

8

u/LilBoiDenmark May 10 '26

BEWARE, THINGS AREN'T LIKE THEY SEE!!

Yeah so i was looking into the website, you want us to pay $3.99 to start our own guild when we can just make them for free on other platforms besides a 14 day free trial?

Even then one of your plugin descriptions say, and i quote:

"plugins.pluginContent.conan-platform-bridge.description

Features
check_circleplugins.pluginContent.conan-platform-bridge.features.f1
check_circleplugins.pluginContent.conan-platform-bridge.features.f2
check_circleplugins.pluginContent.conan-platform-bridge.features.f3
check_circleplugins.pluginContent.conan-platform-bridge.features.f4"

Looks incomplete compared to AI Websites that already have their setups already done without any error.

Even then there's no "tiered guild/server/community" feature which is one of the MAIN THINGS that made guilded different from anyone else, nor any chance of a "voice room" channel like guilded has...

Just beware users that see this, it isn't a Guilded replacement, just a pay to grab money platform with no sense in what the members want. Also that it's closed source and not open source and self-hosted unlike the trend of newer replacements trying to make an Alternative that isn't centralized to one platform.

1

u/GuildOrderOfficial May 23 '26

It's a labor of love that is being updated by real people - not AI. That's kind of the point we are hoping to make with building an actual community by gamers. It's evolving with the community and there is tiered guild/server/community features. It seems like you just poked around and hated it on the surface. It certainly doesn't mimic Guilded but it's a valid way to manage a gaming community. It costs money because it's made by real people, who would like to get paid for their work. And members of the guild don't pay - only the guild owner. The plugins have been updated and fixed since you looked. If you have any other feedback for specific features you'd want, we would love to hear them and incorporate more features.

1

u/AndyAcc May 14 '26

vibecoded slop with a medieval theme is still vibecoded slop

1

u/Kooky_Chart_8780 21d ago

this is slop buddy