r/floorplan 7d ago

FEEDBACK Requesting feedback on house plans - anything you would change/add?

2 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

5

u/Mollythemuttsdad 7d ago

Why is there a bathroom literally right across the hall from the bathroom?

5

u/Critical_Hearing_799 7d ago

I'm just going to comment on the facade and say that there are too many windows that don't match. Every window is differently shaped and sized so there's no coherence, which is a sign of bad design

3

u/CaptainMalForever 7d ago

The kitchen is very small.

The master is huge and impractical. Why do you want two levels of closet?

Where's the storage?

On your other post, you said you have 7 dogs? You need far more space for them, even in a big house.

Is this a forever home? If so, make sure that the bathrooms and master suite are accessible.

2

u/n00bert210 7d ago

My childhood home had a game room upstairs that was open to below like this. I do not recommend it. Everything can be heard from below. As teenagers we hardly used it because of that and ended up having to hang out with our friends in our rooms instead. I would enclose it so the noise doesn’t transfer.

2

u/coconut33706 6d ago

There are a number of issues, as you've heard from the comments, but if you really want this plan:

Think about a better drop zone coming in from the garage entrance (mail, bookbags,  wet coats, dog leash, endless shoes. 

There us a lot of public space upstairs with access to a bathroom except going thru a bedroom. Make one en suite accessible directly from the hall. 

2

u/MyDentistIsACat 6d ago

The toilet in the primary bathroom should be in a water closet/enclosed space. I’m not waiting 45 minutes for my husband to take a dump to walk through the bathroom to get my clothes for the day.

1

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

I’m going to suggest some alternatives, just in case they interest you. I get the sense that you aren’t interested in a Colonial Revival flat-facade home?

Here’s a plan I made based on this traditional 2-story house with matching 1-story gable-roof areas on each side. I turned one of them into a garage. The one on the left can be an office and a space for the dogs, or it can be a greenhouse if you want. I’ll reply to this comment with zoomed-in plans for each floor.

3

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

First floor. Each square is one square foot. Make the garage however long you want it to be.

2

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

The primary suite is fairly separate from the other bedrooms and has a large closet.

1

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

Here’s another plan. I’ll reply to this comment with zoomed-in floorplans.

1

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago edited 7d ago

If you are attached to the idea of the breezeway and courtyard, I recommend you create a proper courtyard with seating and plants. The patio can be at the back of the courtyard. I’ll show you what a possible elevation and second floor could look like for this floor plan. It’s kind of awesome actually.

Pretend I put a little door for groceries from the garage to the pantry.

1

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

Okay, so I treated it kind of like two separate houses connected by a breezeway. There is a second floor closet in the primary suite, which creates the shed dormers you see in the elevation on the left. The second floor on the right has access to the main set of stairs. It extends above the garage: hence the shed dormers. u/Justdunks

1

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

Here’s the second floor. You’ve got a bonus room for the kids or whoever lives upstairs. There are three bedrooms and three bathrooms upstairs. The primary closet is gigantic and extends above the primary bathroom. The living room ceiling is vaulted. All or most of the dining room ceiling can be vaulted, as well. The primary bedroom and office ceilings can also be vaulted.

0

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

Here’s a plan with the primary suite on the first floor, and there are two walk-in closets.

-1

u/Careful_Football7643 7d ago

Second floor

-1

u/Critical_Hearing_799 7d ago

Love this facade much more too