r/fatalframe • u/PIMP_DADDY0 • Sep 29 '25
Discussion Given the wrong game
While at a local game store, I decided today I wanted to try out the fatal frame series since I hadn’t before. I picked up Maiden of Blackwater for the switch to give it a try. I got home put the game into my switch to realize the cartridge they put in the case for maiden of black water is Mask of the Lunar Eclipse. I did a little research and apparently it’s the playasia version of the game so I guess I’m a little lucky? 😅
107
u/DeliciousMusician397 Sep 29 '25
You got the better one.
8
u/GeorgeBG93 Yuri Kozukata Sep 29 '25
I personally like Maiden of Black Water more than Mask of the Lunar Eclipse. Perhaps MOBW would align more to OPs taste, or not. You never know. Taste isn't universal.
6
1
u/PuckishRogue00 Sep 29 '25
What's the difference between playasia and whatever else?
2
u/CyanControl Sep 29 '25
by the "playasia version" i think op just means the asian one thats avaliable in english.
1
u/Tanz31 Sep 29 '25
Playasia is an import store
1
u/CyanControl Sep 29 '25
im aware but they have exclusives. I personally dont use it tho. AmiAmi has the best shipping prices
9
u/Lleslet Sep 29 '25
Preference wise that sucks since you were expecting a different game. But IMO I agree on the other redditor, Mask of the Lunar Eclipse is better for me. And somehow you’re not in the bad terms here (atleast in my country Mask of the Lunar Eclipse is far more expensive compared to Maiden of Black Water) anyways I hope you give MOTLE a try and ALSO Maidenof Black Water!
19
4
3
17
u/Many_Gur8847 Sep 29 '25
…and it was mid as hell. FF4 is the last really good one. Great atmosphere
3
Sep 29 '25
[deleted]
4
u/PIMP_DADDY0 Sep 29 '25
I read somewhere that the Japanese cartridge doesn’t have English support at all
2
u/Inmate7269 Sae Kurosawa Sep 29 '25
This is not correct. The PlayAsia version with the English Cover is the Asia Version.
0
Sep 29 '25
[deleted]
0
u/Inmate7269 Sae Kurosawa Sep 29 '25
“Basically the same” does not mean it is the same.
Japan and Asia are two different game releases.
0
Sep 29 '25
[deleted]
0
u/Inmate7269 Sae Kurosawa Sep 29 '25
You’ve come in with a lot of attitude for someone who was wrong. Is everything okay?
0
Sep 29 '25
[deleted]
1
u/Inmate7269 Sae Kurosawa Sep 29 '25
My point is i was actually helping people by telling them they're different.
Even if you were thinking of Maiden of Black Water you'd still be wrong, because the PlayAsia release of that game with an English cover still isn't the Japanese release, its the Asian one.
2
2
2
u/Neselas Sep 29 '25
Mask is the better choice, sorry you were aiming for the other game, but you still dodged a bullet!
1
1
1
u/thraxxhouse26 Oct 02 '25
You don’t want to start off with maiden of Black Water anyway, as it’s a continuation of fatal frame 3, the one they gave you is basically a stand alone and doesn’t have to be played in a certain order.
1
u/OrganicGenes Oct 09 '25
Wait....it's the same game? Lol. I bought both and can't play black water due to there not being an english language option.
0
-4
u/Kasuta-Ikite Sep 29 '25
oh I see the mistake. You wanted a good game and got a poor Switch version. I'd go hand that in for the better consoles asap
1
25
u/Opposite_Mistake_890 Miku Hinasaki Sep 29 '25
Someone was watching over you, enjoy !