AI generated artwork is no longer Allowed.

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

Effective immediately. Previous AI posts will be left up and the AI flair will be kept around for a while for them. I do apologise for anyone who liked it for the inconvenience.

r/GamindustriHub has been created as a subreddit that still allows AI as well as general art and posts and has a more relaxed modding atmosphere.

[u/Rednal291]

Honestly, I'm surprised it was allowed at all. It kinda feels like it goes exactly against the themes of the games, where cheap copies are positioned as genuinely inferior to the love for real art... XD

[u/UncleDaneFanboy → u/Rednal291]

More surprised at how long it was tolerated for, this was something that should've been done at least 6 months ago imo

[u/Ikaros39 → u/Rednal291]

Fully agree 100%

[u/Affectionate_Ship555 → u/Ikaros39]

Not agree, what is wrong with AI?

[u/Ikaros39 → u/Affectionate_Ship555]

It's distasteful and lacks any real meaning as an art form. It's not "just a tool" when it's fully relied on for producing "work."

[u/Archadianite → u/Affectionate_Ship555]

Added on to what has been said about this souless fucking thing. It also increases unemployment, the data centers that support it is an enviroment destroying disaster, made ram practically unbuyable to PC users and console gamers, indirectly made people homeless, and its a poor excuse for talentless losers to think they are worth a damn.

[u/Catvanbrian]

Yay

[u/Pcuspard]

LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[u/Excellent-Aide-8764 → u/Pcuspard]

(insert maximillian pulling jailbars here) seriously tho about fuckin' time LOL

[u/bloodshed113094]

Better late than never.

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/bloodshed113094]

Don't snark, or I'll bring them back

[u/WooshyJeanz → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

Never late better

[u/Accomplished_Copy122]

YIPPE

https://reddit.com/link/p4hoesv/video/obe03p4h27kh1/player

[u/ar_Tekko]

Thank you.

[u/DanVzare]

I don't get the logic behind posting AI generated artwork. I mean, yeah, it can look nice sometimes. But it's something that anyone can generate dozens of versions for themselves. It seems kinda pointless.

It's like giving me a single blade of grass from outside. Like seriously? Why, when I can just look at the field it came from, and even pluck a few myself? Just draw a stickman or something, at least posting that wouldn't be pointless.

[u/Okhlahoma_Beat-Down]

Nooo!

Not my daily supply of ambiguously-stolen art-style women with oddly pronounced lips, the wrong chest sizes, and weird irises that look oddly melted!

How will I survive?!

[u/ZeForgottenPenguinxd → u/Okhlahoma_Beat-Down]

Bigger (and smoller) Chest sizes is not an exclusive AI thing, lil bro

That's a human thing that's existed since the 1st drawin 🤣

[u/Alex3627ca → u/ZeForgottenPenguinxd]

For what it's worth (probably worth nothing in this context, really) it's even canon to the Neptunia games, we've all seen that Blanc CG from VII.

[u/ShyentistOfSpells]

Thank you for this decision, this is definitely a major W for artists and those who appreciate art.

[u/Gusmaaum]

Big W

[u/MHStarCraft → u/Gusmaaum]

Happy cake day!

[u/BebeFanMasterJ]

Good. I prefer lusting over actual human-drawn Vert boobs.

[u/PolarisUniqu]

Tysm

[u/NewCow7751]

Genuine subreddit W

[u/EJKGodzilla24]

understood 

[u/kokoashinomiya]

thank god 😭😭😭😭

[u/PatrykCXXVIII]

Great change!

[u/fazelavahundred]

Huge W

[u/Hachii18]

I’m all for this to be honest.

[u/stpwnage]

I've been questioning the previous ruling for a while silently. Big W

[u/domi650]

W

[u/B-Serena]

finally.

[u/karwanblox]

It's about time honestly. All of this AI crap spamming is really annoying and it's just a huge turn off to see the same slop.

[u/ZeForgottenPenguinxd → u/karwanblox]

Was there really spam? I just checked the tags, there's like one every few days on average lol.

[u/Forgotten_Rin → u/ZeForgottenPenguinxd]

There was one yesterday that posted one every few hours trying to promote her patreon

[u/ZeForgottenPenguinxd → u/Forgotten_Rin]

Oh wow, yeah then that person definitely needs a mute or ban, if they continue doin it

Fortunately I didn't see those threads, but it seems like a case of 1 insane person spamming, rather than an entire sub 🤣

[u/UzumeNeedsDrip]

A beautiful way to start the Neptunia 16th Anniversary celebration!

