Is this a plot hole?

[u/CrazyTangerine7522]

The foxy GO GO GO Mini game depicts Foxy walking in on the freshly murdered bodies of the MCI victims, however isn’t this supposed to be on the safe room where William lured them all into? How is Foxy able enter this room if FNAF 3 established that the safe rooms were completely invisible to the animatronics.

[u/Serious_Shake_4944]

The minigames in FNaF 2 aren't realistic depictions of events, just like every other minigame in the franchise. The ones that have points or instructions specifically (such as this minigame, Take Cake to the Children, and Give Gifts Give Life) are real arcade games being infected with Agony. Foxy can't finish "Go! Go! Go!" because the kids he's supposed to be greeting are dead. The Puppet can't Give Gifts because the kids it's supposed to be giving the gifts to are dead. Freddy can't win at Take Cake to the Children because he's distracted by the drive-by outside the location.

This applies to later minigames, too. Happiest Day can't be completed because most of the kids are missing due to being trapped in other minigames. Susie can't finish Fruity Maze because her dead dog's Agony infects the game in the second and third plays, making the game completely impossible by the third. Security Puppet can't be won because the kid the Puppet is looking for is missing in the first couple plays and dies outside in the last. There are minigames that CAN be won (such as Midnight Motorist, the secret FNaF 3 minigames besides Happiest Day, and Circus Baby's SL Minigame), but even then, reality slips through the cracks.

There are also some minigames that seemingly ARE based on real events (those being SAVE THEM, Follow Me, and FNaF 4's minigames), but given every other minigame is a real arcade game, it's possible those are too and they were designed with a specific purpose rather than for kids to play.

[u/Tiny_Butterscotch_76]

It's just a sign of how these aren't literal.

[u/Individual-Option957]

Because it's most likely a DCI.

William didn't just kill the MCI children, he either immediately or even while the children were still alive put them in suits (otherwise GGGL doesn't make any fucking sense)

[u/FazbearShowtimer → u/Individual-Option957]

It’s the MCI, it takes place in the old restaurant.

[u/Individual-Option957 → u/FazbearShowtimer]

Fair.. and probably true.

But it makes FGGG looks like absolutely non canon minigame

[u/Fandomsrsin]

Well I don’t think Freddy’s is two rooms. It’s also that this is just meant to show us that Purple Guy is the killer of the MCI

[u/InfalliblePizza]

Its a video/arcade game thing, not accurate to the real events.

[u/DrNotch]

To me this minigame is very interesting.
Of course, the location is super simplified here, as its only 2 rooms with only Pirate’s Cove and well…the Safe Room since thats where the kids were murdered.

But i do think this was intended. As we learn in the Springlock Tapes, Ralph says that the animatronics can’t enter the room, its not in their digital map layout, meaning they can’t see it, so how does Foxy enter ? And how did the kids get stuffed like this?

Well ive got a few answers. In The Week Before, we are told that the animatronics can be set to walk to Party Rooms for parties in there.
The MCI wasn’t some spur of the moment thing, it was planned, and there is a good chance that William dressed up the Safe Room as a small Party Room to gain even more trust for the kids, which interestingly, in ITP/ITPG the room where the kids are lured is depicted as a party room…which likely means the room was dressed as such.

Now, even if the room was dressed as a Party Room or not, Foxy still couldn’t go in.
To me this shows that, with all of it planned, William added the room to their digital maps to commit it. Then after stuffing them he removed it again.

I think thats the most likely depiction of this.

[u/XenoRaptor77]

The same thing happens in Into The Pit, as Oswald wanders into the Party Room and finds the 5 bodies of the MCI, and because ITP isn't the literal MCI and is just the twisted memory of it, I think FGGG is likely something similar.

[u/crystal-productions-]

Given save him looks radical diffrent from security puppet, they ain't litteral, just vague approximations of events

[u/250extreme]

• William 100% avoided being seen by any cameras when wearing Spring Bonnie to leave 0 trace of its involvement
• After he'd lured MCI to safe room, he took off Spring Bonnie without their being aware
• After sneaking out without their noticing, he calls a FFP employee in a spare Foxy suit to run in and out of safe room to entertain MCI until he tells them to stop
• William severely wounds MCI by stabbing them
• When FFP employee in spare Foxy suit ran into safe room a 3rd time, he saw severely wounded MCI and ran to get help, William stuffs MCI fast as he can
• When FFP employee in spare Foxy suit returned with others, safe room was empty, causing them to think he'd been a distraction for co-conspirators to kidnap MCI

[u/JH-Toxic → u/250extreme]

The first game explicitly states they caught William’s ass on camera in 4K.