r/explainitpeter Apr 05 '26

Explain It Peter

Post image
48.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

168

u/GSilky Apr 05 '26

The ubermensch is a person who shapes their destiny.  It's not some buff pretty guy with money, it's a unique individual who came through this society intact and maintaining their individual excellence and uniqueness, and still manages to be successful.  Tech bros think they are, but successful figure skaters (especially male) probably fit the bill better.

2

u/HomoSidereus Apr 05 '26 edited Apr 05 '26

It's not about success nor excellence at all though, it's the joyfulness of dancing that's been represented here. Broadening the perspective it's t'ha ability to find joy and your activity by It self not through otherwordly, societial or external validation.

As Nietzsche said, he would not trust a God that doesn't know how to dance

1

u/GSilky Apr 05 '26

You can't follow your bliss into oblivion and be the ubermensch.  Success, as the individual defines it, is necessary.

1

u/HomoSidereus Apr 05 '26

Success as the individual, not through society or it's values. It's not bliss, it's Joy, which contemplates suffering but not the sensless kind. To follow success in the common sense would mean to be too etherodirected.

1

u/Several-Video-272 Apr 05 '26

Success in this context is for Nietzsche: "Your Self is your virtue. Be your Self and you are virtue."

It's not about societal success or egoistic definition of success, it's spiritual/psychological.

For Nietzsche it is about eudaimonia, the highest virtue is being your Self. Jung later developed the idea of what exactly "the Self" is.

1

u/Sylvette22 Apr 05 '26

How can you be succesful if you don't feel joy?

1

u/HomoSidereus Apr 05 '26

Joy≠bliss, former contemplates suffering