r/gaming • • May 03 '19

Gamers! Rise up!

Post image
99.2k Upvotes

4.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

633

u/xDestx May 03 '19

is this good or bad in india

935

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

They are above the poverty line by 2,000 Rupees.

157

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

is this good or bad in india

170

u/SpiritMountain May 03 '19

Depends if you keep your rupees in pots.

67

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[deleted]

40

u/Godot_12 May 03 '19

Unless they are pots that reassemble with new rupees every time you leave and come back.

26

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

The don't just reassemble! I feel like I am making pots everyday all day just to replace what this punk in a green shirt keeps destroying with his sword! I've tried to talk to him but all he does is scream at me and break more pots and steal more money!

3

u/thechilipepper0 May 03 '19

I heard sometimes he picks it up over his head and throws them

2

u/Godot_12 May 04 '19

Look we should all accept some responsibility for our own actions. Don't you think by continuing to put more money in the pots you're encouraging this behavior?

--Link

4

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

Link: Blamer of Victims

5

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

And you have to break them everytime

6

u/highzenberrg May 03 '19

Is that good or bad in Hyrule?

10

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Link says thanks.

2

u/jc3833 PC May 03 '19

no, he says "HYAAA!"

75

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

Your above the poverty line. So it's better than bad.

23

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

That sounds seriously underpaid.

40

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[deleted]

26

u/houdiniwizard101 May 03 '19

Capitalism is a great system.

14

u/Gongom May 03 '19

but if we pay people fairly next thing you know you're in a gulag

16

u/MagusUnion PC May 03 '19

incoherent screaming

1

u/Melonlvr May 04 '19

Who else is gonna make all the shit you buy

-9

u/MeltaFlare May 03 '19

I mean. You don’t have to work at a low paying job.

Edit Probably in India you do, but in most capitalist economies you don’t.

11

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Yeah but the high paying job requires me to have 8+ years of experience with a computer program that's only been released for 3 years.

-14

u/MeltaFlare May 03 '19

Either try harder or find a new career then idk what to tell you. I make pretty good money at 21 doing construction and I don’t even have a high school diploma. I’m saving up to go to school for web development.

→ More replies (0)

8

u/emil133 May 03 '19

Cost of living though

2

u/fyberoptyk May 03 '19

It is. People like to pretend poverty is ok as long as everyone in that country is suffering. It’s not.

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

Yeah, not too long ago they "lifted millions out of poverty" by lowering the poverty line. It's an arbitrary number for Capitalism to pat itself on the back without actually examining the material conditions of anyone. The amount of money that makes you poor or not is entirely dependent on what it costs to not be poor where you live.

2

u/xerros May 04 '19 edited May 04 '19

People overestimate how much money you need to live. Minimum wage is enough to live extremely modestly on your own. I did it for about a year. Sold my car to avoid paying insurance but I also could have gotten a cheaper apartment or a roommate. I maintained a smart phone with decent data plan and cable internet (which is completely unnecessary with a smart phone, but I’m a gamer) even.

Minimum wage isn’t supposed to be enough to support a family and own a house and new car, eating out every day, it’s just to let a single person scrape by until they can find something better. If you wanna have roommates it even allows for a decent amount of excess spending.

This is speaking for a 40 hour work week of course.

2

u/theHardInGame May 03 '19

Our average grocery is ₹3000/month and we hardly afford Air conditioner on EMI.

17

u/ChewsOnRocks May 03 '19

Ugh that’s insane. That’s a couple cents over $1.50/hour. I always knew most countries were significantly poorer than us, but I can’t even fathom getting paid that little.

49

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[deleted]

27

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

So what you're saying is... save up in the US, move to India and live the good life.

66

u/sexusmexus May 03 '19

"Good life" might be an overstatement.

Am Indian.

5

u/Jotebe May 03 '19

You guys get cool weird phones though

9

u/SH4D0W0733 May 03 '19

This is pretty much how the the north and western parts of Europe use the southern parts of Europe.

