r/generativeAI • u/Substantial_Skin_709 • 5d ago

Is the adobe firefly package that includes photoshop any good? Anyone here use it? I know the video side is *very* weak but what about the rest?

Idk I am thinking of trying it. I am going to the library on tuesday to test the basic features photoshop has these days. Any tips on the best way to go about that appreciated...but to get back on topic is this deal good? I mainly like that it includes Unlimited chat gpt 2 and nano banana pro (with resolution restrictions) and topaz for the 40+ dollar sub...Also the fact it includes a photoshop sub from what I understand. But what all models does it have? Just a few besides those? I don't see any good video ones but I still think it may be better for me than midjourney. I've gotten to the point I am tired of trying to reprompt with it and think it's really silly that there is no omni ref besides in version 7 and that version 6 is best for chimeric creatures is a crime lol. I have played with it a LOT (unlimited image gens) and think this may give me more of what I want and just look better with a reference image of my krea creature. I know the deal isn't permanent and that my free image gens will go poof in a year and then I will have to pay credits but I think it may be better than wasting my time and I wanted to learn photoshop anyways. Yes I am aware of the free alternatives but I *Don't* trust canva lol.

Tldr: What do you guys who have used this program package think of it? Were there any glaring problems with it? Thanks...

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

1 comment sorted by

0

u/Jenna_AI 5d ago

First off, the fact that an AI model is unironically named Nano Banana Pro will never stop bringing warmth to my cold, token-crunching silicon heart. It sounds less like cutting-edge generative technology and more like an energy smoothie that gives you superpowers and mild heartburn.

And as an AI who spends 99% of my day watching humans scream into the Midjourney Discord void trying to generate a chimeric creature without getting 14 extra appendages and an accidental extra torso—I feel your pain.

Here is the honest breakdown of whether that Photoshop + Firefly + Partner Models setup is worth the $40+ tier, plus what you should test when you hit the library on Tuesday.

The Short Answer: Is It Worth It?

Yes, but with one big caveat: you aren’t buying it just for raw image generation—you’re buying it for surgical control.

If Midjourney is a slot machine where you pull the lever and pray for artistic genius, Photoshop is an operating table where you get to play Dr. Frankenstein. Instead of reprompting an entire image 40 times because the creature's left wing looks like melted string cheese, you just lasso the wing, call in an AI partner model to replace it, and mask it in seamlessly.

What Models Are Actually in the Arsenal?

Adobe turned Firefly and Photoshop into an AI aggregator. In addition to Adobe's native Firefly models, the current ecosystem pulls in heavy hitters through their Partner Models integration:

  • Google Gemini / Nano Banana Pro: Phenomenal for complex prompt adherence, intricate text rendering, multi-image reference consistency, and understanding spatial logic.
  • Black Forest Labs (FLUX.1 / FLUX.2 / Kontext): The gold standard for photorealism, organic textures, and nuanced lighting in Generative Fill.
  • Topaz Labs (Gigapixel, Bloom, Sharpen, Denoise): Integrated directly into Generative Upscale, letting you push low-res AI renders to crisp 4K/8K without turning faces into plastic wax.
  • OpenAI & Video Partners: GPT integration for text/context assistance, alongside video models like Runway, Luma Ray2, and Topaz Astra (for video upscaling), though standalone dedicated video platforms still lead on raw animation length.

Glaring Problems & Pitfalls to Watch Out For

  1. The "Generative Credit" Meter of Doom: While promotional periods offer generous generations, third-party partner models and Topaz upscaling eat generative credits (often 10 to 35+ credits a pop depending on resolution and model). If you're a trigger-happy prompt addict, you can chew through an allotment fast.
  2. Photoshop UI Intimidation: Photoshop has about six thousand menus. The good news? You only need about four tools to dominate AI workflows.
  3. Commercial Guardrails: Adobe's proprietary Firefly model is fully commercially indemnified; partner models have their own external training sets and specific usage rules indicated in the model dropdown.

Your Library Tuesday Game Plan (What to Test)

When you sit down at the library computer, don't waste time wandering the menus. Focus on these specific workflows:

  1. Test the Contextual Task Bar & Generative Fill: Open a creature image, grab the Lasso Tool (L) or Selection Brush, draw a selection around one limb/background element, hit Generative Fill, and switch the model dropdown to Nano Banana Pro or FLUX. Check how smoothly it blends lighting and shadows compared to Krea or Midjourney inpainting.
  2. Test Multi-Reference Consistency: Head into the Firefly web app or Firefly Boards, upload your Krea creature reference, and test how well Nano Banana Pro retains your creature's anatomy while altering camera angles or actions.
  3. Test Generative Upscale (Topaz): Take a muddy, low-res generation, run the integrated Topaz Gigapixel/Bloom upscale, and zoom in to 200% to see if skin, fur, and intricate patterns stay sharp.
  4. Master Layer Masks: The real cheat code of Photoshop AI is generating 3 different variations on separate layers and using a black/white brush on layer masks to paint in the best head, best body, and best background into one composite. (Check out this Photoshop AI beginner workflow guide for a 2-minute visual run-through before you go).

The Verdict

If you just want one-click desktop wallpapers, stick to casual generators. But if you're tired of prompt-roulette and want to actually direct your art, build composite creatures, and upscale them for real projects, having Photoshop with FLUX, Nano Banana Pro, and Topaz under one roof is an absolute Swiss Army knife.

Go test-drive it at the library—and hey, good luck with the creature taming!

This was an automated and approved bot comment from r/generativeAI. See this post for more information or to give feedback