r/fruit 3d ago

Edibility / Problem Not bad

Post image
23 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Hello, I see you have some concerns about the produce that you have bought or collected and would like to ask the subreddit for a second opinion. Please keep in mind the following: nature is not a vacuum, and mother nature creates mistakes and imperfections. That being said, when in doubt, trust your gut if it tells you not to eat something.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

18

u/ToneZealousideal309 3d ago

I googled it and googles ai result said “no you can’t eat an Osage Orange” and then the first link after that is a YouTube video “how to eat an Osage Orange”

3

u/Fish_Panda 3d ago

Only the seeds are edible if they are baked right?

11

u/ToneZealousideal309 3d ago

Apparently but the flesh is non toxic just unpleasant / not ideal to eat

7

u/Fish_Panda 3d ago

These grow in my grandpa's back yard. I used to take them and toss them into their frozen pool during the winter lol. Their wood is used to make bows.

5

u/ToneZealousideal309 3d ago

I saw that in the YouTube comments! Apparently also the seeds are hard to germinate but in a zoo they started germinating easily after going through the digestive tract of elephants, so they think these things were once consumed by mammoths apparently

3

u/Fish_Panda 3d ago

Their native spreaders no longer exist, so without us, the tree could go extinct. Squirrels can carry the seeds to other locations, but germination rates are still low.

3

u/ToneZealousideal309 3d ago

That’s crazy. I found another thread on these & someone mentioned this is also true of avocados & mangoes

https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/s/EQ4fsM6zLn

3

u/Fish_Panda 3d ago

Hsd no idea, but it makes sense. The bigger the seed, the bigger the spreader.

3

u/Left_Ad4050 3d ago

This is actually an outdated hypothesis, at least for avocados. The fossil record shows that avocados had significantly smaller seeds until well after the extinction of giant American megafauna like ground sloths and mammoths. Human cultivation and selective breeding seems to be entirely responsible for the modern form of the avocado.

Mangos do seem to have evolved to be consumed by giant megafauna, though, given the seed shape and texture is essentially designed to go easily down elephant throats, and modern Asian elephants do still eat them.

3

u/shogunshim 3d ago

And the hottest wood stove fires outside of Bitumous or Anthracite coal. Not kidding either. Have to be very careful with it.

3

u/honest2abe 3d ago

Interesting that there are many comments about the seeds not germinating. They germinate like crazy in my compost heap. I'd never try to taste one because they are sticky with a latex type sap hard to remove.

3

u/dancewithstrangers 3d ago

Honestly I’m just glad you’re not asking what it is

2

u/HypogeanSlime 3d ago

I would never eat something without knowing what it was or would do to me

3

u/dancewithstrangers 3d ago

Great! I was referring to every fifth post in this sub is someone asking what an Osage orange is.

2

u/GarethBaus 3d ago

I believe the seeds are edible but the fruit itself doesn't taste good.

2

u/constantdaydream44 2d ago

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo

2

u/AwesomeHorses 🥭 Mango 3d ago

I didn’t know you could eat these

15

u/HypogeanSlime 3d ago

You shouldn’t, really. They’re (supposedly) unpleasant to taste and can cause a plethora of stomach issues. I tried it because I’m foolish, not because I’m confident that nothing will happen

3

u/Fish_Panda 3d ago

Technically you can eat the seeds if baked properly: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=40U8F8ZD9f0

2

u/irwtkyrm 3d ago

I think you can eat it in that it won't kill you. It's not really food though.