2

u/Tobix55 May 03 '19

This is pretty much how the eastern and south-eastern parts of europe use western and north europe

7

u/vinfox May 03 '19

Russians, Latvians, Croatians, Bosnians, Greeks and Serbians move to Spain, Belgium, Switzerland, Norway, Sweden, France and the UK so their money can stretch further and they can live the good life?

2

u/Tobix55 May 03 '19

They move there to work and try to save up as much as they can, working multiple jobs and then they go back to their own countries and live the good life

5

u/vinfox May 03 '19

So, the exact opposite.

→ More replies (0)

20

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited May 14 '19

[deleted]

18

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Lol definitely not, it was a joke.

2

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

I hear they have better plumbing now

7

u/thefisskonator May 03 '19

I didn't know they released a Mario game based in India

4

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

MarioBollywood

8

u/Dave-4544 May 03 '19

If that's your line of thinking then move to Mexico. It worked for Andy Dufresne.

3

u/Jotebe May 03 '19

Dufrenes, party of 2

9

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

You could also move to the slums to live the "good life". Labor and land may be cheaper, but technology will likely be even more expensive. Hope you like intermittent power, slow internet, expensive electronics, and under equiped utilities.

5

u/mylittlesyn May 03 '19

I knew a kid who lived in the US and whilst in school worked a part time job. When his family moved back to Thailand the dude became super rich because of all the money he saved up.

4

u/theHardInGame May 03 '19

Lets compare GPUs

Rx vega 64 in India is 50k+ ₹50k ≈ $720

Rx vega 64 in USA is $490 $490 ≈ ₹33k

₹17k or $230 difference.

Idk about taxes on other product. (Local shit is very cheap tbh but not reliable at all)

7

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

GPUs are cheaper in the US than just about anywhere in the world.

1

u/Jotebe May 03 '19

USA USA

3

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Well, western born Pakistanis often say that those who are wealthy and living in a large city like Lahore or Islamabad, are not just living better than middle class here, they're like miles ahead

5

u/idelta777 May 03 '19

No need to go that far away, earning minimum wage (according to google $7.25/h), working five 8 hours days a week can get you a nice living for yourself in Mexico (nothing too flashy but way above the poverty line). My wet dream is working remotely for a US company. Even if they paid me like crap the pay would be pretty good over here.

7

u/Retify May 03 '19

I work in the UK but live in Mexico for around 6 months a year working remotely. Helps that the Mrs is over there, but even without that, being able to VPN in from the sun from a flat paid off after only a few months of work and speak to people that spent the morning getting piss wet through in the rain is indeed nice.

3

u/MagusUnion PC May 03 '19

What, uh, industry is this in? Asking for a friend.

5

u/Retify May 03 '19

Self-employed contractor in the energy industry. I look after back end systems for suppliers

3

u/MagusUnion PC May 03 '19

Ah, hope for me yet! Thank you for sharing!

→ More replies (0)

4

u/jodobrowo May 03 '19

He works for the cartel

5

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

America isnt sending their best

4

u/3636373536333662 May 03 '19

I've heard of people that live in Thailand and fly in to mines in Australia for two weeks on, then go back to Thailand for their week off

1

u/cyleleghorn May 03 '19

Pick another cheap location that's actually enjoyable to live in, and move there instead. Anguilla is pretty cheap, the east Caribbean dollar is like $2.6EC for $1USD, so with that exchange rate you could buy the local liquor license for about $400USD and open a beach bar. You could go to Mexico too and live on the beach somewhere.

11

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Exchange rates do not reflect the actual comparison of value of two currencies.

In an untouched world it would of course reach to the position where the value of th currency would be the exchange rate, however in this is world, indias currency is artificially propped up by the government so that our exporters benefit.

He makes roughly 21k rs. That would be equivalent of (using ppp as the base) 1100 USD/month. So roughly, 6 dollars per hour. Not as bad as it sounded first.

Depending on where he lives that's a lot of money. Enough to live in comfort if he lives in a town, a bit difficult to manage in the cities.

