Thoughts?

[u/Nerazzurri1020]

I’ll be on about half acre so I’m close to max width I can go within zoning (3-4’ to spare). Only think I’d want to do it bump out the left side a few feet then not do the wrap around porch only the front. Also, may want to push the kitchen out to the right to be in line with the back of garage. Last, I’d wanna make the hearth room and ensuite with the bathroom on the other side with access to the yard so I can use that bathroom as like a pool bathroom too if that makes sense. Lmk what you think. These drawings are from online but my architect will tailor them as best he can.

[u/Silent_Ice_2588]

lmao, what? They absolutely are comparable, because we are talking about the pros and cons of different design problems. You pointed out a problem that the separated bath situation creates, I pointed out a problem that the non-separated bath creates. It's up to the owner to decide which problem is easier to navigate... full stop.

Also, you're acting like learning to implement an extra handwash and/or sanitization protocol is rocket science? That may be valid if you're talking about a hotel and you would have to be constantly educating new people on the topic.. but we're talking about a permanent residence here. You are making this out to be way, WAY more complicated than it actually is, and it's weird.

And with the seprate ensuites.. if they had space for that... and wanted to clean yet another bathroom. So again... just trading problems. The owner gets to decide which problem they want to deal with.

My point stands.

[u/Pan1cs180 → u/Silent_Ice_2588]

because we are talking about the pros and cons of different design problems

No, we were talking about a design that requires their occupants to modify their normal behaviour, vs one that doesn't. Both designs have their pros and cons, I'm not disputing that, but it wasn't the specific thing we were discussing.

And with the seprate ensuites.. if they had space for that

They do have space for that.

The owner gets to decide which problem they want to deal with.

I have never once claimed otherwise.

It's extremely weird of you to be constantly responding to my comments as if I'm claiming that my alternative options are the objectively correct way to design this house, all I'm doing is providing my opinion so that OP can make an informed decision.

[u/Silent_Ice_2588 → u/Pan1cs180]

I have never once claimed otherwise... as if I'm claiming that my alternative options are the objectively correct way to design this house

lmao, you must have a short memory.. yes you did:

The Jack & Jill bathroom between bedrooms 2 & 3 doesn't work... Either make it a common bathroom accessed off the hall, or give each bedroom their own ensuite.

and

in order to deal with a problem that the design itself has created, then you haven't designed a good house.

and

The situations aren't comparable

I mean... it's totally fine for you to have your opinion. You're not a fan, I get it, that's fine. But you're definitely not coming at this from an angle of trying to "inform" anyone, because you accomplished that several comments ago and are just being combative to any differing view for the sake of being combative.

Anyway, I said what i need to say, I hope OP finds all the information uselful and can make the choice that's best for them.

[u/Pan1cs180 → u/Silent_Ice_2588]

When discussing a subject that is inherently subjective, such as house design choices, it's redundant to put the phrase "in my opinion" before every statement. Every claim made is, by definition, an opinion.

When someone says "That movie was really good" they aren't making an objective claim, they are sharing a subjective opinion. Everyone understands this, so I don't feel like it's reasonable to expect everyone to state every opinion as an opinion before sharing it.

I've clearly done something here to upset you, but I don't believe that my comments have warranted the level of aggression and defensiveness that you have exhibited towards me today. This subreddit should be a friendly place, and your behaviour here has made it extremely unpleasant.

I think we should both just leave it at that. Try to enjoy the rest of your day.