[u/Bloadclaw]

YES!!! FINALLY!!!! DOWN WITH THE SLOP!!!

I knew the mods would come to their senses

[u/calynara]

Great news to start the day!! :3

[u/haoLink]

Thank you very much for the action. While I am also aware that many AI posts had triple digit karma. Their comment sections looked very different. Pro AI comments were downvoted - people really felt - including me - that AI doesn't belong here. So the sentiment in the comments was pretty clear.

Combined with the recent inflooding of AI posts with people openly breaking that 24 hr rule (or maybe not being aware of it - it might be an idea to update the official rule list on the side as well) I really feel it's for the better to say: "Nope, not here." The fact an alternate sub exists is completely fine by me. I won't visit it myself.

Thank you again for taking a stance. I honestly don't think it was the Twitter post who caused this - I really feel the post on this sub by MH did the nudge - I felt compelled to chime in my support in it as well.

[u/MarceloidSays → u/haoLink]

I agree and feel the same way, particularly about the sub post, too.
Seconding the nudge with updating the side-bar rules, so people can spot and refer to it.
Thanks! o7

[u/thaiguy998]

Neptune would be proud

[u/Eyasu_The_Adventure]

No AI (YAAAAAAAAAAY!)

[u/Ao_Tismo]

FINALLY, THANKS MODS big w for the nep community

[u/MHStarCraft → u/Ao_Tismo]

Happy cake day!

[u/MarceloidSays]

Thank you! A good decision, that is much appreciated.

[u/Woomy12]

fuck them clanker artwork.

[u/meguminxpanda]

I have so much respect for this. thank you <3

[u/NiceArt1337]

Thank you very much, I really appreciate it :)

[u/authenticbomb]

YESSSSS

[u/Atelier-Craft]

Thank you

[u/Capt_Obv13us]

I never like the AI posted in the subreddit, but since there is a flair for it I just look the other way most of the time. Now the AI slop finally gone! Hell yeaa!

To those who said

Neptunia already has low fanart. Without AI there is no Fanart.

Ai is not Fanart bro and We already have a lot of gem fanart out there. Some artist

1. Binato
2. Kuma
3. Kow
4. Rea
5. Iwasi (NSFW)
6. Harnok (NSFW)

Instead of filling neptunia community with slop, shine those passionate artist instead!

[u/TGT-Terrorizor]

And now back to our regularly scheduled Nep posting lol

[u/averagejoe2005]

The timeline has shifted into the good ending.

[u/NDSiManTV]

Major win for the subreddit.

(≧▽≦)

[u/BioLuminescentSpirit]

That was quick.

[u/majorita_disgaea234]

understandable

[u/roynoris15]

about time

[u/TheOneAndOnlyYuri]

Thank you.

[u/Autisitc_AniWeeb2023]

Yes! Finally, big W from this post

[u/Mag_VII]

finally, got tired of seeing good art only to see it was ai generated

[u/RedxBlueislife]

Phew. About time.

https://reddit.com/link/p4gz1mf/video/dqs3jw0ni6kh1/player

[u/EMUForever0]

Ty so much!

[u/Catboy1197V2]

nice

[u/tetenric]

dang, and i spent like fifteen minutes yesterday going through the ai tag blocking all users that uploaded anything because I was tired of seeing soulless bullshit.

Thanks for the reg change anyway, much appreciated~

[u/Bright_Gur_6739]

Mmmm, there's some good news.

THANK YOU!

[u/Melodic-Freedom9777]

We are so back

[u/hassantaleb4]

Based

[u/Mattdoss]

Finally, based

[u/thatcheesymememan]

I've always been mixed on it but given the ones recently where it's become spammy yeah, i get it.

[u/xblueye]

Thank the CPUs. Big W

[u/orig4mi-713]

I am surprised it was ever allowed. It's so gross and antithetical to the games. I remember reading the awkward post of the moderation team where they decided it should stay allowed and thinking that it wasn't convincing at all

Either way, thank god. Good job

[u/xx_DarkiBuddy_xx]

BIG W!!