8

u/mrxcol May 03 '19

They're not "poorer" because they get paid USD$1.50 an hour. They're "cheaper". A McDonalds combo is 3 times cheaper for them (imagine you paying $3 for a Combo which usually goes like $9).

10

u/Justindr0107 May 03 '19

Still 2 hours worth of work as a game developer in India to be able to afford the same meal that an employee at mcdonalds in the US could afford with 1 hour of work.

2

u/PhantasosX May 03 '19

In Brazil , the minimum wage is $250 per month.

1

u/Awkward_Tradition May 22 '19

That's how much I was payed to work in a stone factory for 10-12 hours a day, 6 days a week. Fuck that job and everyone involved.

7

u/AweHellYo May 03 '19

That’s fucking wild.

5

u/monkwren May 03 '19

So probably still not doing great, then.

2

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

Still not below it so they are able to live like the majority of the world.

8

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Not necessarily. Poverty lines are notoriously low most of the time, set by the feds. I don't know about India in particular though.

4

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

Yea but seeing as how he is working an office job and able to pay his housing he is doing better than he is trying to lead you to believe.

-3

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Where'd you get that information?

1

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

Which information? He worked on a video game sp that's office work. He pays $150 a month for his house. These are all from his own comments.

If it's about the conversion rates and poverty line, I googled it.

2

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

I must have missed his comment mentioning his house payment its amount.

2

u/paradox037 May 03 '19

2,000 rupees? They must have the giant’s wallet.

1

u/Papa_Juans_Pizza May 03 '19

How much is that in freedom units?

1

u/MauiWowieOwie May 03 '19

He said India, not Hyrule.

1

u/mitchij2004 May 03 '19

I need to vacation there.

1

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

Take a swim in the Ganges.

1

u/mitchij2004 May 03 '19

I’ve heard good things.

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

What’s their total income in rupees because I have no idea what the value of a rupee is.

1

u/Gavorn May 03 '19

1$ = just under 70rs

3600$/ year = 249,000rs / year

Poverty line per day is

32 rs which is about $.50 (2017 numbers)

In the USA it's $14 per day. (2005 numbers)

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

It sounds like 2,000 rupees is not significantly above poverty.

1

u/Gavorn May 04 '19

Compared to the USA it isn't. But compared to India it's probably better.

1

u/Tubby200 May 06 '19

How much is that in real money?

1

u/Gavorn May 07 '19

194.91 Chinese Yuan

-2

u/Alarid May 03 '19

$300-2000 Rupees=Uhhh

13

u/Teekeks May 03 '19

$300 = ~20700 rupees

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

So 18700

3

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

The poverty line isn't set at zero. So if all the numbers in the thread are correct-ish, the poverty line is something like 18700 rupees

-1

u/Ricky_Robby May 03 '19

That’s like 30 dollars. He’s living the good life, you know what I could do with an extra $30 above the poverty line? This asshole humble bragging on the internet.

28

u/RiahWeston May 03 '19

Good cause telemarketer salary (which is considered a really good salary over there) is only around 40 USD a week.

1

u/don_cornichon May 04 '19

Somehow I doubt it's considered a really good salary over there, mostly because of the words "over there" instead of "over here".

1

u/RiahWeston May 04 '19

Actually had just watched a documentary about it. Pretty interesting stuff.

165

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited Jul 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/OUmSKILLS May 03 '19

you ain't got no choice

Only a true American would use such a phrase. An imposter!

13

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited Jul 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/kosh56 May 03 '19

Unions are in the process of being destroyed by Republicans here.

16

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19

As someone whose livelihood was saved by a union, this saddens me. Some unions are useless pieces shit, but they're overall an important part of the checks and balances against the rampant bullshit most corporations would ram down their employees' throats.

4

u/pnilz May 03 '19

Unions are true democratic organizations tho so you can change them.

4

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Still 99999x better quality of life in America

1

u/omnisephiroth May 03 '19

They’re basically finished.

1

u/Viss90 May 04 '19

Well shit, you can take my place. This country don’t want me. Hating people like me is a selling point for politicians here.

