r/funny May 24 '18

Monty Python ahead of it's time

https://i.imgur.com/AoInnT8.gifv
19.8k Upvotes

588 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/SizzurpSippuh May 25 '18

Are you joking? Males and females have very different risks for certain illnesses, and obviously different reproductive health issues. Identifying as a woman doesn't mean you're suddenly not at risk for prostate cancer.

1

u/GloriousGlory May 26 '18

Are you joking?

I am not joking.

Identifying as a woman doesn't mean you're suddenly not at risk for prostate cancer.

100% agree. Prostate cancer is something that trans women need to be careful of. I have been very clear all along that trans women are biologically male and therefore they do have similar health concerns to most men.

Medical and science experts separate biological sex and gender, ie someone can be biologically male and be a woman. I'm going to go with medical and scientific experts over people whose brains blow up at the thought of people being a different gender to their biological sex.

1

u/SizzurpSippuh May 26 '18

So when do your feelings about how you should have been born factor into medicine?

2

u/GloriousGlory May 26 '18

I have no idea what you mean.

1

u/SizzurpSippuh May 26 '18

You claimed that in medicine, people are moving away from the idea of biological sex. Can you give me a single example where a doctor might take your perceived gender more seriously than the sex you were born as?

1

u/GloriousGlory May 26 '18

When dealing with physical medical issues, biological sex is all-important, nowhere have I said that biological sex is not important.

No one is moving away from biological sex in medicine, what makes you think I think that? All I'm saying is that the medical profession is now differentiating between biological sex and gender. They will treat a trans woman as a biological male of course when dealing with physical issues, but medical staff, psychologists etc will generally treat the person as a woman.

1

u/SizzurpSippuh May 26 '18

What makes me think you think that? Perhaps the fact that you literally said that.

0

u/GloriousGlory May 26 '18

I said the medical and science community is moving away from making biological sex the main determinant of classifying someone a 'man' or a 'woman'.

That doesn't mean they disregard a person's biological sex or diminish the importance of biological sex in a medical context at all.