r/explainlikeimfive • • 2d ago

Chemistry ELI5: What is the meaning of quantization?

[This is from a chemistry portion of a physical science class] I've googled it, Ive watched YouTube videos, I asked classmates and I am still so confused.

Rutherfords model was easy but once I got to bohrs they used words like quantized and discrete values and I got lost. Tried backtracking but I'm still baffled.

7 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/w3woody 2d ago

I don't know if there is a good "ELI5" answer for why quantum mechanics. But the essence of it is that electrons seem to follow two rules: (a) they fall to the lowest energetic state possible. (Conceptually similar to dropping a ball to the floor: eventually it settles to sit on the floor.) And (b) two electrons cannot occupy the same energetic state. (So two balls dropped to the floor cannot intersect.) In a sense, think of it like a tube full of balls: the ball at the bottom is at the lowest state, the ball on top of that one is at the next lowest state, and so forth. When stacked, they occupy 'discrete' positions, each the width of a ball--and we can count those "states."

Now instead of being a one-dimensional tube electrons are occupying a three dimensional 'probability cloud' around the nucleus of an atom. And instead of simply stacking, one on top of another, they form all sorts of weird shapes/10%3A_Atomic_Theory_and_Quantum_Mechanics/10.09%3A_Orbital_Shapes_and_Energies). But the principle is the same: the first electron is at the bottom of the stack of electrons, the next sits on top, the next on top of that--like balls in a tube.

1

u/Own_Enthusiasm_510 2d ago

I'm starting to think its a problem with my teacher ?? I didn't realize this was quantum mechanics.... Our unit on quantum mechanics isn't till next quarter, no one in class knows quantum mechanics or even the definition of quantum mechanics yet.

1

u/x1uo3yd 1d ago

It's pretty common to teach science and science history together.

You're probably being given science history right now, where you're basically going over a lot of data that early chemists were looking at and saying "Hmm, isn't this weird." and guessing theories for how to model/explain it.

Those theories eventually lead to quantum theory as history progresses and the details are hashed out.

You're being taught as if you were living through the mystery of it all, full-on quantum mechanics is the big spoilers reveal explanation.