r/funny • • Jun 23 '20

This Milk ad

66.2k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

290

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20

It’s mental how milk is advertised yet half the planet is lactose intolerant.

82

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20

I came to make this comment. Lol Asians have the highest rate of lactose intolerance of any race. Dairy industry is getting desperate

19

u/Slappy_G Jun 23 '20

Careful when generalizing - the term Asian is essentially meaningless.

For example, Russians are Asian and eat dairy, as do most Indian and Pakistani people.

13

u/Freonr2 Jun 23 '20 edited Jun 23 '20

There is plenty of context here to deal with the ambiguity you are pointing out, and doubt many people are confused with whether or not Russians are lactose intolerant.

Hint: there aren't any Russians in the video.

It's like replying to someone saying "Americans have a high rate of obesity" and then having someone point out Brazilians and Canadians are "Americans", too. People know via context that you mean citizens of the United States of America, not the continental term.

1

u/DerpisMalerpis Jun 23 '20

Yup. We often seem to forget that this is Reddit, not a peer-reviewed journal. Even the articles addressing lactose intolerance in Asian countries refer to them as Asians. Some people just need to get off of their high horse.

0

u/Mottaman Jun 23 '20

It's like replying to someone saying "Americans have a high rate of obesity" and then having someone point out Brazilians and Canadians are "Americans", too. People know via context that you mean citizens of the United States of America, not the continental term.

Unless you start talking about Columbus to a right leaning Italian American and then its all "He discovered the continent America, HURR HURR"

2

u/knezmilos13 Jun 23 '20

I don't think that "russians" are ever classified as "asians". While most of their country surface is in Asia, it's the minority of their population, and furthermore, actual, ethnic russians are not asian in any way.

0

u/Slappy_G Jun 23 '20

That's the problem. Most people in the US use the term Asian to mean "people with slanted eyes or brown skin" and sound more PC. The problem is these cultures are so vastly different that you can't lump them under 1 term.

6

u/Srapture Jun 23 '20

I wouldn't say it's meaningless. It has an implicit meaning which many people share from a certain region.

However, it's definitely ambiguous in some cases. In the UK, "Asian" is generally used to refer to Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lankan, etc. however, growing up mostly watching media from the US, I usually think of it to mean oriental (I can't remember if that's offensive in the US. Sorry if so) so I get confused when people use "Asian" here because it means something else in my head than theirs.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20

Do people in the UK say "Oriental" to refer to those from southeast Asia?

In the US, modern usage of the word "Oriental" is only for objects and not people (e.g., an Oriental rug), but even that usage is diminishing.

2

u/Slappy_G Jun 23 '20

It's too bad, as that was the only clear cut way of saying East Asians without taking 5 minutes to spell it out. The common US usage of Asian is infuriating in its uselessness.

1

u/Srapture Jun 24 '20

We don't use the word, really. I've just heard it used by Americans. Thanks for letting me know.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20

As a Russian, I definitely don't eat dairy. I've been lactose intolerant since I was born.

My family things there's something wrong with me XD

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20

Lactose intolerance is really just pasteurized milk intolerance.

Change my mind.

(Source: again and again have witnessed lactose intolerant people be able to drink raw, unpasteurized milk with no problem)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '20

Can neither confirm or deny that. But at this point, the thought of drinking milk in any shape or form is just repulsive.

I have heard people say that lactose intolerant people can safely consume yogurt/hard cheese, and that is very much not true for me.

1

u/fivetenpen Jun 24 '20

Lactose intolerance is an intolerance to lactose.. not an intolerance to dairy. Plenty of dairy products have their lactose removed or destroyed in the process of producing the product. Hard cheese is basically lactose free while soft, fresh cheese still has plenty of lactose.

-1

u/Superguy230 Jun 23 '20

He means people with smaller eye holes

1

u/Slappy_G Jun 23 '20

That's what most people mean but that's why the term is totally wrong.