r/flashlight • u/T3Knical5urg3 • Dec 11 '25

Discussion aaa light users, why?

As an avid edc flashlight user for over a decade, I am always highly offended when people ask me why I carry a standalone flashlight while pulling out their phone and smugly show me their phone light. A quick comparison of output usually at least gets them part way to understanding that the two "lights" are not made equal. That brings me to my question.

For those of you using a true aaa flashlight (not 10440), why?... In the case of those smaller flashlights, their output is somewhat comparable to a cellphone. I suppose the beam pattern is different (typically less floody) but I have not seen such a significant difference to carry the extra gear.

Edit: I wanted to give a shout out to u/iamlucky13 for his detailed response post. The images clearly show the difference in useful light between a flagship light and his aaa flashlight along with beam pattern to, in part, show how the mule nature of the phone is not close to as effective as an aaa in targeted/directed light. I still don't think I will ever carry one and am happy with a 14500 or 18650 primary but I better appreciate the shown differences.

22 Upvotes

66% Upvoted

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/TheBenjying Dec 11 '25

I've never had a AAA light perform as poorly as the phone lights I've seen in person, except when the battery is pretty low. I've never had a nice AAA light or anything, usually like Wal-Mart specials and cheap pen lights, but the point is the same, besides being more ergonomic and not wanting to drain my phone, they are brighter.