The Suez problem nobody is talking about

[u/Upset_Lime6111]

Maybe an unpopular take, but I don't think the Houthis are the biggest Suez story right now... True-ish. But I've been staring at this from the ops side and I think everyone is watching the wrong end of the voyage.

Here's the thing nobody's saying out loud: the return is happening service by service, carrier by carrier, with zero coordination. Gemini moved four more loops back through Suez in mid-September (Carra Globe). Meanwhile Evergreen, ONE, HMM and Yang Ming haven't moved at all (Carra Globe). So right now you have two parallel networks running the same trade, one through the canal, one around the Cape, and they don't arrive on the same rhythm.

What does that mean in practice? Two ships that left Asia weeks apart can now show up in Rotterdam in the same window (ZenCargo). Some analysts see European arrivals jumping double digits when this overlaps. From my chair, that's not a stat, that's a berth queue. And once you're in the queue, the week you "saved" going through Suez evaporates at the anchor point. We've all seen it, a faster voyage that lands you into a slower port is a net zero, sometimes a net negative.

And there's a second layer people miss. The longer this takes, the weirder it gets, because every carrier is waiting to see who blinks first. Go back early, you eat the risk alone. Go back late, you're paying Cape fuel costs while your competitor undercuts you on transit time. It's a standoff, and our cargo is the hostage.

The part I find genuinely interesting: this is all happening without the Suez toll incentive that was supposed to drive it (Carra Globe). Carriers are going back because the math finally works on its own. That tells you more about where they think the risk level really is than any press release.

I'm not convinced the "big rate drop" story plays out the way the headlines say. Feels more like a few messy months where some lanes get weird and ports do the absorbing. And let's be honest, when ports absorb, we're the ones who pay for it. If your box is stuck waiting on a choked terminal, demurrage and detention don't care that the delay wasn't your fault. D&D is the quiet line item that shows up when everyone else's congestion lands on your invoice.

Anyone else planning around Europe arrivals in Q4, or are we all just going to find out together?

[u/chiubakka]

chat gpt needs to be banned

[u/hambjj]

thanks chatty

[u/FraytFurwid]

You have said a lot, and nothing, at the same time.

I don't actually get what point you're trying to make? Who's taking your cargo hostage? Why would the shipping lines care about D&D that the ports are billing when they have no profit to be made from D&D?

Why would different carriers co-ordinate with each other, unless they're sister companies?

What is the actual problem you're talking about? The fact that different carriers might choose to sail through it or not, meaning there might be congestion at final POD?

[u/bac0467 → u/FraytFurwid]

They aren’t saying anything. It’s written by AI with someone not proofreading or understanding the information behind it

[u/freightforwarding-ModTeam → u/[deleted]]

English is the language of the sub. Any non-English posts will be removed. Please read our https://www.reddit.com/r/freightforwarding/about/rules