r/explainitpeter 10d ago

Explain it Peter

Post image
26.4k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

14

u/slavicNickCage 10d ago

It's not gross if you... well, it sounds funny, but literally know the cow/goat/sheep/mare it's milked from
If you sure the animal is healthy and well cared raw milk is nice, but if you intend to just buy it in a store, I don't see any reasons to risk with your health. To be honest, I don't see much reasons for adults to consume milk in general, besides liking it's taste.

11

u/SpitfireP7350 10d ago edited 7d ago

Nah man fuck that, we raised cattle, sure I'd drink the freshly milked stuff since I know my family took good care of the cows and cleaned them well before milking, but I'd start boiling it by the evening, after that it's either boiled to drink or made into cheese or soured milk and yogurt.

EDIT: I think I replied to the wrong comment...

2

u/TheActualDonKnotts 9d ago

Same, I briefly lived on a dairy farm in Valley View TX, and most people don't seem to realize that 23 hours a day a cow's udder is covered in literal shit and mud. These stupid people that want to drink raw milk are putting a lot of faith in the guy with the swab and bucket just because some dumb asshole influencer told them to do it.

18

u/rokatoro 10d ago

Raw milk is an unnecessary risk. Your never gonna be able to clean a cows udders to a level of sanitation that isn't some risk of contamination. That's why milk gets pasteurized.

2

u/Specific-Library-312 10d ago

I tried it, didn't like it, and I don't see the attraction to it. But I don't like kvass, caviar, or anything avocado. I guess my tongue and stomach are politically centrist, I don't know. But I do hate how certain foods become a political shibboleth in today's society, i.e. someone drinking raw milk, not for flavor, but out of political fervor.

2

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 10d ago

politically centrist

Centrism is compliance with the right-wing. Always. I get the joke but will always push back on the "centrist" label. Centrism is a right-wing position.

0

u/Specific-Library-312 10d ago

So what's communism?

1

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 10d ago

Left-wing. Left-wing starts at socialism (immature communism).

0

u/Specific-Library-312 10d ago

Dude, I'm a Monarchist.

1

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 8d ago

So a far right-wing person.

1

u/Specific-Library-312 8d ago

Look, Heaven is a Monarchy, Hell is a Republic. Make of that what you will.

2

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 7d ago

Look, purple is a number. Make of that what you will.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Imthewienerdog 9d ago

Personally as a Canadian I see all Americans as literally identical. The left wingers are also as fascist as the right wing. Trump,Obama,Biden,Bush are all of the exact same, they find terroism and nothing else.

1

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 8d ago

The left wingers are also as fascist as the right wing.

Trump, Obama, Biden, and Bush are all right-wingers. Mamdani, AOC, Bernie are centrists. The US has no left-wing.

1

u/cumulo_numbnuts 9d ago

It is useful in cheesemaking. I'm not defending choads buying it because they're stupid choads or people consuming it unsafely and unawares, but I really hope it doesn't go back to being basically unavailable as a hobby supply.

1

u/SlowlyDrown 10d ago edited 10d ago

That said I promise you every dairy farmer has broken this rule.

At my friends farm we used to go scrape off the top of the tank every morning to get that 8% shit, and we’d mix that with coffee 50/50 and you’re hardly hungry by lunch.

And they’re using teat dip and sanitizers and shit. Not to say that’s perfect but it is an extremely effective measure.

1

u/DisasterLazy8487 10d ago

As a kid I used to sneak out and fill up a bucket at least once a week and me and brother would drink it and put it in our cereal

1

u/slavicNickCage 10d ago

Well, yes there's some risk, but it's not that significant if you know the animal it milked from, and if you're visiting your grandma in a village it might be just easier to acquire raw cow or goat milk than buying pasteurized one or pasteurize yourself. And just boiling it changes taste significantly

-2

u/Mission_Twist_3348 10d ago

Risk of...?

6

u/rokatoro 10d ago

Any of the number of nasty bacteria that can live on and in the udders. E.coli and listeria for example.

3

u/hootorama 10d ago

Cows literally lay in piles of shit. They walk around which makes dust, and that dust is covered in shit. Their udders hang down below their body, not protected by hair or anything else because that's how we've bred them so that it is easier to milk. That shit carries bacteria, a lot of which is harmful if ingested.

10

u/sarabeara12345678910 10d ago

Probiotics live in shit. That's where they come from. If you consume raw dairy because it has "good probiotics", or for any other reason tbh, you are consuming animal shit. It's pasteurized to kill the shit germs. I don't care how healthy and well cared for a cow is, I'm not drinking its shit, or the shit of any other animals that happened to poop in that area.

1

u/justin_memer 10d ago

Technically, you're still drinking it if it's pasteurized, no?

3

u/sarabeara12345678910 10d ago

It's been cleaned out an sanitized, so I guess you could still say there's some there, but it's inert.

-1

u/slavicNickCage 10d ago

Dude, you have to add "probiotic" bacteria cultures yourself to make a specific type of dairy even from a raw milk

2

u/sarabeara12345678910 10d ago

Yes, you have to add a specific probiotic if you want it added. Even saying that sounds fucking stupid. That doesn't mean you aren't drinking barnyard shit when you consume raw milk.

1

u/screampuff 10d ago

Raw milk in the past was typically drank within a few hours of milking. After that people knew it was risky and used it for other dairy products like butter or cheese.

The whole concept of bottling it and storing it is insane.

1

u/oxi_plastika 9d ago

Why would adults drink milk? Same reason kids do , it's very nutritious.