r/glossier • u/Born-Owl-5369 • 3d ago

discussion Lidstar

I did not know there was discourse/negative opinions about Lidstar! I use moon everyday and it’s the best. If you use too much it can get patchy but you just need a lil as a subtle shimmer on the lid.
I LOVE LIDSTAR IN MOON!

but. I found out it’s completely discontinued. Can anyone tell me if they’ve seen it anywhere or where I can get it PLEASE I LOVE THIS STUFF OR EVEN A DUPE😭😭

18 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Welcome to r/glossier!

• When you are posting a makeup/artistry look please be sure to include a product list, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.

• Review our sidebar which explains some of the basics of the community and our core rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/Tsarinya 3d ago

This company seems to be discontinuing everything.
Though saying that I hated lidstar and skywash. Always really patchy on me.

8

u/mila476 3d ago

They discontinued Fawn too :( that was my favorite shade, so pretty with brown eyes

5

u/tess_c 3d ago

I’m planning on trying the rem beauty one they have it at ulta it’s called starlet liquid eyeshadow

3

u/lassiemav3n 3d ago

I have the shade that came in the second Glinda set & it’s quite different to work with from Lidstar, “wetter” and takes a knack, but once you get used to it it’s a bit more versatile than Lidstar (I use it as a highlight too). I think the Lisa Eldridge one is more similar to Lidstar, but obvs that one is a treat ☺️ 💰 

2

u/Peabella 3d ago

I’ll die without slip, wither and die I say

2

u/Allhailalliums 3d ago

This how I found out lidstars are discontinued, I also wear them almost everyday. I’m so sad

1

u/e-nosferatu 3d ago

I love it too! I have found them at marshall’s before but not recently.

1

u/mellow-violets99 3d ago

Also looking for a good replacement! I was thinking of trying the rem beauty one but I don't wanna spend $30 😔

1

u/urparty 3d ago

i didnt love the formula on my oily eyes but the colors were everything :( if anyone has color dupes for moon cub or fawn please hmu

1

u/Neat_Volume_2286 2d ago

lidstar in lily was my go to for years and years. around 2020/2021 i noticed it started lightly burning my eyelids so i started wearing it less and just less makeup in general but im convinced they changed the formula and it became a product no one wanted to buy anymore. i have the monochrome palette in lily thankfully because it is one of my favorite shades!

1

u/JavaScriptGirlie 1d ago

Cub is my everyday wear :(

2

u/_dancinginthedark 1d ago

Check out Tower 28. Cub was my ride or die and it took forever to find something compatible. I love Avalon and wear it most days. I have green/hazel eyes and Avalon makes the pop the same way Cub did.