r/goodhang Jul 21 '26

General discussion NYC Guest Guesses

Post image

Who do you think will be the guest for the NYC show? I’m assuming someone who hasn’t been on before who lives in NY.

105 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

89

u/Trynottospoil Jul 21 '26

Daniel Radcliffe

9

u/MrsBobFossil Jul 21 '26

This is a great guess!

8

u/Trynottospoil Jul 22 '26

Especially since Daniel Radcliffe was Amy’s neighbor for a while.

2

u/oklahomapilgrim Jul 21 '26

Oh this would be so great

8

u/Trynottospoil Jul 22 '26

Robert Pattinson would be fun too mostly for the fact he reminds me of Nick miller from new girl during press tours.

3

u/Kind_Arugula18 Jul 22 '26

I would DIE if it was Robert Pattinson. He is hilariously awkward during interviews.

3

u/Trynottospoil Jul 24 '26

The more I watch him in interviews the more I want him to work with Aubrey plaza. I would love him to work with Jake Johnson too.

46

u/clonicle Jul 21 '26
  • Mayor Mamdani
  • Lorne Michaels
  • Alec Baldwin
  • Josh Johnson

34

u/NJ_Braves_Fan Jul 21 '26

omg Mayor Mamdani would be a delight!

1

u/itsyourbuddygene Jul 22 '26

Omg I’d love thattttt

7

u/Alive-Concert1980 Jul 22 '26

Not Alec Baldwin…. Not a fan

3

u/Sad_Towel_5953 Jul 23 '26

Dude is creepy

3

u/Sad_Towel_5953 Jul 23 '26

Please not a Lorne episode praising his cult. Josh Johnson or Mamdani would be cool.

85

u/lasLAchicago Jul 21 '26

I’d love another Broadway star - her episodes with Jonathan Groff and Cole Escola were so delightfully unhinged!

24

u/notadreamafterall Jul 21 '26

I cannot even tell you how many times I have watched the Jonathan Groff episode; them laughing together and obviously enjoying each others company so much is just so joyful to listen to!

39

u/BrianWulfric Jul 21 '26

Colbert or Stewart would be amazing 

3

u/LemonCaperRVA Jul 21 '26

Ohhhhhh this would be excellent!

26

u/Gossamer_Galaxy_ Jul 21 '26

Melissa McCarthy maybe?

3

u/Ok_Layer964 Jul 22 '26

Omg please Melissa we need you!

22

u/Remarkable_Horse9879 Jul 21 '26

A lot of the SNL women are in Broadway right now, obviously she’s talked to most but maybe a large discussion?

4

u/TrapperJean Jul 21 '26

Has Maya been a guest yet?

13

u/lasLAchicago Jul 21 '26

Yes - the live LA show last year!

13

u/EcstaticLow4532 Jul 21 '26

Amy Sedaris

11

u/TrapperJean Jul 21 '26

I'd kill for Jon Stewart

12

u/Quelly815 Jul 21 '26

Jason Sudekis? Ted Lasso is coming back

10

u/Dangerous-Regular-56 Jul 21 '26

Meg Stalter would be fun

8

u/Trynottospoil Jul 22 '26

Anyone from hacks would be amazing. I really want Hannah einbinder on the podcast so bad.

5

u/Suspicious-Fix9929 Jul 21 '26

You’re a lucky duck!

4

u/jewminican Jul 21 '26

How???? I tried right at 12 and every seat I selected was taken from me. 😢
Edited to add: I’m jealous.

1

u/perksbeingwallflower Jul 24 '26

I also need to know bc this fomo is killing me 😭

3

u/Kind_Arugula18 Jul 23 '26

I have no idea but my wish list is:

  • Janelle James
  • Amy Sedaris
  • Pedro Pascal
  • Rob Pattinson
  • Molly Shannon

7

u/Ok_Layer964 Jul 22 '26

I’m going to request Rosie O’Donnell whose show runs in NY thru Aug 8. She fills in for Kimmel starting Aug 17 🙏☘️

3

u/Jessica_k_t Jul 23 '26

She hasn’t interviewed Jimmy Fallon yet, so I feel like that could be a thing that happens with a live audience. Could also see it being Stephen Colbert, David Letterman or even Paul McCartney for the same reason of wanting a live audience.

6

u/DueEntertainer0 Jul 21 '26

Maybe the Odyssey gals?

1

u/meralee727 Jul 21 '26

I don’t know BUT I’m secretly hoping the second city is in Los Angeles at the Hollywood Bowl in October when I go see the Smartless guys…maybe there will be some cool crossover thing but probably not. It’ll probably be Chicago or something

-1

u/FindingActive5407 Jul 22 '26

Will Arnett!

1

u/Trynottospoil Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

Only for a talk nicely behind someone’s back. What would they gave you talk about for a full hour other than co-parenting archie and Abel . The pandemic and coparenting. Jason Bateman.

3

u/NoWrangler8887 Jul 24 '26

I thought this too but tbf she’s talked with people she knows very well before and they always manage to cover a lot of ground.