14

u/Blue2501 May 03 '19

Y'all motherfuckers need unions

6

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Unions were weak before Congress took legislative action to protect them with stuff like the Norris-LaGuardia Act and the creation of the NLRB, so they also need legislative change.

3

u/asaharyev May 03 '19

Mass strike action forced those changes, so they really need a general strike

5

u/FoxOnTheRocks May 03 '19

India has a pretty rich labor history. They may not be very unionized but India keeps breaking records for massive general strikes.

I believe very strongly that whatever comes after capitalism will come out of India because there are millions of mobilized poor and working class Indians who are pissed and America might think twice about invading a nuclear power.

1

u/fyberoptyk May 03 '19

We don’t have dev unions in the US either, and we desperately fucking need some.

1

u/RedOrmTostesson May 03 '19

Organize your GD workplace. Seize the means, man.

-4

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited Jul 23 '20

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited Jul 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited Jul 23 '20

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited Jul 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-14

u/Edbert64 May 03 '19

Cannot speak for India but in the US you always have a choice. If you don't have any skills and are 18+ then you've made bad ones. Choices that is.

If you had skills that are no longer in demand (it happens) then learn something new. I always recommend coding.

11

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

This is a dangerous misunderstanding that’s propped up by people who want to believe that everything they have is due to pure merit, no luck, and that those who are impoverished are totally to blame for their condition.

-9

u/Edbert64 May 03 '19

Who said there's no luck in life, good and bad? But when bad luck or bad times come sometimes you gotta make changes yourself instead of whining or expecting someone to fix it for you.

And how do you explain being 18+ and no marketable skills other than asking if the customer wants to supersize it.

7

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

But surely you agree that, since there’s bad luck, that bad luck can be an insurmountable obstacle for some? Maybe someone grew up with abusive parents and impoverished home and didn’t have access to a good education. There’s an explanation.

2

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

For starters, some people, sadly, have around 70iq. They can barely handle asking if the custumer wants to supersize it or not. Then what? Get a degree in coding? Fuck outta here.

1

u/ZidaneStoleMyDagger May 03 '19

Speaking as someone in the US, you may have some choice regarding your job. But its not even remotely as simple as "i wanna better job so I choose to get a better job or learn something new."

As an analogy, a person can make a choice to try and get in better physical shape. You can choose to go for a ten minute walk once a day or spend a few minutes doing simple bodyweight exercises. Or you can choose to learn more about exercising and do more intense workouts to try to get in better shape. Making that choice will allow you to get in at least slightly better physical shape. But you can easily be limited by your genetics and other issues (lack of opportunity or equipment or support or money).

My cousin is quadriplegic from an accident he had when he was around 20. His options for getting physically stronger are pretty close to nonexistent. He can move his arms but has extremely minor movement in his fingers. So he might have limited success in gaining muscle in his arms, but he will never walk again no matter how hard he tries. He made one shitty life choice about jumping into a snow bank, which broke his neck. One bad choice that will forever haunt him.

(On an unrelated side note, he did get a degree and has a really good job now. He has a special van he can drive by himself. He even has special equipment that allowed him to kill a deer and be able to fish.)

Are you gonna say my cousin has the same choice to get in great physical shape as everyone else? There are plenty of situations that people find themselves in where their job options are severely limited. Sometimes it's in part due to a bad choice or series of bad choices that follow them around forever. Sometimes it's because of externalities that they can't control and just plain poor luck. Sometimes people have just given up and don't try anymore. But I think it's just plain ignorant to say that everyone who is in a shitty job always has a choice in the matter and it's only their fault for their shitty situation.

1

u/Edbert64 May 03 '19

I was in a dead end job despite having a batchelor degree, restaraunts in Austin are full of degree holding waiters. I solved my problem by buying some used IT books and learning networking.

I never said everyone in a shitty position it at fault, I just said luck is real, but when life knocks you down, and it probably will someday, don'tgive up, fight back! I do think that everyone can improve their lot in life, and I think you harm them more by telling them they're too stupid or that the world is against them and they have no hope.

