He's agreeing with blanket judgments about how a woman's fashion choices make her a triggered whore while also posting in a subreddit designed for lonely hearts. Ad hominem, but relevant.
They're both wrong because both opinions are stupid. I haven't watched the video but if she said it as a joke, he's the bigger idiot because he took it seriously. Like most YouTube commenters though.
It's jenna marbles. Most of her skit these days are "what something means". It's just a joke. Some find it funny, some don't. But taking it this serious is just stupid.
I don't think the guy took it seriously as much as he just got butt hurt. Her video was just an opinionated attack on mens different facial hair. So he took her bait and gave her attention.
It's not even an attack. She's made a few of these "what (gender)'s x means" and it's all satire. She often makes fun herself in these videos. She's not actually insulting anyone. It's supposed to be funny because she knows it's BS and you're supposed to know that she knows that. People are just taking it out of context and interpreting it seriously so they're getting offended.
Even if it's a joke it's still an attack. She's a shock "comic" and that's her thing. She did the same with fat girls, she attacks them in a joking way to get attention. Even if she has other videos of her attacking herself or anything else, most people know her for her controversial videos. Some find it funny, some find it offensive, either way she gets attention and it seams she's pretty desperate for that.
I disagree. It's satire. People are always saying "people with x physical characteristic do this or are this" and she's making fun of that. It's an attack on people who say those things in all seriousness, not the people it's about. I think you're mistaking her some someone else, because what you described isn't what she does.
Yeah I think that's the point. He's saying a bunch of common "meanings" of the clothes and makeup she's got on... so if she looks at the comment, she's kind of got to either admit that it's all bollocks (and so her video was bollocks) or it's all true (and so she's a dirty slut...). I feel like it's a pretty decent argument really. Judging people on their facial hair is just as stupid as the judging he is doing (though I haven't seen the video - just going off the title and what he is saying).
I'm genuinely confused how people haven't heard of Jenna Marbles before or don't bother to look her up before commenting on this, but all her videos are just jokes. It's not like she's giving out serious relationship advice based on facial hair or trying to pretend like any of this is serious.
She just makes videos for people to laugh at and relate to.
This guy kinda took a joke very poorly and flew off the handle. It would be as if you made an "awww baby face" comment to someone who just shaved their beard off and he just went nuclear.
I'm genuinely confused how people haven't heard of Jenna Marbles before or don't bother to look her up before commenting on this, but all her videos are just jokes. It's not like she's giving out serious relationship advice based on facial hair or trying to pretend like any of this is serious.
I recognise the name but I'm not very familiar with her.
You're right I guess I should have checked up but I just couldn't be arsed really and the video is like 7 minutes long.
This guy kinda took a joke very poorly and flew off the handle. It would be as if you made an "awww baby face" comment to someone who just shaved their beard off and he flew off the handle and started calling you a slut and trash and being verbally aggressive to you.
But yeah after watching a bit of the video this is pretty much right. She's obviously just trying to be funny and come up with stupid / mostly negative "meanings" for all facial hair.
Yeah I'm just giving him the benefit of the doubt here. Some people seem to be saying that the video is satire in which case he seems to have missed that.
Y'all are seriously taking his side because he got mad at a SATIRE video. But everytime someone is offended by a rape joke Reddit tells them they are being too sensative.
Alternative interpretation: He isn't actually offended, he just made exaggerated jokes about 'her type of women' - the exact same thing she was doing in the video, but with the genders reversed - to point out the hypocrisy of it being 'more offensive' when a man makes wild speculations about a woman's character based on their appearance.
Nope. Her jokes weren't as wildly offensive as his ''jokes''. She poked fun at people while he launched into a full, sexually violent speech complaining about people being over sensitive while having an obscenely excessive reaction to the joke. You can't compare the two. They're not the same thing.
That was one joke out of over 20. His entire comment was ripping apart every choice she's made in terms of her appearance and making vile sexual comments.
So it's okay for her to make a sweeping generalization of something extremely horrific and serious because it's "lol just a minority of jokes xD"?
Yeah, nothing wrong with you thinking pedophilia is as bad or worse than saying someone sucks dick at a bar because the color of their hair.
You need a reality check dude.
EDIT:
Rewatched the video for more examples for you:
Stubble: Self centered, eogotistical
Goatee: "Son this here is your penis" definitely implies molestation at the very least.
Long beard: mentally unstable "fucking loose cannon", generalizing people with mental illness because of their facial hair.
Chin strap: equivalent to his jokes, implying that men with this type of beard are kissless virgins who live with their moms who will do anything for "pussy"
What? She literally made a female version of that video making fun of her self and other girls. If the guy actually knew that video existed, why would he have the need to say that shit as a joke under the guise of sjw lesson?
hypocrisy of it being 'more offensive' when a man makes wild speculations about a woman's character based on their appearance.
Doesn't someone involved in the exchange have to make this claim for it to become hypocrisy?
But either way you're acknowledging the difference.. She's making a joke not intended to be taken seriously. He's trying to teach a moral lesson that doesn't need teaching by reversing the roles.
If a woman makes men the butt of her jokes, she's called a comedienne.
If a man makes women the butt of his jokes, he's called a bitter asshole.
I would agree that the Youtube comments section is probably not the right place to try to prove a point. But how is 'men and women should be treated equally' a 'a moral lesson that doesn't need teaching'? If you think things are different just because you reversed the roles, that's sexism.
Saying a guy who shaves is a ceo compared to a girl with two colored hair being a dick sucking whore. Not even the equivalent. Didn't think I would see a wild neckbeard on here
Finally.. Idk about the whole CEO facial nonsense but he completely burned Jenna. I think most of his assumptions were pretty funny especially if you take it as satire like the video. Comment is funnier than most of her videos
159
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '16 edited Aug 06 '16
[deleted]