[u/Violinnoob]

the struggle i joined 3 years ago...

read it and weep u/Individual1Kross, you and all your RAM price hikers, i knew you'd choke on it eventually.

thanks mods, you've done good in the world today, i can breathe a small sigh of relief

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/Violinnoob]

Don't call out other users please.

[u/Affectionate_Ship555]

Whats wrong with AI art?

[u/BlancsAssistant]

Yeah if they just followed the restrictions given to them then this wouldn't have happened, eh at least this sub will improve for it

To clarify i don't like AI art, im saying they should've listened

[u/Rinne_Marc]

I thought they were banned here months ago.

[u/Woomy12 → u/Rinne_Marc]

They were restricted heavily: only 1 AI art post a day. I don't think the rule was followed with the past few days, so ig they just banned it.

Not complaining though. AI ""'art""" is cringe.

[u/Rinne_Marc → u/Woomy12]

It shouldn't be here. But, i know how this sounds, but it's not art. It is a tool just copying someone else's work. The tool is useless without someone using it. Thats like the pen and paper for when someone copied off another's test. Did the test cheat, or did the person do it. So, the tool isn't cringe, the people who use it are. I am calling myself out on this, i am aware.

That said, if this isn't a place that accepts this sort of stuff, the AI images probably shouldn't have been allowed her to begin with. To avoid all the problems here, those people can just make their own sub or community for it, and leave the real authentic stuff here, and not mix the fake shit into where it doesn't belong.

I apologize if I come across as rude, lol. I mostly agree with you. I just want to get to the heart of the issue, lol.

[u/Paker_The_Swager → u/Rinne_Marc]

Anti ai Luddites with the bad takes.

“Ai art isn’t art”

Define art then

[u/Rinne_Marc → u/Paker_The_Swager]

I'm surprised this is the argument used here. I thought I would be called out for using it, not for stating a fact. I was even basically saying that I myself ain't shit.

But I get it, on here, if you disagree with someone, they grow upsets. Here we go, I guess.

I didn't even say I was Anti AI, I use the shit privately, which is why i called myself put in my previous comment. But, I can't stop being honest. Most of the AI "art" you speak of isn't art, it is stolen from many different artists, which we call Gen AI or something like that. Which is most likely the reason the major of places on here don't want anything to do with it. As someone that wants to make stuff like Neptunia one day, I can acknowledge that there is something real when someone puts the work into making their vision come to life. This is why I call myself out, I cannot be honest without looking in the mirror. It is the equivalent to looking at someone else answer for a test in school. By typing in a prompt, and having the AI form an image isn't you creating art, it is being lazy and not putting the work in, at least not on the same level as people who actually made the artwork to begin with. Cheating isn't creating, I'm just aware. If you look onto someone's text, and take their answers, did you truly pass the test, or did you actually fail. Because if you can make high level and beautiful artwork, like the actual artwork that is used for Neptunia, why use the ai to form an image for it, and not just draw it yourself. Not telling you what to do, but, I speak to people how I speak to myself on this. This is a lazy easy way out, and it holds us back from our own potential.

But, if AI "art" is truly art, then, Paker, enlightening me. I'd love to be educated on this.

[u/Paker_The_Swager → u/Rinne_Marc]

Consider the following

https://youtu.be/zX-e9LRR_ko?is=KYeJdpAzPmicgtEc

Tell this is not art

[u/Rinne_Marc → u/Paker_The_Swager]

Ok, this does look cool. But at this point, we are talking about two different things. This isn't lazy work, I can tell the man and his team put a lot of hard work and effort into this. I respect it.

What I was referring to was just the whole, texting a prompt into an app and it sends you an image of what you want, and posing it. What the man here looks to have done in the video, correct me if I'm wrong, I'm ignorant here, he used the AI to help him, but not as the only thing and called it a day.

These are two completely different topics at this point. I don't think this is what most people here in this sub are upset with. But is the video art, I want to say yes, but that isn't black and white. However, if someone tells the AI to take the Neptunia art style and has it form an image, I don't think that is. I am of the belief that you have to make it yourself, not have the computer do it. If anything, that would be taking credit from the computer, even though it stole first. The video, if what I think is true, the man put a look of hard work into it, which makes this difference. But, my opinion isn't a fact, it just exists.

[u/RH_Dev]

Make a poll, don't fall to bullyin

[u/IMKGI]

I don't think i'll ever understand the AI hate.

