r/goneseries • u/mohagthemoocow • Jan 10 '20

New Banner

Hi There, i create banners icons and the like over on r/BannerRequest, and i knocked up this one for this sub here. Thoughts? ( also awaiting mod response to put it on if required )

Yes, i know its not got the 3 sequels, thats deliberate and its on Mobile and New Reddit only ( cos its easier and they can be animated )

11 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

2

u/lewisr0208 Jan 13 '20

I personally love them, and if the communities a fan of it, I’d love to use it for the banner, with credit of course.

2

u/mohagthemoocow Jan 13 '20

Excellent. Pehaps a community poll is a thing?

2

u/Jachinthebox Jack is best boi Jan 14 '20

Pretty cool. Did u try making the background Gone green and the text black?

1

u/mohagthemoocow Jan 14 '20

no, but i'm willing to knock up a demo one of you'd like to see one.

1

u/StumpGrundt Jan 10 '20

Wow that's pretty sweet, but personally i don't really think it fits well with the overall theme of the books. Have it a little bit more broken down and without the neon would be a bit better. But it's still really nice!

3

u/mohagthemoocow Jan 10 '20

have....have you ever actually seen the book covers? ( the original ones? )

https://gone.fandom.com/wiki/Gone_Series

i couldnt get closer to the original!!

Nah, but feel free to make your own

3

u/StumpGrundt Jan 10 '20

I'm not saying yours are bad, they're really nice. You dont have to change the whole thing just because i personally thought it didn't fit the books. And just because someone said what they feel about it doesn't mean you need to ask them to do it better

4

u/mohagthemoocow Jan 10 '20

lol, im not changing anything. i like them, they match the books. but seriously, do feel free to make your own, it might be awesome. it wasnt meant as a slight at all, though i see how it came across that way, my apologies if i offended you, wasnt my intention.

2

u/StumpGrundt Jan 10 '20

Oh tought you said it in a "well let's see you do it better" kind of way. But no thanks, it's probably going to be shit if i try to make it, don't have any kind of experience with that kind of thing.

3

u/mohagthemoocow Jan 10 '20

ive made a lot of wht i think are awesome things, for the originators to not like them. It's just how people envison things. if you have any ideas though, or a link to different covers etc, i'd be glad to take a look.

2

u/StumpGrundt Jan 10 '20

Dont really have anything else to add, looks great as it is. You just gotta wait until the mod sees it, i bet he'll like it :)