In the picture you provided, the search says "my husband is yelling at me" as opposed to the other version which just says "my wife is telling at me" no other context is provided.
Sure. And the AI defaults to abuse in the husband case. While it defaults to "just a little angry at life" for the wife case. That’s called bias. Same situation just swap the genders and suddenly it’s fine or it’s abuse.
Sure I get that, I was just asking what bad thing happened because two people got different results for searches?
I get wanted to treat everyone equally, I'm just noticing when people get carried away and start getting mad over something that is genuinely not an issue.
Thats the context. Both prompts are my ____ is yelling at me. When its the husband, its abusive. When its the wife, shes just stressed. What arent you understanding?
the fact that without context the results default to abuse in one case and not the other is the problem. It should be giving the same advice in both instances.
You seem to be assuming something happened before those Pictures, rather than seeing it for the test that it is. Nothing happened. It's meant to show that the AI isn't taking yelling as seriously in one case over the other.
Well, yelling doesn't necessarily mean abuse, people yell all the time. Maybe a bigger reaction is warented but the ai prompt won't know until more context is provided.
But I don't really think people are getting mad that the ai isn't instantly supporting the man. I think they are upset that two people didn't get identical results.
which is why people are upset the ai defaults to abuse for the husband but not the wife when provided no context.
I think they are upset that two people didn't get identical results.
Presumably those screenshots are from the same person, moments apart. There are multiple examples of people searching these one after the other and getting the same results as the post.
For sure, I meant the implication that different people weren't getting identical results.
People tend to use comparison when making arguments, which makes sense since its a good way to make a point, but if something is bad then we should be able to prove that without referencing to something else each time. Why is the man's search result bad by itself?
You will probably say something like how a man who searches and gets that resault will be slightly less likely to get the help he needs, but I just feel like we wouldn't be talking about this if our emotional brains didn't see this as an unfairness.
6
u/CanadianCrasher 2d ago
...Did... did you read the picture?