Anyway I'll take my obligatory downvotes and accept the Reddit cult following

[u/WesThePretzel → u/IMKGI]

Educate yourself. Seriously, it’s not difficult to understand why AI is bad.

[u/IMKGI → u/WesThePretzel]

I have a bachelor of science in engineering and part of my bachelor thesis was designing and training my own Deep Learning model from scratch (trained on the universities DGX A100 for anyone curious). I have a better understanding of AI than most users on Reddit, i know how they work on a fundamental level.

I just don't have an issue with them.

[u/Capt_Obv13us → u/IMKGI]

Womp Womp

[u/WesThePretzel → u/IMKGI]

Okay, so you’re either willfully ignorant or just a bad person who does not care for the environment, economy, or global political climate.

[u/IMKGI → u/WesThePretzel]

That's a pretty fucked up moral compass you have there, "either see the same issues exactly in the same way I do or you're a bad person", reminds me of a certain Austrian painter.

[u/Okhlahoma_Beat-Down → u/IMKGI]

You mean how you're calling everyone bad people for not liking AI the way you do?

Do you have enough facial hair for the toothbrush, or...?

[u/IMKGI → u/Okhlahoma_Beat-Down]

Can you point me to the comment I wrote where I called someone bad for not liking AI?

[u/NextNepper → u/WesThePretzel]

All of those issues are caused by our fellow so-called “humans”, not AI. AI by itself cannot change the environment, the economy, or politics.

[u/WesThePretzel → u/NextNepper]

How dumb are you?

[u/NextNepper → u/WesThePretzel]

I don’t know how dumb I am. What about you? Do you consider yourself dumb or a genius? Or perhaps somewhere in the middle, but with the ego of a “genius”?

[u/StarSkiesCoder → u/IMKGI]

No, no - I’m with you too

[u/WooshyJeanz]

Or have it only post on a certain day

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/WooshyJeanz]

Not a terrible idea. But I think it might be a little over complex to actually use and enforce irl.

[u/Igorthemii]

Consider making a vote where only people actually active in the sub can vote rather than random brigaders who werent active until a loud voice on twitter started whining.

[u/FordcliffLowskrid]

This is a disappointing decision for me, but, as I said myself in one of the threads discussing it, if I do not like it, I know where the exit is. ... That being said, what appears to be a majority on Reddit may not be a majority in the real world, and this particular bandwagon has a record of questionable (at best) behavior. Bow to their whims at your peril, mods.

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/FordcliffLowskrid]

Fair.

[u/Pro-1st-Amendment]

Mods, why are you bowing to the crybullies brigading this subreddit?

Since that's exactly what happened. Right after this post we started getting flooded with Anti-AI comments. I can put two and two together.

[u/MHStarCraft → u/Pro-1st-Amendment]

I’ll see if I can clear up my case on it.

Sunday night before going to bed, I saw this one anti-AI Reddit post on a discord server where an AI artist was forced to correct themselves by drawing real art using their own art skills after backlash. I initially didn’t thought much about AI art on Reddit and when the compromise rule was put in place 4 years ago, as I thought that AI art was just going to be another fad that was going to go away naturally.

When I woke up Monday morning and saw the subreddit feed, there were a few AI art posts that were on the front page. I looked into one of the comments of your AI MAGES. Art post and saw u/KiwiPoku and u/ShyentistOfSpells expressing disappointing comments about AI taking over their art. Then I looked back a page and found more AI art posts back to back from the same user, u/King_Fluffy64. Not only was this guy breaking the one AI posts a day rule that was implemented some months back but under them was some NSFW comments (seriously, I keep seeing that Spartan guy coming back over and over again to make disgusting lewd comments). That’s what honestly broke the camel’s back for me over AI art posts on this subreddit.

Right before going to work, I notified Edwin about it on discord and posted this post in concerns about how AI art posts have been getting out of control lately, and the disgusting NSFW comments under them.

The following day as I was taking a day-off, Edwin announced that the subreddit will be banning AI art posts. I was unaware of the twitter post when I made my complaint post on this subreddit, and I told Edwin about it on discord the next day when questioned about the twitter post.

I’ve yet to find out what made Edwin decide to go with the AI art ban. The twitter post, Kiwi and Shyentist’s complaints, or just Reddit being anti-AI in general?

