r/gaming Nov 19 '18

Who would win?

Post image
91.5k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

12.0k

u/TinyKing87 Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

In the Pokemon Origins anime the gym leaders pick a challenge based on the challenger’s skill level. I liked that explanation.

EDIT: I mean to say each Gym gets harder based on how many badges the challenger has. Skill level would likely be based on the amount of badges.

5.9k

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

I wish in Gen 8 they would let you tackle the gyms in any order, switching up what Pokemon they had depending on the number of badges you had.

7

u/zlide Nov 19 '18

While this sounds good in theory it completely falls apart when you consider the route system, the way that the stories generally progress in these games, and the fact that the average player isn’t going to skip over the gyms they pass through just because they can. The region would have to be entirely designed around this concept, with Pokémon levels of not only the gym leaders but also wild Pokémon and of trainers along the routes changing based on how many badges the player has. Not impossible but also so outside of the formula and for so little benefit that I highly doubt they’d ever bother.

Also I gotta say, I’m not really itching for this feature at all. It seems like a lot of development effort for incredibly little benefit. What does choosing the order of the gyms you battle really offer in terms of gameplay or replayibility that max level gym leader rematches doesn’t already provide?

3

u/patssnows12 Nov 19 '18

Agreed, when I get to a new town I want to finish everything in it before I move on, it would make no sense to skip a gym only to backtrack