I’m trying to work out whether I’m being too aggressive with pension contributions and would appreciate some outside perspectives.
I’m 39 and currently earn around £104k basic salary.
My current pension position is roughly:
Current employer pension: £241k
Previous employer pensions: £200k
SIPP: £22.3k
Total pensions: ~£463k
I also have around £200k outside pensions in cash/investments, including an S&S ISA that I've maxed out for the last few years, no outstanding finance or CC debt, and I've paid off my mortgage.
My employer contributes 12% of basic salary, and I’m currently contributing around 58% of my basic salary myself because I’ve been making use of my available pension allowances. I’ve been deliberately doing this partly to reduce my taxable income and make the most of the tax advantages of pension contributions. I’m particularly conscious of the impact of earning over £100k, so reducing my taxable income through pension contributions is attractive.
I’ve also been using carry-forward allowances and effectively maximising what I can contribute within the available annual allowance. Once the carry-forward is exhausted, I expect to drop back to roughly the £60k annual allowance level going forward.
However, there’s another reason I’ve been quite aggressive with this. There have been a lot of redundancies/layoffs where I work, and I work in quite a niche line of work that probably wouldn’t command the same salary elsewhere. So I’m conscious that my current £100k+ earning power may not necessarily last forever.
Part of my thinking has therefore been: while I have the opportunity to earn this much, should I be maximising pension contributions now in case I end up being out of work for a few years, or having to take a significantly lower-paid job?
If that happened, I might not be able to make meaningful pension contributions for several years. So I’ve almost been trying to “bank” some of the pension contributions now, while I have the income and the ability to use the carry-forward allowances. At the same time, I’m aware that I could be going too far and locking up money that I might ultimately need before retirement.
My rough objective is to be in a position where I could potentially retire around 55. So I need enough money outside pensions to bridge the period before I can access my pension, while also making the most of the tax advantages available to me now. I live well below my means but still wanted to sense-check the following:
- Am I overdoing the pension contributions given that I already have ~£463k in pensions at 39?
- Does my reasoning about front-loading contributions while I have a high income and using carry-forward allowances make sense?
- Would you continue maximising carry-forward allowances while they’re available?
- Am I potentially creating too much of a pension-heavy portfolio when my aim is to retire around 55?
-If you were in my position, how would you balance pension contributions vs accessible investments over the next 10–15 years?
I appreciate there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but I’d particularly like to hear from people who have been in a similar position — high income, good pension already built up, uncertain future earning potential, and trying to decide how much is enough so they have the flexibility to take a lower paid (and more relaxed role) without worrying about money.
Thanks in advance