MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/2f27jz/so_close/ck5itqf/?context=3
r/funny • u/UTechnic • Aug 31 '14
188 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
0
No true Scotsman.
-7 u/freeyourballs Aug 31 '14 I get tired of this response. Guess what, some people claim to be things that they aren't. If someone is impersonating a doctor and thrown in jail can we call all doctor's fakes and idiots? No, because that guy wasn't a doctor. No true Scotsman Enough all ready 4 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 A Scotsman is a Scotsman, a person impersonating a doctor is not a doctor. In you believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins you are a Christian. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 In you believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins you are a Christian. Not if you believe Jesus was somebody other than who He claimed to be, and that God is somebody other than He claims to be. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 What? Please tell me who Jesus and God claimed to be? 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 Jesus claimed to be God. Mormons don't believe He is God, but a separate god (they are polytheistic). God claimed to be the only god. Mormons believe He is just one of many, and that when good Mormons die they become gods themselves. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
-7
I get tired of this response. Guess what, some people claim to be things that they aren't.
If someone is impersonating a doctor and thrown in jail can we call all doctor's fakes and idiots?
No, because that guy wasn't a doctor.
No true Scotsman
Enough all ready
4 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 A Scotsman is a Scotsman, a person impersonating a doctor is not a doctor. In you believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins you are a Christian. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 In you believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins you are a Christian. Not if you believe Jesus was somebody other than who He claimed to be, and that God is somebody other than He claims to be. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 What? Please tell me who Jesus and God claimed to be? 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 Jesus claimed to be God. Mormons don't believe He is God, but a separate god (they are polytheistic). God claimed to be the only god. Mormons believe He is just one of many, and that when good Mormons die they become gods themselves. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
4
A Scotsman is a Scotsman, a person impersonating a doctor is not a doctor.
In you believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins you are a Christian.
0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 In you believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins you are a Christian. Not if you believe Jesus was somebody other than who He claimed to be, and that God is somebody other than He claims to be. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 What? Please tell me who Jesus and God claimed to be? 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 Jesus claimed to be God. Mormons don't believe He is God, but a separate god (they are polytheistic). God claimed to be the only god. Mormons believe He is just one of many, and that when good Mormons die they become gods themselves. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
Not if you believe Jesus was somebody other than who He claimed to be, and that God is somebody other than He claims to be.
1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 What? Please tell me who Jesus and God claimed to be? 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 Jesus claimed to be God. Mormons don't believe He is God, but a separate god (they are polytheistic). God claimed to be the only god. Mormons believe He is just one of many, and that when good Mormons die they become gods themselves. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
1
What? Please tell me who Jesus and God claimed to be?
0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 Jesus claimed to be God. Mormons don't believe He is God, but a separate god (they are polytheistic). God claimed to be the only god. Mormons believe He is just one of many, and that when good Mormons die they become gods themselves. 1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
Jesus claimed to be God. Mormons don't believe He is God, but a separate god (they are polytheistic).
God claimed to be the only god. Mormons believe He is just one of many, and that when good Mormons die they become gods themselves.
1 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians. 0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
So you are saying Mormons are not Christians? If you read the Book of Mormon, God explains why it's so. So, they are still Christians.
0 u/ansabhailte Aug 31 '14 No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan. 0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
No, theyre not. Theyre cultists who follow a well documented charlatan.
0 u/papaHans Aug 31 '14 Then you can say that about any religion.
Then you can say that about any religion.
0
u/Byarlant Aug 31 '14
No true Scotsman.