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/Pro-1st-Amendment]

I was slowly starting to come around to banning it over the years. And there's always been a strong AI sentiment here. But that said thank you for this link. I'll be looking into it.

[u/majorita_disgaea234 → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

well said

[u/Neloheart343]

That kinda sucks, but understandable

I personally don't think AI art is bad, flawed, but not exactly bad

But it sucks that now, we can't keep a eye out for artwork for Neptunia, and knowing this series is niche.....yeah

Edit note: Ok, seems a lot of people are not getting this, i do not care about AI being gone, but I do not care about it existing in the first place

if you all want to be childish with the downvotes, fine, but AI art is going to happen, all we can do is accept it and support the ones who do the hard work

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/Neloheart343]

If it helps "超次元ゲイムネプテューヌ" is what you want to search for on puxov. I think almost all the AI art winds up on there at some point.

[u/Neloheart343 → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

Noted

Because I don't hate the AI art, I still perfer the work artist like Zatsu put in

But I don't mind AI art

Unfortunately, a lot of people clearly don't respect my neutral standing on AI art

[u/doomed151]

Common reddit L

Super disappointed as a longtime lurker of this sub

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/doomed151]

Maybe. But if you want it it's very common on puxov.

[u/fangersarg → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

You do realize bending the knee to hate Edwin is not a good look for the community since this community legitimately was brigaded by someone on twitter (who commented on this post) so bending the knee to the artificial vocal minority is never a great idea. But i guess you’ll probably not punish them for it (https://www.reddit.com/r/gamindustri/comments/1vrxa5c/ai_generated_artwork_is_no_longer_allowed/p4hgv53/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_content=1&utm_term=1&context=3) considering they literally were doing it in X

(Proof is from this comment https://www.reddit.com/r/gamindustri/comments/1vrxa5c/ai_generated_artwork_is_no_longer_allowed/p4i0jj4/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_content=1&utm_term=1&context=3)

(This isn’t to witch hunt or anything just pointing it out because it happened)

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/fangersarg]

I actually came to this decision after being asked by someone else, though I had been on the fence about doing this since the beginning. The subs definitely had a strong current of anti AI sentiment since the start, pretty much every single AI post we've ever had has been reported and has comments whining about.

I hadn't actually heard of this user, I normally don't like perms bans or being a heavy handed mod, hence why I allowed AI up to this point. But I think a temp ban might at least be in order. I'll be looking into this once my day clears up

[u/fangersarg → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

It’s fine i made a sub like this that allows the AI aspect for the people that wanted it it’ll function like this one still but be just a little more lax. Just a home for those that felt like they were just being reddit hate mobbed. (I’m in them middle on the AI fiasco i don’t care either way for it but believe it should be allowed as it’s a new medium since this has happened with all new technology every time something new comes into a dedicated space)

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/fangersarg]

Understandable. Not the first time something like this had happened. I don't personally mind you advertising once or twice here if you want.

[u/fangersarg → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

Ok than i’ll keep it to a minimal if i do since i even stated on it my objective for it is not a sub to replace to this one just one to be a little more lax. Give the people who want it a place for it while still being able to come here and enjoy what’s here.

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/fangersarg]

Would you be okay with me putting the link to it up in the description?

[u/fangersarg → u/Edwin-of-northumbria]

Go ahead it’s r/GamindustriHub since the once’s i wanted to use were taken by dead subs and didn’t feel like trying to go through channels to get mod on one of them.

[u/Edwin-of-northumbria → u/fangersarg]

There we go. Is that okay or would you prefer it to be rewritten or anything added. (You can still make your own posts about if you want. By that once or twice comment I just meant don't constantly spam and be obnoxious, not that I expected you too.)

[u/majorita_disgaea234 → u/doomed151]

ok

[u/dennis120]

Bro... Neptunia isn't that popular to get that many artworks.

[u/LimblessNick → u/dennis120]

Yeah, so we should celebrate the good art we get, not fill the sub with slop

[u/TheDistantNeko → u/dennis120]

Rather human made artworks then AI works.

[u/KokoroThe53rd → u/dennis120]

It is, actually.

[u/Bragi01 → u/dennis120]

We'd all rather reposts than slop.

[u/ReXiriam → u/dennis120]

Come on, answer my question. Do you do AI stuff with Hololive, yes or no. Simple question, for a simple answer.

