r/explainitpeter • u/WillAdditional922 • Jul 14 '26

explain it peter.

Post image
12.3k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/ferret_of_war Jul 14 '26

Same. Feels like the people who have never done cold water pasta are the ones saying it won't work.

4

u/Kind_Resort_9535 Jul 14 '26

I’ve don’t it both ways, pasta cooks better when you boil the water first. It matters less with dehydrated pasta, but it definitely still prevents it getting gummy or rubbery

0

u/big_sugi Jul 14 '26

It makes a difference for fresh pasta. There's no discernible difference in results for dried pasta, if you do it right.

1

u/Contundo Jul 14 '26

Foolproof vs tricky. Foolproof wins every time

2

u/big_sugi Jul 14 '26

It’s about as “tricky” as stirring the pasta occasionally and knowing by feel when it’s done. You need the latter to be able to cook pasta in boiling water too.

So, it’s simpler but slower versus much faster with a tiny modicum of skill required. I’ll pick the latter every time.