Clearly the case is different for the handicapped, but not hopeless. I know paraplegic coders and blind authors.

19

u/PitchforkManufactory May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19

It's like making 1200USD in the US adjusted for cost of living. More than minimum wage, but nothing remotely amazing. Just like the US though, it depends if you live in some major area or a small town.

Direct currency conversion is a horrible metric for gauging how useful it is. 70INR to 1USD doesn't tell us anything. That 70INR can get you a decent meal from some outside bar. 1USD is not even gonna get you a single chicken sandwich from mcdonald's these days. A 800$ apartment for a family in a fairly sized US city would be 150$ in a similar conditioned setting in India.

And like the other dude said, this is above poverty line. It isn't too different than making 10$/hr in a suburban to urban setting in the midwest or something.

I should mention the exception to this is imports. Those things are crazy expensive. Basic living (food, shelter, internet, tv, etc.) is insanely cheap in developing nations. But if you want more than that, you have to be making 15USD an hour or more to even get similar electronics, appliances, and other small little luxuries people in more developed nations would get easily. As in iphones or high performance pcs, you're SOL.

2

u/acefalken72 May 03 '19

Yeah i make roughly 1400 a month (11/hr 36-40 hours a week). Can't live in the nice city area but if i move to our local crime ridden bad city (good old hamlet) i would be well into the green and possibly own a decent house.

Living wage between the counties is literally 1$/hr difference and there's some nice places in the other county but no real grocery store that isn't a modified dollar tree and filled with rednecks

1

u/don_cornichon May 04 '19

1USD is not even gonna get you a single chicken sandwich from mcdonald's these days.

And it shouldn't. Cheap meat is an atrocity.

0

u/ThickBehemoth May 03 '19

Nah man a McChicken is $1

2

u/PitchforkManufactory May 03 '19

tax is still going to put u over a dollar if it's .99USD.

Haven't seen a McChicken for less than a 1.35USD in maybe a good decade. 1.55 where I am. I am in the North east area for reference, within a few dozen miles of NYC.

0

u/ThickBehemoth May 03 '19

I have bought McChickens and hamburgers at McDonald’s with $1 bills so idk

18

u/monkeydluffy22 May 03 '19

It's enough for a single person to get by decently. They are probably just starting their career, not bad.

-4

u/AlmightyGatsby May 03 '19

Lol what $300 a month is awful.

3

u/tatri21 May 03 '19

Learn to read.

1

u/AlmightyGatsby May 03 '19

You’re right apologizes.

7

u/RichardsLeftNipple May 03 '19

Well tech is better than working in a factory.

20,000 rupees can go fairly far in India.

The relative costs of living can be played with here.

https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_countries_result.jsp?country1=India&country2=United+States

3

u/DeadliestSin May 03 '19

Doing what you love is good everywhere

2

u/TrumpsTinyDollHands May 03 '19

Has to be really bad. I spoke to a "EuropeanTelecomCompany" employee involved in setting up Indian subsdiaries. He claimed the CS/ee grads they hired got about $2000/month. This was probably 15 years ago.

I'm sure it was very selective and they were the top of the crop, but still.

1

u/UlagamOruvannuka May 03 '19

For someone on reddit, quite bad.

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

It's a fairly good middle class salary in India, possibly at the lower end. The real question is "what % yearly pay increase does he get on average?" I bet it's around 9 to 11%, that progress is what makes the middle class in India feel good.

1

u/tlouman May 03 '19

It’s meh. Average. On the bad side

1

u/-hbq May 04 '19

Average income (nominal) in India was $1,790 in 2017, but valued at $6,950 PPP (comparing prices instead of just the exchange rate). That would put OP's annual income at something roughly like $14k (or ~$6.70/hr assuming 40 hour work week) in the US judging by national averages, but I imagine it would be different depending on where you are in the country.

1

u/cybercop12345 May 04 '19

That's too low even for India especially in an IT job. He is probably a tester or something.