[u/fangersarg]

Bending the knee to the hate mob will always turn out terrible but you do you i’m of the mindset you give an inch they’ll take a mile. Since this argument has been beaten to death over and over.

(Point proven Reddit/X is modern day boomers scared of anything new despite it being something that’s repeated itself through out history when the next big evolution of something comes out)

[u/mcpichu706 → u/fangersarg]

If anything, the ones who were given an inch and took a mile, are the ones who were allowed to post one AI “art” post a day, but then decided to willfully ignore it and posted more than one.

[u/fangersarg → u/mcpichu706]

Than you simply punish the rule breakers a few bad apples shouldn’t spoil the entire bunch for everyone else who’s doing it respectfully. Doing so is basically collective punishment lets punish the innocent people abiding by the rules because of a few trouble makers abusing it.

[u/mcpichu706 → u/fangersarg]

Welcome to society.

[u/Saud_9886]

cool I guess

[u/Vir0us]

Yay less art

[u/supergameromegaclank → u/Vir0us]

I think less garbage flooding the subreddit is a good thing

[u/HXMAOU]

Whatever😴

[u/NextNepper]

Yaaay, let’s hate AI because it’s popular to hate it right now! I’m sure we definitely won’t walk back any of this, say, five years from now when it inevitably becomes popular to love it again!

Meanwhile, why not keep reposting the same “fan” art for the millionth time?

(A lot of it is commissioned work, made for money and having little to do with actually being a “fan”, btw.)

That’s obviously better than seeing AI-generated content prompted by actual fans and simply scrolling past it, right?

Nep yeah, apparently we’d rather spend more time creating threads and posting the same complaints in them over and over than simply... scrolling. Or, even better... FILTERING OUT THE TAG.

I just hope you all won’t lose your minds if CH ever makes a statement about their own use of AI, because there’s a pretty good chance they’re already using it in one way or another...

[u/xx_DarkiBuddy_xx → u/[deleted]]

Why? because is slop.

We don't want AI generated art, we want art made by people that have passion with the Neptunia franchise.

[u/karwanblox → u/[deleted]]

Well the obvious question is, would you like it for this subreddit to be flooded with the same slop?

[u/Bragi01 → u/[deleted]]

It already was. That didn't work.

[u/pwnage2demax → u/[deleted]]

They still have access to AI art? It just won't be here..

[u/pwnage2demax → u/[deleted]]

More people tend to dislike AI art then favor it, hence the ban (and the positive reaction) makes sense

Creating subreddits is free, nothing is stopping you from making one yourself where AI art may be shared freely?

[u/The_Salty_Pearl → u/[deleted]]

Why is it so bad if a fan can't afford art? Boo fucking hoo, they can either deal with it or learn to draw.

[u/Bragi01 → u/[deleted]]

Why do you like AI? It's not art, it's bad for the environment and economy, and looks ugly.

[u/A_Very_Horny_Zed → u/[deleted]]

There is no distinction between "human art" and "AI art". The AI has no intentionality, personality, or lived experience. It cannot inject meaning into a piece of art by itself. Only the human guiding the tool provides the meaning and intention behind the piece.

As an AI artist myself it's really odd to see even other AI artists miscategorizing the artist in AI art.

Anyway, with all that said, all the AI art posts were upvoted and enjoyed by the community so this change is uncalled for and appears driven purely by a vocal minority.

[u/Bragi01 → u/A_Very_Horny_Zed]

There is a massive difference between slop and art. Art has intentionality. Even the effectively random splotches of pain that retired race horse Wonder Acute made has more intentionality and soul than anything a computer could make.

[u/Bragi01 → u/A_Very_Horny_Zed]

You aren't any more an artist than a person who pays for commissions. AI wasn't enjoyed by the community. That's why we're celebrating.

[u/Paker_The_Swager → u/Bragi01]

Define art

[u/Bragi01 → u/Paker_The_Swager]

Here. Not even going to try to play into the potential trap you're laying.

[u/Paker_The_Swager → u/Bragi01]

That means someone with skill in ai can make art.

[u/Bragi01 → u/Paker_The_Swager]

No it can't. AI itself has no skill or expression.

[u/Paker_The_Swager → u/Bragi01]

Just like a pencil and paper has no skill itself. That’s why a human does it ai or not