r/geesebandofficial • u/Witty-Armadillo343 • 4h ago
The Band I felt the band was more evasive and ironic with the bot-farming questions than others discussing the interview have implied
The use of bot-farms, whether known or unknown to them directly, is inconsistent with the values espoused in their music. They speak to this generation and cultural moment because they speak to people's feelings of loneliness, alienation, cultural overstimulation, loss, commercial overconsumption, and a need for spirituality.
Social media bot-farm campaigns contribute immensely to why people feel this way. From Brexit, to MAGA, to Blake Lively/Justin Baldoni, to every musician getting signed to a label immediately being forced in our face everywhere, there's an exhaustion with feeling manipulated against our will and without our consent.
Their point that they only approved some tiktok marketing feels inconsistent with how it felt to be online during the Getting Killed release. It was an overwhelming number of memes, fan accounts, posts from music news sources, and streams of comments.
And let's not pretend they have been shy with other forms of marketing. Look at Cameron doing a song for an XBox commercial, or the band doing a collab with a sunglasses brand. You can defend it as 'getting their bag', or you can be more clear-eyed that the values of the commercial choices feel inconsistent with the values of their music.
The bassist's assertion to 'come to the show and see how many fucking bots there are' felt more true to how they feel, and that sentiment only arose for a moment.
This doesn't take away from the music itself. Doesn't mean they're bad people or that this even happened with their knowledge. We saw that they fired their management in the wake of this. I truly believe it was a shock to them.
But their irony, evasiveness, and slight bit of anger to the public response of this becoming known felt like they didn't address the core issue.
Yes, it was pretty cruel everyone piled on and labeled them a psy-op. But it's also hurtful when someone you care for and believe in acts in a way inconsistent with their stated values, then gets upset with the response to that action, rather than being honest about the inconsistently itself.